Dejours' article (see reference below) addresses the 'psychodynamics of work'. He notes in his opening lines that for many of his clients, work is inseparable from suffering. Oddly enough though, he also characterises work as being 'at the origin of intelligence and ingeniousness'. The chosen challenge for subjectivity sees outcomes in terms of self-fulfillment or mental pathology - but either way, it's a chosen attitude.
Work is always completed 'for someone' - it is completely constructed in social relation. 'It is the power to feel, to think, to invent'. From a psychodynamic perspective, work is encountered when the personality must confront a task that is subject to material and social constraints. Dejours proposes that there is no such thing as purely screwing-toothpaste-lids-onto-toothpaste-tubes kind of work. There is always a gap between the prescriptive and the concrete reality of a situation - work seeks to bridge it. The prescriptive cannot define the total of reality, so 'the real' must constantly be defined as what subjects must add to a task in order to complete it.
Here it becomes interesting - 'the real' therefore is defined in failure - the real manifests itself to the subject in resistance to procedure, or knowledge, the real is defined in a thwarting of control. The real manifests itself in an affectively unpleasant moment of realisation for the subject - frustration, discouragement, powerlessness.
This affective suffering becomes the point of departure - the concentration of subjectivity that it entails prefigures a period of expansion as the subject acts to surmount the resistance of reality. Suffering is at once a subjective impression of the world and the source of an attempt to conquer (conquer!) the world...suffering lies at the origin of the intelligence that sets out in search of the world,in order to challenge, transform, and increase itself....subjectivity itself is transformed, increased and revealed to itself. [Italics and exclamation are mine]
Gives me a new way to think about that poor, naked, emaciated, body nailed bloodily to a cross, really.
Dejours proposes that intellectual work in no way can be reduced to mere cognition - subjectivity is not a looming ghost, but rather is governed by a particular body and a unique corporality. The body is the locus of skill in work - sensitivity to the tasks to be deployed can only be attuned through the body. We create a dialogue with that with which we work - with people, with machines, we create a strange vitalist fantasy, of projection, of availability, of need.
The body that we use is not the biologists body - rather it is the corpspropriation, that which relates to Other, that feels, that re-acts. The erotic body is the one through which we engage with the world. Dissociation from this body equates to mental illness in our culture. While this body is visible to the world, the suffering within it is not. The unseen suffering is thus un-valued, in our culture.
As highlighted above, being intelligent always means being a step outside of the procedure and instruction - codes must be violated, normative organisation must be traversed, in order to achieve. This too, however, is an invisible, and thus un-valued [or perhaps, more correctly for my thinking, not-correctly valued] skill.
Is work a necessary condition for the emergence of subjectivity? In a way that parallels the emergence of a subject in relationship, subjectivity in love? I don't think so - Dejours proposes rather that the development of subjectivity comes about through the relationship between suffering and reality.
Dejours argues that in psychodynamic theory proposes a paradox of double centrality, in the existence in a subject of suffering and drives on one hand, and the reality of the world and the unconscious on another. Freud defines the instinct as 'a measure of the demand made upon the mind for work in consequence of it's connection with the body'.
To tie this to the notion of work as Dejours has undertaken to analyse it, of poeisis, would require semantic ties to Traumarbeit (dream work) Trauerarbeit (work of mourning), Durcharbeiten (working through), Verdrangungsarbeit (work of repression), Arbeitsanforderung (work requirement), Verdichtungsarbeit (work of condensation) and so on.
This (above) places work and subjectivity in a consubstantial relationship - work in this way would allow that subjectivity be revealed to itself. Work then forms the transcendental condition for the revelation of absolute life. This brings the question of work into the realm of political theory.
Ordinary work, of course, does not present itself as a solipsistic relationship between self and self. Work is a social relationship - characterised by inequality, power and domination, expressed in a hierarchy. Work is the experience of resistance in a social world . To coordinate contradiction and conflict arising from the inevitability of personal style emerging from individual intelligence, the real organisation must be adjusted - out of the prescriptive organisation. Arriving at a collaborative effort implies worker commitment to disentangle deviations from procedures [whatever communally defined procedures might have been originally established, maybe]. Collective activity thus presumes a series of arguments, ideally oriented to efficiency, quality and social objective - a de facto compromise, that is at once both technical and social. Living together is not self-evident, it demands deontic activity.
So why do we self-limit our subjectivity in the name of collective will?
- violence from conflict demands it?
- the limited resources and invisibility in/of work demands that real work becomes visible. Judgment can be established when visibility is maximised.
The recognition of doing makes it possible to work with people we don't particularly seek for company. Cooperation may also function to ward off social solitude. Ultimately, rational compromise between individual subjectivity and collective action is possible in holding a centrality of work.
Back to the drawing board (literally! :) ) for me.
Ref:
Dejours, C. (2007). Subjectivity, Work and Action, Critical Horizons, 7, 45-62.
Online reading:
http://www.eap.philosophy-australia.com/issue_2/EAP2_THE_ENDURING_SIGNIFICANCE_OF_AXEL_HONNETH'S_CRITICAL_CONCEPTION_OF_WORK.pdf
http://www98.griffith.edu.au/dspace/bitstream/10072/1678/1/CLWRworkinglife.pdf
http://www.ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/res/article/viewFile/2465/2312
Sunday, May 9, 2010
Saturday, May 8, 2010
Millais, Ophelia, 1852
'Ophelia', Sir John Everett Millais 1829-1896
http://www.tate.org.uk/servlet/ViewWork?workid=9506&searchid=9260
Ref:
Kim, K. (2009). "The time is out of joint" in New Essays on the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory. (Ed. A. Drake). Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, p. 141 - 168.
Tuesday, May 4, 2010
The words that grace the moving beyond
The last eight lines from a poem called '90 North' by Randall Jarrell:
'Where, living or dying, I am still alone;
Here where North, the night, the berg of death
Crowd me out of the ignorant darkness,
I see at last that all the knowledge
I wrung from the darkness—that the darkness flung me—
Is worthless as ignorance: nothing comes from nothing,
The darkness from the darkness. Pain comes from the darkness
And we call it wisdom. It is pain.'
I'm working through an essay on the symbolism that is recruited by a self-harmer in acts of self-mutilation. In psychoanalytic theory, a thread from Klein through to Segal through to Woodruff runs, addressing this question, the detailed accounts of the traumatised psychotic patients seeming to me to become more sensitive, more astute, through these women's accounts, over time, through history. Psychoanalysis is not a well established academic field, and it's a field that does not lend itself easily to models and systematisation, at that. Offerings made available through journal articles in this field speak of a uniqueness that is perhaps an outcome of this un-trammelled corner of human expertise - the papers tend to have a feel of direct transmission from the author's fingertips, and seem free, in some ways of the overbearing APA standardisation procedures that I'm now accustomed to.
The modelling that is valuable for me, here, comes directly from the practitioners, not neat Venn diagrams and statistical significance at alpha 0.05. The modelling comes from the increasing emphasis through history placed in their own accounts of what is occurring, for them, as they work with, and beside, these patients. The most powerful accounts seem to arise through their explication of their involvement in countertransference, through the understanding of themselves, as they were, as they are, that they are brave enough to release to the world, in, of all places, academic papers.
[sharp change of subject]
These lines from Jarrell's poem grounds a place to work from, for me - it speaks not of annihilation but more of that continual starting over, the continual re-dressing that has to take place, as the world shifts through time, of what we thought we knew. Like these women who publish papers on the symbolism of inordinate acts of cruelty enacted instrumentally against the self, re-dressing and re-naming what was, and shifting to what is, into the darkness, is the work of being trully human, to me.
Language is birthed as we break our symbiotic relationship to our maternal figure in human development. That question of whether all symbol formation, from the time we are small children onwards is an attempt to crawl back into the womb, in some ways, speaks to me of the unity discourse, the basis of so much of our spirituality.
Where be the One?
or should it be
Why be the One?
'Where, living or dying, I am still alone;
Here where North, the night, the berg of death
Crowd me out of the ignorant darkness,
I see at last that all the knowledge
I wrung from the darkness—that the darkness flung me—
Is worthless as ignorance: nothing comes from nothing,
The darkness from the darkness. Pain comes from the darkness
And we call it wisdom. It is pain.'
I'm working through an essay on the symbolism that is recruited by a self-harmer in acts of self-mutilation. In psychoanalytic theory, a thread from Klein through to Segal through to Woodruff runs, addressing this question, the detailed accounts of the traumatised psychotic patients seeming to me to become more sensitive, more astute, through these women's accounts, over time, through history. Psychoanalysis is not a well established academic field, and it's a field that does not lend itself easily to models and systematisation, at that. Offerings made available through journal articles in this field speak of a uniqueness that is perhaps an outcome of this un-trammelled corner of human expertise - the papers tend to have a feel of direct transmission from the author's fingertips, and seem free, in some ways of the overbearing APA standardisation procedures that I'm now accustomed to.
The modelling that is valuable for me, here, comes directly from the practitioners, not neat Venn diagrams and statistical significance at alpha 0.05. The modelling comes from the increasing emphasis through history placed in their own accounts of what is occurring, for them, as they work with, and beside, these patients. The most powerful accounts seem to arise through their explication of their involvement in countertransference, through the understanding of themselves, as they were, as they are, that they are brave enough to release to the world, in, of all places, academic papers.
[sharp change of subject]
These lines from Jarrell's poem grounds a place to work from, for me - it speaks not of annihilation but more of that continual starting over, the continual re-dressing that has to take place, as the world shifts through time, of what we thought we knew. Like these women who publish papers on the symbolism of inordinate acts of cruelty enacted instrumentally against the self, re-dressing and re-naming what was, and shifting to what is, into the darkness, is the work of being trully human, to me.
Language is birthed as we break our symbiotic relationship to our maternal figure in human development. That question of whether all symbol formation, from the time we are small children onwards is an attempt to crawl back into the womb, in some ways, speaks to me of the unity discourse, the basis of so much of our spirituality.
Where be the One?
or should it be
Why be the One?
Saturday, May 1, 2010
Friday, April 30, 2010
Me and A Gun - Tori Amos Live
The power of this song, for me, comes from the paradox of Tori singing it - her voice is soft and light and controlled (well, with the odd wrenched lift and cry) but the emotional labour and emphasis of the song is carried in the expressiveness of her face. I've seen other performances where the characters in the story seemingly flit across her face as she sings the lines, and she flirts with the audience a little in the beginning, small smiles and steely eyes and quirked eyebrows and tongue to the corner of the upper lip, to end up dragged into the current of despair and anguish and hopelessness, a torture that is the direct response to her experience.
She says it took her seven years to open up, to allow vulnerability to be intertwined into self-expression sufficiently to release herself from the psychological suffering that was an outcome of the rape:
"In the song, I say it was Me and a Gun but it wasn't a gun. It was a knife he had. And the idea was to take me to his friends and cut me up, and he kept telling me that, for hours. And if he hadn't needed more drugs I would have been just one more news report, where you see the parents grieving for their daughter. And I was singing hymns, as I say in the song, because he told me to. I sang to stay alive [italics mine]. Yet I survived that torture, which left me urinating all over myself and left me paralysed for years. That's what that night was all about, mutilation, more than violation through sex.
I really do feel as though I was psychologically mutilated that night and that now I'm trying to put the pieces back together again. Through love, not hatred. And through my music. My strength has been to open again, to life, and my victory is the fact that, despite it all, I kept alive my vulnerability."
My mind chases over and over the lyrics:
'I don't think you'll be back in three days time
So you choose well'
I resonate, far far too strongly, perhaps, with these lines.
Not Gods. Not Eternity. Not Ephemeral. Not Known.
Monday, April 26, 2010
Contemporary Castration
An interesting component of my coursework:
Modern Day Emasculations: Triumphs, Tragedies, and Transcendence
Various populations of genetic males seek either chemical or surgical castration in order to change their life. These range from advanced prostate cancer patients who are simply trying to improve their chances of survival, to male-to-female transsexuals who are trying to change their fundamental identity as male. In his lecture, Professor Wassersug will focus on modern day voluntary eunuchs – males who desire to be emasculated yet do not wish to be female. Some have a nonspecific Gender Identity Disorder, others a Body Integrity Identity Disorder, and some have extreme sadomasochistic paraphilias (fetishes). Professor Wassersug will shed light on what motivates these men – why, how, and where they get castrated, and the consequences of their castration.
When: 7th May at 4pm
Where: DT A Lecture Theatre, Heydon Laurence Bldg (A08), The University of Sydney
Modern Day Emasculations: Triumphs, Tragedies, and Transcendence
Various populations of genetic males seek either chemical or surgical castration in order to change their life. These range from advanced prostate cancer patients who are simply trying to improve their chances of survival, to male-to-female transsexuals who are trying to change their fundamental identity as male. In his lecture, Professor Wassersug will focus on modern day voluntary eunuchs – males who desire to be emasculated yet do not wish to be female. Some have a nonspecific Gender Identity Disorder, others a Body Integrity Identity Disorder, and some have extreme sadomasochistic paraphilias (fetishes). Professor Wassersug will shed light on what motivates these men – why, how, and where they get castrated, and the consequences of their castration.
When: 7th May at 4pm
Where: DT A Lecture Theatre, Heydon Laurence Bldg (A08), The University of Sydney
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Dark Beautiful Things
'The Sacrifice' composed by Michael Nyman, from the movie 'The Piano' (1993) written and directed by Jane Campion.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
