Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Context

A lesson on the essential nature of context in deductive reasoning, as constructed within a conversation between a cognitive psychology researcher and a Liberian Kpelle tribal leader:


EXPERIMENTER: At one time spider went to a feast. He was told to answer this question before he could eat any food. The question is: Spider and black deer always eat together. Spider is eating. Is black deer eating?

LEADER: Were they in the bush?

EXPERIMENTER: Yes.

LEADER: They were eating together?

EXPERIMENTER: Spider and black deer always eat together. Spider is eating. Is black deer eating?

LEADER: But I was not there. How can I answer such a question?

EXPERMENTER: Can't you answer it? Even if you were not there, you can answer it.

LEADER: Ask the question again for me to hear.

EXPERMENTER: Spider and black deer always eat together. Spider is eating. Is black deer eating?

LEADER: Oh oh black dear was eating.

EXPERMENTER: Black dear was eating?

LEADER: Yes.

EXPERIMENTER: What is your reason for saying black deer was eating?

LEADER: The reason is that black deer walks about all day eating green leaves in the bush. When it rests for a while it gets up again and goes and eats in the bush.
(Cole, Gay, Glick & Sharp, 1971, P 187)



Reasoning on the basis of experience would seem to imply that one could not pursue decontextualised abstract logic too far away from the real world.

There's not just a smattering of wisdom there in terms of relevance and observation, to my mind, there's also recognition of the shared space, of a sensitivity to the deer's patterns of behaviour and the already present relationship, the dynamic, between the tribesman and the animal life.

That's cool.



Ref: HolyOak, K.J., Morrison, R.G., (2005).The Cambridge handbook of thinking and reasoning
Cambridge University Press, pg 676

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Prophets of Sophia


Yet Sophia is justified by all her children. 

Luke 7:35

You are the Bread, and You the Table, the Love
Who serves at our feast. Tou are the Leaven of 
promise among us, the Life in every seed.
God of the galaxies, of time and space,
Wisdom at play in our world,
bear our fragile, living earth
upon your wings of peace. 

Monks of Weston Priory, Vermont

Fiorenza, E.S. (1995) Chapter 5. Prophets of Sophia: Searching for Divine Wisdom. Jesus: Miriam's child, Sophia's prophet: critical issues in feminist Christology, NY: Continuum Publishing, p 131-162.


Wednesday, May 13, 2009

The Problem of Paradox

Excerpt taken from an interview on the ABC wireless show, the Philosopher's Zone, with Huw Price, author of 'Time's Arrow & Archimedes' Point', and Professor of Philosophy at Sydney University:

'Alan Saunders: There's a question here that relates I suppose to philosophy of science. I have a great deal of sympathy with Einstein because he is facing a situation which seems to mean that the prevailing theories have unacceptably paradoxical consequences, and it seems to me that it is reasonable in a situation like that, to say Well the paradoxes can't be reality, that's what a paradox is, it is something that is not describing reality. And the point about paradoxes is that they draw our attention to some failure in our understanding of the world, or our understanding of our thought processes, or whatever. Therefore, even if we haven't got the answer yet, there has to be a better answer than this. I mean that's a reasonable position for Einstein to adopt, isn't it?

Huw Price: Yes, I agree. I think it's a completely reasonable position. One of the difficulties, however, is that the issue as to whether something is actually paradoxical in the sense of a true logical paradox which simply can't be true, or whether it's merely something counter-intuitive that we have to live with, is a very difficult one. And in effect, Einstein's opponents were saying, Look, we've just discovered something new about the world.

Alan Saunders: Well when do we know that we've got something counter-intuitive that we have to live with and when do we know that we have something like Schrodinger's cat, which just shows that reality can't be like that?

Huw Price: It's very difficult. The problem that we were talking about before, the problem of where you draw the division between, as it were, the small stuff and the big stuff, the microscopic and the macroscopic, that problem emerges in a slightly different form as the problem as to what constitutes a measurement, because the view that there was that split between the microscopic and the macroscopic, tended to go a long with the view that the macroscopic things were the things like measuring devices, and the microscopic stuff became sharp in particular ways when it encountered these measuring devices.

Now if that's your view, then it becomes an important issue to say what it takes to be a measuring device. And that problem has come to be called the Measurement Problem. It is one which is still hotly debated and so one of the things that a proponent of any particular interpretation of quantum mechanics has to do, is to say what their answer to the Measurement Problem is.'


I honestly hadn't thought that paradoxes could be conceived of as a failure. That we have to live with them, sure. That they're problematic, on some level? Absolutely. That they are insufficient, a non-performance that does not meet desired ends? Hmm. Is it paradox itself, or is it us with our human limitations of understanding that is really at issue?

Sunday, May 3, 2009

Dolkar

Of course, I should be blase about this.

This afternoon, I took refuge at the Vajrayana Institute in Ashfield, with Geshe Samten. The ceremony was long, and the teachings were not trivial, and the undertaking, itself, is a somewhat serious one. 

Which does naught to explain my childlike elation this afternoon. I've just made a vow to pray three times twice a day, to revere my guru, and to follow the five precepts and ten moral values of the lay Buddhist practitioner. I should be at least, sobered by these responsibilities. I should be at least a little pained, perhaps, sitting for three hours straight during satsang (yeah, that's right, me, sitting that still. Three hours. Go figure). 

And I feel blessed. 

Partly, this comes from the unexpected part of the proceedings, over and above learning about the causes, objects, motivations, benefits and advice in refuge from Geshe Samten.

Many years ago, when I was just getting my toehold on the form and emptiness mind-gizmo, I picked out White Tara as my deity - or, you could say that she kind of picked me. I've got a copy of an old thangka painting, which has formed the basis of my meditation 'shrine' that has moved with me across 10 suburbs in the 7 directions (well, not qute, but you get the idea). 

Her compassion speaks to longevity - Green Tara can be called on when you need help, now, but White Tara, manifested from the tear of Avalokiteshavara (the Dalai Lama is the incarnation of the same, as Chenrezig), White Tara is a little more full bodied, and her maternal compassion is the mercy of those who are wounded, either physically or psychically.

It's her picture on this blog, as 'The Divine Mother'.

So really, it's no surprise at all, that when it comes to being given a refuge name today by Geshe Samten, a monk for whom I've paid reverent audience once before but certainly have never personally spoken to, before today, when it comes to this, in my prayerbook, written in there by Geshe-la, I've been given the name:

Dolkar.

It means White Tara.

There are times when you can look another human being in the eye, and for a flash of a second, there's a connection that speaks to an out-of-this-world space, but of a connection that's absolutely grounded in the depth of the other's worldview. A flash. It lasts less than an instant. It may well be worth far less than that - my mind is inevitably the eternal storyteller. 

I live for these moments. 

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

The Difference that Makes a Difference

Taken from:

Bateson, G. & Bateson, M.C. (2005). Angels Fear - Towards an Epistemology of the Sacred. Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.

Elaborating on the contrast between Creatura and Pleroma in C.G. Jung's Septem Sermones ad Mortuos:

'In fact, wherever information - or comparison- is of the essence in our explanation, there, for me, is mental process. Information can be defined as a difference that makes a difference. A sensory end organ is a comparator, a device which responds to the difference. Of course, the sensory end organ is material, but it is this responsiveness to difference that we shall use to distinguish it's functioning as 'mental'.....information is all ours; it is part of our life processes. The world of nonliving matter, the Pleroma, which is described by the laws of physics and chemistry, itself contains no description. A stone does not respond to information and does not use injunctions or information or trial and error in it's internal organisation. To respond in a behavioural sense, the stone would have to use energy contained within itself, as organisms do. It would cease to be a stone.....
I can give the stone a name, I can distinguish it from other stones. But it is not it's name, and it cannot distinguish.....while Pleroma is without thought or information, it still contains - is the matrix of - many other sorts of regularities. Inertia, cause and effect, connection and disconnection, and so on, these regularities are immanent in Pleroma. Although they can be translated into the language of Creatura, the material world still remains inaccessible, the Kantian Ding an sich which you cannot get close to....
In summary then, we will use Jung's term Pleroma as a name for that unliving world described by physics which in itself contains and makes no distinctions, although we must, of course, make distinctions in our description of it.
In contrast, we will use Creatura for that world of explanation in which the very phenomena described are among themselves governed and determined by difference, distinction, and information.'

At the interface of the Pleroma and Creatura, we have the line of information-in and information-out that we call 'mind'. Herein, according to Bateson, is birthed epistemology. Jung's epistemology is perhaps a step sideways from Descartes's - it starts from a comparison of difference, not from matter. We presume knowing is possible, and begin to tease out how it is done.

I must dig out some Korzybski to read......

Monday, April 27, 2009

Offset

I'm trundling my way through my 1500 word essay this morning, fix a reference here, look up a synonym for 'difference' there, when I get leg jitters enough to need to stand up, and wander about the house.

Our house bears a strong resemblance to a big red brick refrigerator this time of year. The sun looks inviting, teasing it's way through the back screen door, so I take a moment to wander out into the jungle of our backyard.

I'm someone who looks in the mirror and frequently gets nothing less than shocked, shocked by the thought that it's only by the grace of this thing called an eye that I get to know that this thing staring at the mirror is me. Without that eye, without that functioning, that being-a-component within and as partner to many-other-components, there ain't nothing there to look at.

So I guess it's no surprise when I toddle out into the warm, soft, green backyard from the confines of the cold house and hard edges of my essay that I'm dunked into a mindsweeping sensation of graced-ness. What, all this?

In that moment, my breath itself is given up for God. It's an overwhelm that runs all the way from the depth of the deep blue Sydney autmn sky all the way through my body to the tiny green caterpillar that was munching its way across the weeds between the paving at my slippered feet. I can't, but I am, able to take it all in. It's all in the breath, without this, I am not here to drown, or drink it all in, down.

Living in the offset.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

No Conviction

Some shameless cross posting of a taste of a chapter of a new book:

The Orthodox Heretic by Peter Rollins as promoted by 'The Website of Unknowing':

No Conviction

In a world where following Christ is decreed to be a subversive and illegal activity you have been accused of being a believer, arrested, and dragged before a court.

You have been under clandestine surveillance for some time now, and so the prosecution has been able to build up quite a case against you. They begin the trial by offering the judge dozens of photographs that show you attending church meetings, speaking at religious events, and participating in various prayer and worship services. After this, they present a selection of items that have been confiscated from your home: religious books that you own, worship CDs, and other Christian artifacts. Then they step up the pace by displaying your many poems, pieces of prose, and journal entries that you had lovingly written concerning your faith. Finally, in closing, the prosecution offers your Bible to the judge. This is a well-worn book with scribbles, notes, drawings, and underlings throughout, evidence, if it were needed, that you had read and re-read this sacred text many times.

Throughout the case you have been sitting silently in fear and trembling. You know deep in your heart that with the large body of evidence that has been amassed by the prosecution you face the possibility of long imprisonment or even execution. At various times throughout the proceedings you have lost all confidence and been on the verge of standing up and denying Christ. But while this thought has plagued your mind throughout the trial, you resist the temptation and remain focused.

Once the prosecution is finished presenting their case the judge proceeds to ask if you have anything to add, but you remain silent, resolute, terrified that if you open your mouth, even for a moment, you might deny the charges made against you. Like Christ, you remain silent before your accusers. In response you are led outside to wait as the judge ponders your case.

The hours pass slowly as you sit under guard in the foyer waiting to be summoned back. Eventually a young man in uniform appears and leads you into the courtroom so that you may hear the verdict and receive word of your punishment. Once you have been seated in the dock the judge, a harsh and unyielding man, enters the room, stands before you, looks deep into your eyes and begins to speak,

“Of the charges that have been brought forward I find the accused not guilty.”

“Not guilty?” your heart freezes. Then, in a split second, the fear and terror that had moments before threatened to strip your resolve are swallowed up by confusion and rage.

Despite the surroundings, you stand defiantly before the judge and demand that he give an account concerning why you are innocent of the charges in light of the evidence.

“What evidence?” he replies in shock.

“What about the poems and prose that I wrote?” you reply.

“They simply show that you think of yourself as a poet, nothing more.”

“But what about the services I spoke at, the times I wept in church and the long, sleepless nights of prayer?”

“Evidence that you are a good speaker and actor, nothing more.” Replied the judge, “It is obvious that you deluded those around you, and perhaps at times you even deluded yourself, but this foolishness is not enough to convict you in a court of law.”

“But this is madness!” you shout. “It would seem that no evidence would convince you!”

“Not so,” replies the judge as if informing you of a great, long-forgotten secret.

“The court is indifferent towards your Bible reading and church attendance; it has no concern for worship with words and a pen. Continue to develop your theology, and use it to paint pictures of love. We have no interest in such armchair artists who spend their time creating images of a better world. We exist only for those who would lay down their brush, and their life, in a Christlike endeavor to create a better world. So, until you challenge this system and become a thorn in our side, until you die to yourself and offer your body to the flames, until then, my friend, you are no enemy of ours.”


If we step for a moment into Christ's shoes, and think about offering the bread and the wine to our closest compatriots, as we ask them to 'take this, all of you and eat it, this is my body, which shall be given up for you', it's impossible not to be hit with the indubitable gravity of the request/demand. A sense of immense self sacrifice, and the immense load of one human life lived for anyone else except for that self, all wrapped up in flour, water and wine and blessed, to boot.

I had a good conversation tonight with a good friend about the nature of self sacrifice, and how pitifully easy it is to come across as virtuous in our culture (Oh no, my car doesn't have air conditioning. Does yours?) About how the true nature of intentionality is never quite captured in the act, no matter your high or low moral standpoint. About how crispy clear we can get our definitions and distinctions, and still not even come close to representing the intricate messiness and ridiculous beauty that is inherent in every moment we're graced to be part of.

How indeed we see through a glass darkly, never more so than when we think that we know God. All of which has left me with a humbled grin as I dare to start treading the path through a Gnostic seminary.

One day, somehow, I might see the means to hold back my self-misgivings just long enough to hand you a wafer and a swig of red. 'Til then, I'm kinda with the Dust Brothers:

'I say let me never be complete
I say may I never be content
I say deliver me from Swedish furniture
I say deliver me from clever arts'


lyrics liberated from 'This is Your Life' - from the soundtrack to the movie 'Fight Club'