Saturday, July 31, 2010

Phenomenology via Kupers per Merleau Ponty

With Merleau Ponty, per Kupers in the paper listed below, phenomenology undergoes a radical return to the body and to embodiment as the basic nexus of human living, where we always already are situated in meaningful inter-relationship.

Merleau-Ponty’s overall ambition was to disclose the roots of rationality and Being, through extending Husserl’s account of the ‘lived body’ to include a body that experiences and is experienced, thus overcoming Cartesian dualism. For Merleau-Ponty, the body is already lived, meaningful, relational and intentional.  He not only rejects referentialist-representationalism, following Heidegger, he builds an anti-foundationalist, anti-essentialist, non-reductive ‘open media’ account of embodiment, rearticulating the relationship between subject and object.

Returning to the life-world and things themselves, for Merleau-Ponty, is going back to the way we experience before we begin to theorise. We are embodied as subjects into an inter-subjective and inter-objective continuum, an embedded existence. Interestingly, Kupers proposes that as unruly and unpredictable realities, per Merleau-Ponty, bodies themselves are de-centering, providing a less-than-perfect means of boundary building, for subjectivity.

We learn to move our bodies pre-reflectively, and thus there is a level of intentionality below our explicit acts, manifesting itself in bodily engagement that is our primary rapport with the world.

‘A movement is learned when the body has understood it, that is, when it has incorporated itself into its world, and to move one’s body is to aim at things through it, it is to allow oneself to respond to their call’ (Merleau-Ponty, 1962)

An operative intentionality establishes and utilises secret bonds of correspondence and interdependency, which constitute our reciprocal involvements. The interaction thus inferred within an ever-present world frame opens up an orientation to a post-dualistic ontology in Merleau-Ponty’s late works. Seeing the pre-personal, the personal and the interpersonal as chiasmic, intertwined and reversible, we are allowed the possibility of understanding phenomena with greater profundity. The patterns of meaningful being and action exist neither in the mind nor in the external world, they are ‘in-between’, an inter-relationality of individual, social and trans-subjective practices.

‘Within this fleshly being the in-between is as ‘fullness of void’ understood as a creative and fulfilling emptiness.’

It is via this in-between, which is the birth place of intertwined individual identity, that we encounter social and inter-objective knowledge, realities and creative relationships. With this kind of relational ontology, a proto-integral interpretation becomes available, of phenomenology as precipitating a birth into an awareness easily identified as 'Integral'.

Kupers, W. (2009). The Status and Relevance of Phenomenology for Integral Research: Or Why Phenomenology Is More and Different than an ‘Upper Left’ or Zone #1 Affair. Integral Review, 5(1), 51 – 95. 

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

The Aim of Attention

'The goal of attention, or shamatha, practice is to become aware of awareness. Awareness is the basis, or what you might call the “support,” of the mind. It is steady and unchanging, like the pole to which the flag of ordinary consciousness is attached. When we recognize and become grounded in awareness of awareness, the “wind” of emotion may still blow. But instead of being carried away by the wind, we turn our attention inward, watching the shifts and changes with the intention of becoming familiar with that aspect of consciousness that recognizes Oh, this is what I’m feeling, this is what I’m thinking. As we do so, a bit of space opens up within us. With practice, that space—which is the mind’s natural clarity—begins to expand and settle. We can begin to watch our thoughts and emotions without necessarily being affected by them quite as powerfully or vividly as we’re used to. We can still feel our feelings, think our thoughts, but slowly our identity shifts from a person who defines him- or herself as lonely, ashamed, frightened, or hobbled by low self-esteem to a person who can look at loneliness, shame, and low self-esteem as movements of the mind.'

-Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche, The Aim of Attention (Summer 2009)


The whole article was really worth it's easy reading....


Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Psychological Stepping Stones - Knowledge Through Appreciation Empowerment

This empowerment aims at assisting the student to feelingly envision, and envision feelingly, the dynamics of Being as the masculine-feminine ‘polarity’, as occuring in their rapturous lovemaking. She is given to understand the varying degrees of delight as they are blended within the body, as a multi-levelled system. The vision occurs between between rapture in ecstatic intensity, and the everyday-'I', and the idea is to give a tangible sensuous form through the vision, where the masculine and feminine address and disclose to each other their embodied sexuality:

‘Being’s coming to presence and being interpreted as world is the reification of it’s being in a supramundane world, where bliss reigns supreme, and in it
Being’s amorously frolicking pristine awareness triumphs as bliss supreme.
By engaging n the passionate desire between ‘activity’ and ‘appreciation’ emancipation is won; therefore you too
Engage and participate in this ceaseless amorous frolicking!
Therein lies bliss supreme.’

Both Being’s coming-to-presence and interpretation as an environing world and it’s organismic life forms in it’s totality, since time before time, are understood to have endured in what is it’s linear transformation of deiform energies, that presences itself in men and women. Their bonding in ‘activity' and 'appreciation’ expresses itself in bliss. By this bliss do we come to know the superthought-intentionality of the Victorious One (one’s own ecstatic intensity, identifiable as bliss supreme).

There is a symmetry break that marks Being’s open state coming-to-presence and actual radiant closed state, the envelope into which Being wraps itself as itself, it’s ‘ownmostness’. Because of it’s dynamics inherited from the virtual state, a further bifurcation takes place, into the realm of gods and goddesses. Any symmetry break implies an increase in complexity that carries with it the challenge to ‘get to the source or origin of it’. The feminine here plays a vital role (and here I had been trying to steer clear of feminist discourse, huh).

In her capacity of expressing and Being the expression of Being’s openness/nothingness, a spaciousness and a mystery, she is able to open up the unformed with it’s immense wealth of open possibilities or to offer value perception or appreciative awareness that is active as an inspiration and is revered in its role as ‘heroine’. The rousing of masculine activity in response, that is made to express itself in the four dynamic regimes of psychic energy interchange results in self-transcendence, in bliss supreme. Bliss supreme goes beyond the four postulates of existence and nonexistence, eternalism and nihilism, and thus is known as four delights (I love this!)

Through this empowerment the student is made to move not simply from one aspect ‘appreciative’ to another one ‘pristine awareness’ as if one was higher, but they learn to live, harmoniously, with both at the same time.

Perhaps showing either his own stripes or the stripes of the tradition he describes, Gunther here has identified ‘women’ (actually – I’ve interposed the term 'feminine' and stripped out the comment that is sort of chauvinistic) approximately as sex objects. In some way this is meant to be reconciled by a quote that he gives from the Klong-gsal (a Dzogchen text) which, is actually a quote I need to apply to my own self, objectified:

Despising a woman is tantamount to denigrating Being’s spaciousness,  and
Withdrawing yourself from pleasure you court the deepest hell.


With what value, and how deep goes, a commitment, to the self?

Ref:

Gunther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.

Monday, July 19, 2010

Being's Holomovement

(Being having risen in it’s wholeness as a presence out of Being)

Because of it’s thereness as if it were some resonance
samsara and nirvana are an unbroken whole;

Because of it’s thereness as if it were light frequencies
everything that is going to come-to-presence is an inner lucency;

Because of it’s thereness as if it were some gestalt
the cognitive capacity does not lose itself in the extraneous;

Because of it’s thereness as if it were a pristine awareness everything
that is coming-to-presence is of an insubstantial-dissipative nature;

Because of it’s thereness as if it were non-dual
one’s cognitive capacity abides in it’s focusedness.

Because of it’s thereness as if it were free from perimeters
 it does not abide in any of the confines;

Because of it’s thereness as an impure gate
the emergence of an interpreted world never stops.

Because of it’s thereness as a pure pristine awareness gate, Being’s possibilising dynamics
expresses itself in the connectedness of a mother with her child.


Rin-chen spungs-pa - from 'The Sun's Life Giving Force' - Padma Legs-grub, 1608

Full title: 'The sun's life giving force or the explanation of the intrinsic meaning of the indestructible light that is the sublime and most mysterious and unsurpassable message of all spiritual pursuits.'

Who could walk past that tome on a bookshelf? :)

Psychological Stepping Stones - The Mystery Empowerment

For anyone reading this who might be familiar with Integral discourse on masculine and feminine ‘types’, I actually propose that the association between the masculine and feminine and emptiness and form identified in this empowerment, is orthogonal to the relationship as formed in Integral parlance.  It’s been mind-bending and beneficial, for me to spend time with this ‘upside-down’ version of the masculine feminine relationship – it feels similar to comparing the Hindu masculine passive feminine active divinities with the Western mythology’s masculine agency and feminine’s communion, for my money.

Using a skull filled with the ‘elixir of immortality’, this ritual uses the same four dynamic regimes of the body as the first, and aims at making the student experience the mystery of the creative forces that shape both her biological existence plus the existence of the universe.


Overflowing bliss supreme, self-existent, this skull is
Brimful  with the mutual passion rinsed of the pseudoconcrete.
My dear child of the highest life form, empowered by it
May you come to possess the power over these same forces as they organise themselves into their breeze like movement in a coherent web of chreods.

The bliss supreme is given to arise in the downward flow of creative fluids that are purer than pure in the masculine and feminine aspects of Being’s self existent pristine awareness.  The description by Gunther includes a sense that the power that ‘organises itself’ is genetic material, and it is a component of the lucency of Being’s ownmostness. This has an enduring vibration that represents a paradox - colourlessness versus the full-colour spectrum, one virtual, the other actual. Thus Being becomes, through vibrations. Becoming is directionless, having no endpoint beyond it's own expression. This spectrum is felt in the heart, the ‘tsitta’ palace.

The projective character of Being’s ownmostness sets up a boundary of vibrationary patterns which may be understood as a kind of spatialisation. It is referred to as the self-informing, self organising dynamics of Being’s ownmostness as pure light. Immense and rare beauty radiates from here.

While space-and-time binding here are non-linear, the phase is referred to as the self-organising dynamics of Being’s luminescence into the complementarity and inseparability of masculine and feminine. It is intensely felt as a cognitive dynamic in the immediacy of experience, as a complementarity/inseparability of Being’s openness/nothingness with it’s lighting up/coming to presence. Lighting up is seen as a masculine intensity, and openness-nothingness is the feminine intensity. Precisely because the feminine is spacious like the sky, openness-nothingness is the very possibilising dynamic of Being. The masculine lighting up in all it’s bright brilliance adorns the possibilising dynamic (the feminine) which would literally otherwise be nothing.
The mutualising passion in the intimate embrace antedates any materialisation in any other phase of the system’s dynamics. In Dzogchen it is so clear, here, there is no rigid separation between the psychic and the physical, and there is no Western battle, between them – rather they give themselves to each other, in imaginative, total, playful abandonment.

The masculine and feminine creative dynamics may be conceived of as an instability phase, where the system is about to undergo a symmetry ‘break’ that becomes the way of self-actualisation. This way composes of two information carriers, called:

‘information carrier in the service of building up one’s commonly accepted physical reality’ and 
‘information carrier in the service of maintaining one’s spiritual heritage’.

The latter resides in the light chreods, as an effulgence that by virtue of it’s own motility evolves into a web of pristine awareness modes fed by ‘the sea of bliss supreme’ as the ultimate organising principle.


Ref:

Gunther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.

Saturday, July 17, 2010

Psychological Stepping Stones - The Flask Empowerment

Five flasks are used to symbolise the washing away of dross that has accumulated to make an individual blind to her own potential.  There is the evolution of the mandala, or a spiral movement involved in the empowerment process, where the starting point is identical with the ending result – each flask illustrates the interdependence or correspondence with the structure and function of the flask.
To start, the flask in the center is lifted above the initiate’s head and a drop of water serves to cleanse the dynamic regime. The first utterance is pronounced at the same time:

This flask of Being’s possibilising dynamics in it’s field-like expanse
Is filled with the natural water of Being’s openness/nothingness radiance
My dear child, being empowered by it
May you understand the abidingness of the field-like expanse.

The field-like expanse is the source of all meanings.

The next, eastern-point flask is raised to the initiate’s heart, representing the mental/spiritual dimension, with the words:

This flask of Being’s vitalising core intensity that is something not born, thus that will not die
It is filled with the natural substance of it’s incessantness.
My dear child, being empowered by it
May you understand Being’s reality in not posing any danger.

This is the dynamic of the mirror-like pristine awareness mode.  The vibrant dimension of pure experience that is without birth and open like the sky, an ecstatic intensity that does never cease, this is the presencing of Being’s pure actuality. This complementarity and indivisibility of the field and it’s excitation as experience is what is meant and is illustrated by the flask and the water in it. Gunther highlights that via the establishing of a relationship between subjective, inner reality and objective, outer reality, access to a holistic and self-consistent reality is gained.
The next, southern-point flask is lifted to the throat, symbolising the dynamic regime of the linguistic, symbolic:
This flask of Being’s self-existing pristine awareness in action
Is filled with the natural substances of objects and sensuous pleasures.
My dear child empowered by it
May you come to possess the power of your thoughts, becoming spontaneously realised.

This empowerment consists in exploring the wealth of qualities the world holds, a venturing into what has always been there, but has been un-noticed, in being there. From this vantage point, all that we ever need is available to us, and everything that comes into existence must be consistent with itself and everything else.
Gunther notes here the sheer ecstasy that intensifies, with each level of the initiation.
At which point I must admit - I’m so easily carried, on words.  :-)

The next western-point flask is raised to the navel – for the dynamic regime of the person’s physical/physiological dimension, which has been set acourse by the sexual act in excitement, plateau, climax and resolution, the whole of which has a physical and a spiritual dimension.
This flask, of Being’s impassibility, that is not something that has been born,
Is filled with the streaming profusion of bliss supreme
My dear child, being empowered by this
May you come to possess the power of a passion that is not subjectively appropriated.

This empowerment takes us to bliss supreme, which is the impassibility of pure experience that is without birth but has been so since time before time.  The fundmental forces moving through the hierarchically organised dynamic regimes shifts energy, from descending into details, to ascending into enriched meaningfulness, as well as damming up the psychospiritual potential, which is the bliss supreme.

The process ends in pure creativity at the northern-most point, extending over all levels and establishing it’s own dynamic dimension, with the words:

This flask symbolising Being’s pristine awareness in its insubstantiality
Is filled with the substances of the five kinds of motility that never stop.
My dear child being empowered by it
May you come to possess the power of Being’s superb creativity, in all it’s completeness.

What is meant here is illustrated in the complementarity/indivisibility of the flask and the water, the vibrant dimension of the in-substantiability of Being’s pristine awareness as a function of it’s ecstatic intensity, that acts in ultimate emancipation, since time before time.
There is a subtle distinction, threaded through here, between understanding and possessing. The possibilising dynamics of the whole mirrors itself in us, and we are now called upon to act out the possibilities of what we see, so that they become our assets in the true sense of the word. The power which is our attention is drawn by the empowerments, and roused into self-realisation we possess and then understand, in, and of, ourselves.

Outwardly, by having acquired and possessing the power of experiencing, this enables us to symbolically recreate the presencing of the condition of dissolving into supramundane reals;
Inwardly, by having acquired and possessing the power of experiencing the ‘phantasmal’ body, the material concretisation of beliefs about one’s body dissolve into sheer lucency;
Arcanely, by having acquired and possessing the power of oneself as Being’s vastness and ecstatic intensity, the trend of being divided against oneself and slipping into mistaken identifications stops by itself.

The empowerment seeks to effect a transition from the narrowly circumscribed, nonimaginative discursive mind to a place of lowering of conceptual restraints, releasing into emancipatory dynamics. Imagination is indispensible for coming to an understanding of the self, in the perception of a gestalt structure, embodying a meaningfully organised experience. The cognitive principle is immanent, not in a solid spatial structure, but in the way the system organises, renews and resolves. The meaning rich gestalt, in own-space, ends us where we started.

In Being’s core intensity that is Being’s superdiaphaneity that has no name
There is neither possession nor non-possession.
Non-understanding gives rise to duality.



Ref:

Gunther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.

Tuesday, July 13, 2010

Psychological Stepping Stones - Introduction

There are a series of subtle-body noticings that come with working through the four Dzogchen empowerments, as translated here by Herbert Gunther in Chapter 5 of 'Meditation Differently'.

I have no claim, whatsoever, on any Dzogchen lineage. I have this book, a reverence, and some attention that I'm training my will upon. This book has helped deepen my appreciation for exactly what initiation, or empowerment, can liberate. I do not claim in any way that there is a spiritual athleticism, to be practiced, in working through these four stages of empowerment, simply by reading these words, strengthening visualisation processes, and spacing out the stages, across time. I only have the record of what went on, for me, when I worked through this material.

Gunther highlights the empowerment journey as progressing from the external to the internal, and from the arcane to the super-arcane. Linearity, however, definitely doesn't apply, in this work.

The purpose of the empowerments is to mobilise the individual's inner potential and have it mature into what is best described as that individual's autonomy as an expression and a measure of their relations with their environment. There is a liberation, in the growth of cognitive capacity in emancipation from organismic and representational restrictions. It's highest expression would then be what has been termed the ec-static intensity as it becomes experienced in it's pristine awareness modes [italics mine].

'the river of the empowering force that is nothing else but
    the beingness of Being;
the river of the empowering force that is
     self existing resonance;
the river of the empowering force that is
      the five pristine awareness modes;
the river of the empowering force that is the five gnosemes
      the dominant figures in the prototypes of conscious life.' p 50.

These rivers are associated with developmental lines that constitute the dynamic body image, ranging from the affective-organismic to the spiritual and ecstatic.

An individual finds themselves always already in a social context. In this place, interaction and communication are constitutive of the individual, and evoke corresponding processes, when shared. Ritual is a kind of social language that serves to symbolise social communication.

In the first of the the initiatory processes, a flask of water is used, to symbolise purification, a restoration and recognition of an individual's highest potential. The Dzogchen thinker's realm is Being's abidingness. This endogenous pristine awareness has central dynamics that are already 'on the move' - a mandala or spiral movement that starts from the whole, of Being's spontaneity. In it's movement it forms a socio-human reality that is itself a process of uncovering a universe in which the human individual is being disclosed to an understanding of her being.

'The outer is but inner, raised to a state of mystery' - Novalis

The formative outer phase is the activity configurational setting, that is a reflection as the way [italics mine]. The empowerments are imaged as occurring in the mandala of the process structure that is the self presentation of Being to itself, by way of symbolic re-creation, in the uniquely singled out cognitive space of the experiencer's whole multi-levelled body awareness. This self sensing process reflexively instantiates itself via:

1) Sense-perceptions - iterative feedback between outer and inner world where we continously re-cast and re-mold our experience of reality;
2) intensification of the sense-perception process.

Before initiation it is vital that the student learn to see themselves fresh, with new eyes. To see things as meanings. Transformative vision applies equally to household utensils as it does to the conch, a mirror, a lute, fruits and a scarf (symbols of sensuous pleasures). Transformative vision applies also to fellow household members. Five flasks with five scarves symbolising the complementarity of male/female aspects of the protopatterns of synergetic consciousness are arranged at the five expected points. Learning to see household members on the energetic level sees these scarves become vital identifiers, the territory of gods and goddesses.

The gate opens, the sweat begins. :)


Ref:

Gunther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.