Saturday, May 8, 2010

Millais, Ophelia, 1852



'Ophelia', Sir John Everett Millais  1829-1896 

http://www.tate.org.uk/servlet/ViewWork?workid=9506&searchid=9260

Ref:

Kim, K. (2009). "The time is out of joint" in New Essays on the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory. (Ed. A. Drake). Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, p. 141 - 168.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

The words that grace the moving beyond

The last eight lines from a poem called '90 North' by Randall Jarrell:

'Where, living or dying, I am still alone;
Here where North, the night, the berg of death
Crowd me out of the ignorant darkness,
I see at last that all the knowledge

I wrung from the darkness—that the darkness flung me—
Is worthless as ignorance: nothing comes from nothing,
The darkness from the darkness. Pain comes from the darkness
And we call it wisdom. It is pain.'





I'm working through an essay on the symbolism that is recruited by a self-harmer in acts of self-mutilation. In psychoanalytic theory, a thread from Klein through to Segal through to Woodruff runs, addressing this question, the detailed accounts of the traumatised psychotic patients seeming to me to become more sensitive, more astute, through these women's accounts, over time, through history. Psychoanalysis is not a well established academic field, and it's a field that does not lend itself easily to models and systematisation, at that. Offerings made available through journal articles in this field speak of a uniqueness that is perhaps an outcome of this un-trammelled corner of human expertise - the papers tend  to have a feel of direct transmission from the author's fingertips, and seem free, in some ways of the overbearing APA standardisation procedures that I'm now accustomed to.


The modelling that is valuable for me, here, comes directly from the practitioners, not neat Venn diagrams and statistical significance at alpha 0.05. The modelling comes from the increasing emphasis through history placed in their own accounts of what is occurring, for them, as they work with, and beside, these patients. The most powerful accounts seem to arise through their explication of their involvement in countertransference, through the understanding of themselves, as they were, as they are, that they are brave enough to release to the world, in, of all places, academic papers.


[sharp change of subject]


These lines from Jarrell's poem grounds a place to work from, for me - it speaks not of annihilation but more of that continual starting over, the continual re-dressing that has to take place, as the world shifts through time, of what we thought we knew. Like these women who publish papers on the symbolism of inordinate acts of cruelty enacted instrumentally against the self, re-dressing and re-naming what was, and shifting to what is, into the darkness, is the work of being trully human, to me. 


Language is birthed as we break our symbiotic relationship to our maternal figure in human development. That question of whether all symbol formation, from the time we are small children onwards is an attempt to crawl back into the womb, in some ways, speaks to me of the unity discourse, the basis of so much of our spirituality.


Where be the One?


or should it be


Why be the One?

Saturday, May 1, 2010

A custodia matutina usque ad noctem

Friday, April 30, 2010

Me and A Gun - Tori Amos Live





The power of this song, for me, comes from the paradox of Tori singing it - her voice is soft and light and controlled (well, with the odd wrenched lift and cry) but the emotional labour and emphasis of the song  is carried in the expressiveness of her face. I've seen other performances where the characters in the story seemingly flit across her face as she sings the lines, and she flirts with the audience a little in the beginning, small smiles and steely eyes and quirked eyebrows and tongue to the corner of the upper lip, to end up dragged into the current of despair and anguish and hopelessness, a torture that is the direct response to her experience.

She says it took her seven years to open up, to allow vulnerability to be intertwined into self-expression sufficiently to release herself from the psychological suffering that was an outcome of the rape:

"In the song, I say it was Me and a Gun but it wasn't a gun. It was a knife he had. And the idea was to take me to his friends and cut me up, and he kept telling me that, for hours. And if he hadn't needed more drugs I would have been just one more news report, where you see the parents grieving for their daughter. And I was singing hymns, as I say in the song, because he told me to. I sang to stay alive [italics mine]. Yet I survived that torture, which left me urinating all over myself and left me paralysed for years. That's what that night was all about, mutilation, more than violation through sex.


I really do feel as though I was psychologically mutilated that night and that now I'm trying to put the pieces back together again. Through love, not hatred. And through my music. My strength has been to open again, to life, and my victory is the fact that, despite it all, I kept alive my vulnerability."

My mind chases over and over the lyrics:

'I don't think you'll be back in three days time
So you choose well'

I resonate, far far too strongly, perhaps, with these lines.


Not Gods. Not Eternity. Not Ephemeral. Not Known.


Monday, April 26, 2010

Contemporary Castration

An interesting component of my coursework:


Modern Day Emasculations: Triumphs, Tragedies, and Transcendence
Various populations of genetic males seek either chemical or surgical castration in order to change their life. These range from advanced prostate cancer patients who are simply trying to improve their chances of survival, to male-to-female transsexuals who are trying to change their fundamental identity as male. In his lecture, Professor Wassersug will focus on modern day voluntary eunuchs – males who desire to be emasculated yet do not wish to be female. Some have a nonspecific Gender Identity Disorder, others a Body Integrity Identity Disorder, and some have extreme sadomasochistic paraphilias (fetishes). Professor Wassersug will shed light on what motivates these men – why, how, and where they get castrated, and the consequences of their castration.

When: 7th May at 4pm
Where: DT A Lecture Theatre, Heydon Laurence Bldg (A08), The University of Sydney

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Dark Beautiful Things




'The Sacrifice' composed by Michael Nyman, from the movie 'The Piano' (1993) written and directed by Jane Campion.

The Contours of the Death Drive

A summary of a paper by Otto Kernberg (see reference below).

Not for the feint-hearted, in some ways this material is kind of like an episode of Grey's Anatomy directed at the psyche rather than the body, and without the attractive American actors.

Repetition compulsion, sadism and masochism, negative therapy reactions and depression resulting in suicide are all explored in this paper, and Kernberg draws the conclusion that the general dominance of aggressive affects can count for much of the explanatory power of the ‘death drive’. The theories of Eros and Thanatos are proposed by Freud to be fundamental motivational principles that have implications for the formation symptoms and unconscious schemata.  Through biological study we know that the primary motivational system for humans consists of affects of a positive and negative activation. Embedded libidinal positive and negative affects are implicated in fantasies of love and hatred. (p.1010)

Kernberg (2009) identifies the death drive as ‘a dominant unconscious motivation towards self-destructiveness’.  It may extend beyond the bounds of the self to imply the destruction of others.
Kernberg captures aggression, as per Freud, as arising from the conflict between the pleasure principle and the reality principle. Biological preparation in the service of territoriality or the competition of males for females is seen as the ground upon which more complex manifestations of the death drive emerge, including repetition compulsion, sadism and masochism, negative therapeutic reaction, suicide and self-destructive development in group processes. (p.1012)

The repetition compulsion is the repeating of the same destructive behaviour while being resistant to analysis.  Repetition compulsion can be a working through of a conflict or a traumatic relationship, and it may reflect a re-kindling of primitive processes embedded early in the behavioural chain. Identification with the perpetrator of the trauma may be one other way that the compulsion becomes apparent, where an effort to reverse the roles and place someone else in the role of overwhelmed victim is a reified unconscious defensive response.
‘Andre Green...has described unconscious identification with a ‘dead mother’, that is, a severely depressed mother who had chronically frustrated the needs for love and dependency of her infant...The patient, in unconscious identification with a fantasied ‘dead mother’ denies the existence of all live relationships in reality as if he himself were dead to the world’ (p.1012).

Destructive narcissistic organisation in some clients presents as a level of denial that destroys the work of an envied therapist – a relentless self-destructive motivation becomes apparent as the client uses the denial to reassure and protect themselves from awareness of their avoidance of life tasks (p. 1013).

Kernberg parallels sadism and masochism with anorexia, in viewing the unconscious conflicts of anorectics as extending across a spectrum of Oedipal rivalry through to primitive self-hatred. Perversity in the form of a recruitment of love in service of aggression in order that the beloved object, seduced into helpfulness, is lured into a trap that ends with the destruction of the person in a symbolic or a real sense also qualifies here as self-destructive pathology. Some clients with profoundly forbidden oedipal urges or severe unconscious aggression simply destroy what they receive (p. 1014).

Negative therapeutic reaction is a severe self-directed destruction that may arise through guilt over receiving treatment or be apparent in narcissistic clients in envy of the therapist. Some patients too can only manifest a real relationship with a person who will destroy them. Pursued into countertransference, analysands may find themselves ‘acting out’ the roles which allow the client to escalate their self-destructive behaviour (p. 1015).

Suicidal tendencies in melancholia, where the introjection of an ambivalently loved and lost object draws aggression into that object in order that the ego might destroy it constitutes a very final form of self-destruction on behalf of the superego (p. 1015).

Kernberg describes the work of Melanie Klein in object relations, where she described the work of the depressive as overcoming a split between positive, idealised relations and aggressive projections onto the object. This split is a normal component of early development, but is a split that is returned to across all later mourning processes as the primal moment of object loss. Relentless self attack may form part of this split pathology where an attack is launched on the self from the superego, and in severely narcissistic personalities, abandonment to death, or suicide, emerges with the superego triumphant over a ‘depreciated, worthless world’ (p. 1016).

Self destruction may also emerge in social movements, where enemy formations, protected dependency and focussed aggression combined with the projection of a superego onto the leader may activate destructiveness at a social level (p.1017).

Severe self-destructive aggression is not a primary tendency but rather is an organised motivational system that is not simply ‘secondary to trauma’. The clinical view offers intrapsychic struggles between internalised sadistic representations and masochistic representations of the self. The internalised sadistic representations include projected and reintrojected aggressive impulses, plus traumatic experiences. Masochistic self representations include eroticisation of painful experiences and guilty suffering. What makes a self destructive person is a difficult question to answer, even for Kernberg. He points to some genetic determination of a negative affect dominance and for inadequate cognitive contextualisation of negative affect expressed as an insecure attachment style in early years. Traumatic experience early in life will often constitute the ground for a disorganised personality style that is self-destructive at core.  Intensity of negative aggressive affect and an internalised narcissistic structure emerge as consistently present in the dominant motivation for self destruction in clients.

Ref:

Kernberg, O. (2009). The concept of the death drive: A clinical perspective. International Journal of Psychoanalysis,, 90, 1009-1023.