Thursday, June 11, 2009

Corpus Christi

Sub divérsis speciébus, * Signis
tantum, et non rebus, * Latent
res exímiæ.

Here beneath these signs are hidden *
Priceless things, to sense forbidden *
Signs, not things, are all we see.

from the Alleluia sequence from the Proper of the Mass for the Solemnity of Corpus Christi.


ref: http://www.maternalheart.org/propers/Sundays%20after%20Pentecost/Pentecost%201%20-%20Thursday%20-%20Corpus%20Christi/corpuschristi.pdf

The feast of Corpus Christi, which is celebrated on the Thursday after Trinity Sunday, comes to be birthed in the Catholic Liturical calendar in a gorgeous way - in 1209, St Juliana of Mt Cornillon, a devout nun who was devoted to care for the sick at the Convent for Augustinian Sisters in Liege, had a vision.

She saw the moon hanging in mid air, in the sky. Although the moon was shining bright, there was a single black spot on it. St Juliana was not used to seeing things like this. She thought that the vision was just her imagination, so she tried to forget about it, and prayed, more fervently, that she might find salvation from these petty distractions.

But, through the inner dialogue that grew with her Christ, she came to understand that this vision of the moon was a symbol of the Church, so bright with all its Feasts. The black part of the moon was a hole, where there was no Feast to honour the Blessed Sacrament. She understands her Mission as a call to get many people interested in this new Feast Day. But St Juliana was very humble, and she was frightened at the thought of such a Mission. She believed that this vision was just her imagination, so she decided to keep the whole thing a secret.

In 1230, St Juliana became Mother Superior of the Augustinian Monastery. Soon after her election, she again had the vision of the moon with the black spot on it. Mother Juliana decided to share her secret. She decided to tell this Canon de Lausanne, a priest in Liege about her vision and also begged him to talk to other theologians, to try to make head or tail of it.

While the Feast was quickly incorporated into the Office of St Martin, St Juliana did not live to see the Feast accepted in all Churches in her local area - indeed, it was only through the work of her staunch friend St Eve, combined with the efforts of Pope Urban IV (I love that name) that the Feast become an institution in the Catholic Church.

ALLELUIA, alleluia. Caro mea
vere est cibus, et sanguis meus vere
est potus: qui mandúcat meam carnem,
et bibit meum sánguinem, in
me manet et ego is eo. Allelúia.

Alleluia, alleluia. My Flesh is meat indeed,
and My Blood is drink indeed: he
that eateth My Flesh and drinketh My
Blood, abideth in Me, and I in him. Alleluia.


Ref: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04390b.htm
http://www.sspx.ca/EucharisticCrusade/2002January/St_Juliana_of_Mt_Cornillon.htm


Friday, June 5, 2009

Hoc Est Enim Corpus Meum




Haec quotiescumque feceritis, in mei memoriam facietis.


hostiam puram, hostiam sanctam, hostiam immaculatam, Panem sanctum vitae aeternae, et calicem salutis perpetuae.

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

Salome

I never did fully get over this music video, much less the song.



Stand Inside Your Love by The Smashing Pumkins (2000). Theme for the video is based on Salome by Oscar Wilde.

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Attuning to the Music

'No one remembers, word for word, all that was said in any lecture, or played in any piece. But, if you understood it once, you now own new networks of knowledge, about each theme and how it changes and relates to others. Thus, no one could remember Beethoven's Fifth Symphony entire, from a single hearing. But neither could you ever hear again those first four notes as just four notes! Once but a tiny scrap of sound; it is now a Known Thing - a locus in the web of all the other things that we know, whose meanings and significances depend on one another.'- Marvin Minsky

Friday, May 29, 2009

Being and Nothing

The second chapter of 'The Uses of Paradox' is entitled 'Credo Quia Absurdum', and explores the notion of paradox as a practice of cognitive asceticism, explicated via the work of Soren Kirkegaard. Set against a statement by Hume - 'that the causal source of theological absurdity in human nature (fear) explains it's strange imperviousness to the basic principles of logic', Bagger introduces the idea of psychological cognitive dissonance as a way to view the cultivation of paradox as an ascetic practice.

Two cognitions, x and y, are dissonant if not-x follows from y, for example. Logical inconsistency, conflict with past experience, incompatibility between behaviour and cultural mores and conflicts in specific and general opinion all count as cognitive dissonances. Typically people will act to reduce the psychological discomfort of cognitive dissonance, and John Gager has proposed that it suffices as as an explanation for the success of early Christianity, reducing the dissonance occasioned by disappointed expectations of the coming of the Messiah. Reductions to dissonance are available through either changing the cognition, or adding cognitive elements - where adding can occur by converting other people to be of the same opinion, to diminish the importance of the dissonant cognition, or to reconcile the two cognitions.

The discomfort of cognitive dissonance can be exalted by a psychologically astute ascetic - and Soren Kirkegaard employs a character called Johannes Climacus to explicitly deny the notion that religious life involves physical self torment - rather it is the embracing of voluntary self-denial that is engaged with in a systematic pursuit of self-transformation. Religious existence in this view is essentially continual suffering, where the individual must renounce all finite ends to relate him or herself absolutely to the absolute. This necessitates the existential recognition that the individual is capable of doing nothing himself, but is nothing before God - rather the individual is passively transformed by God, so suffering becomes the pain of self-annihilation and passivity before God's activity.

A Hegelian lens, which would allow the operation of understanding through the Aristotelian principles of identity, non-contradiction and the excluded middle, is juxtaposed against the exercise of dialectical reason which identifies the possibility that all concepts imply their own contradiction. Kirkegaard recounts that dialectical reason is crucial to understanding precisely because Aristotle's three principles cannot adequately define the natural and social worlds.

Hegel's 'pure being' represents a perfectly abstract and undetermined starting point, without form and without content. For the understanding, for Hegel, the identity of being and nothing is a paradox - but a paradox united in becoming. When something becomes it simultaneously is and is not. Becoming negates the absolute negativity of nothing by bringing the positivity of being and the negativity of nothing into (positive) union.

'Nowhere in heaven of on earth is there anything which does not contain within itself both being and nothing. Of course, since we are speaking here of an actual something, those determinations are no longer present in it in the complete untruth in which they are being and nothing, they are a more deoveloped determination, and are grasped as positive and negative'....

Kirkegaard actually objects to Hegel's language here of negativity (and speculation), but employs exactly the notion of negativity as the motive force in individual inward deepening. While Hegel has a final positive landing point in 'becoming', Kirkegaard adopts no such salvific notion, rather the deepest most inward expression of the religious sphere is found in the wound of negativity.

Kirkegaard gives examples of the positive being distinguished by the negative - revelation marked by mystery, eternal happiness by suffering, certitude of faith by uncertainty, easiness by difficulty, truth by absurdity, the infinite eternal and the finite temporal. We participate in timeless truths and ideals, but exist in a temporal world of becoming, and there is an infinite ethical task to be completed, uniting the contradictory elements into a synthesis.

For Kirkegaard then, faith in the Christian paradox, that an eternal God entered into the finite world in a human form culminates the religious project of self annihilation and effects a 'new birth'. Faith becomes a martyrdom, a crucifixion of the understanding. Faith ensures that the relation to the absolute is not relative. The faithful individual breaks from immanence - from the vain delusion that he is ontologically and epistemologically adequate to the truth. Kirkegaard's antipathy for Hegel arises because Hegel attempts to reconcile the paradox - speculation attempts to align itself with God, and Kirkegaard would prefer to maintain the heightened sense of prodigious contradiction in order to hold Christianity as an existence-communication that must be subjectively appropriated and then actively engaged with, in cognitive asceticism, nulling and voiding the sense of understanding that might be best described by a quote:

'For faith sees best in the dark'.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Paradox Without Piety

'When paradox entered the English language sometime in the sixteenth century, it simply meant 'an eccentric opinion'....In contemporary English the word refers to a more curious kind of doxastic anomaly....I stipulatively define paradox as an apparently absurd claim, i.e., a claim that apparently entails a self-contradiction (either formally, materially or performatively), to which one feels at least some inclination to assent because it is supported by at least one form of epistemic authority that one recognises.'

 'Paradoxes are not mere wordplay. Neither are they primarily exercises in logic....The two elements of my definition - the apparent self-contradiction and the epistemic authority - point to the two conventional ways that a paradox can be resolved...either: one eliminates a paradox by concluding that the appearance of the self contradiction is deceiving...or: one eliminates a paradox by subverting the epistemic authority that supports what one now views as a straightforward self-contradiction...one finds the flaw in the argument, rejects the testimony, repudiates tradition, concludes the master made a mistake.....'

 'Faced with a contradiction that seems fundamentally irreconcilable, one can ignore it, or deny it, worship it or try to remove it...in religious contexts paradox can assume a holy or sacred mien.'

 'Religious thinkers venerate paradoxes….when a metaphysical doctrine that generates paradox is constitutive of religious beliefs or practices in which the thinkers are heavily invested. Paradox functions as a means of worship - not an object of worship - when it comes to inform cognitive practices. Cognitive practices are techniques of self transformation....They work to alter the individual's volitional complex - his or her beliefs, emotions, attitudes, perspectives and desires - in accord with a religious end.'

 '...pre-commitment strategies bind one through causal mechanisms one sets up in the world...some raise the stakes for failure..others restrict one's exposure to temptation...or opportunities for failure...yet others work directly to change one's volitional complex (e.g. taking cold showers to strengthen the will, working to develop habits)...Manuals of spiritual discipline advocate all the pre-commitment techniques, but also recommend a rich variety of techniques for rearranging inner space.'

 'Meditation takes many forms...the Buddhist monk engaged in 'mental culture' (bhavana) aims to appropriate the truth of Buddhist doctrine subjectively. Through vipassana or insight meditation he discerns the real by applying Buddhist doctrine to his own personal experience....Teresa of Avila continually implores her nuns to meditate on the humanity of Christ, to gaze at his beautiful face, to witness his suffering for their sakes...such a practice counters selfish reluctance to do his will. Shantideva similarly harnesses the imagination when he counsels that one plagued by lust should imagine the object of one's lust as a sack of excrement.'

 'Religiously motivated self-transformation texts sometimes describe argot of the idiom of detachment and union. That paradox can foster detachment from disfavoured affections and judgments and /or promote identification with a wider perspective, explains why religious texts sometimes seem to revel in paradox...'

 'Cognitive ascetics harness the discomfort of cognitive dissonance and hitch it to an ascetic regimen...in their hands paradox becomes a tool of ascetic self-transformation....a second type of religious response to paradox (is) mysticism...a mystic purports to attain ineffable superknowledge on the far side of paradox. For a mystic, paradox does not mark the limits of human cognition; rather, paradox opens out onto a plane of exceptional cognition...Mystical apprehension serves to refashion the perspective and attitudes composing the self...'

 'Reactions to paradox gain emotional force from their basis in attitudes toward social relations. To a thinker who feels his group threatened by outsiders, paradox will offend and horrify. If this thinker uses cognitive dissonance ascetically, these affects exacerbate the discomfort. To a thinker invested in bringing outsiders across the external boundary of the group, paradox will evoke awe and reverence. The mystic’s belief that he has attained ineffable superknowledge dispels the cognitive dissonance attendant in paradox, while these strong affects lend the doctrine that begat the paradox the vivacity to impel a change in his volitional complex….’

 ‘The very concept of absolute transcendence generates paradox. To characterise the transcendent as beyond all limited and describable things is to limit it and describe it as something in relation to all other limited things. The absolutely transcendent must, therefore, paradoxically be within all things as well as beyond them.’

Bagger, M. (2007). Ch1: 'Paradox Without Piety', The Uses of Paradox (Religion, Self-Transformation, and the Absurd), New York: Columbia University Press, p 1 - 14.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

The 'felt presence' of God - circa 5th century

The heart itself is only a small vessel,
yet dragons are there, and lions,
there are poisonous beasts,
and all the treasures of evil,
there are rough and uneven roads,
there are precipes;
but there too is God and the angels,
life is there, and the Kingdom,
there too is light, and there the apostles
and heavenly cities,
and treasures of grace.
All things lie within that little space.

St Makarios the Great.