Sunday, July 17, 2011

Risking Recognition

"When Hegel introduces the notion of recognition in the section on lordship and bondage in The Phenomenology of Spirit, he narrates the primary encounter with the Other in terms of self-loss. "Self-consciousness...has come out of itself...it has lost itself, for it finds itself as an other being". One might understand Hegel to be describing merely a pathological state in which a fantasy of absorption by the Other constitutes an early or primitive experience. But he is saying something more. He is saying that whatever consciousness is, whatever the self is, will find itself only through a reflection of itself in another. To be itself, it must pass through self-loss, and when it passes through, it will never be "returned" to what it was. To be reflected in or as another will have a double significance for consciousness, however, since consciousness will, through the reflection, regain itself in some way. But it will, by virtue of the external status of reflection, regain itself as external to itself, and hence, continue to lose itself. Thus the relationship to the Other will invariably be ambivalent. The price of self-knowledge will be self-loss, and the Other poses the possibility of both securing and undermining self-knowledge. What becomes clear, though, is that the self never returns to itself free of the Other, that it's relationality becomes constitutive of who the self is."

"Negation is a destruction that is survived."

Ref: 

Butler, J. (2010). Longing for Recognition in (K Hutchings and T Pulkkinen, Eds) Hegel's Philosophy and Feminist Thought: Beyond Antigone?. New York: Palgrave. p. 109 - 132.

Saturday, June 25, 2011

Engaging the new

A new maxim crystallises as layers of memory, pressure and concern reverberate together in a new situation. 

The new is ushered into being through processes that exceed either rational thought or the derivation of pragmatic implications from universal principles. To engage with the territory of the new we might turn to the immanent naturalists. Via immanent naturalism we might project an open temporal horizon exceeding human mastery, irreducible to radical transcendence. Here we might list Democritus, Spinoza, Thoreau, Deleuze, Foucault, whereas those embracing immanence in a world of becoming sustained with a trace of transcendence include Bergson, William James and AN Whitehead.

Both groups emphasise remaining sustained in fecund moments of duration, where care for the world, informed by exquisite sensitivity in an unpredictable moment, sets the conditions for the ushering in of new ideas, maxims, becomings. All modern thinkers listed are philosophers of time as becoming - time for them is not linear, circular or purposive, rather time periodically (!) folds the new into being in a universe that is intrinsically open to an uncertain degree.

This way, emergent formations are not reducible to patterns of probability or efficient causality. Rather, becoming occurs as a periodic intersection between different force fields, where the psychological, biological, social, cultural, geographical and climatic forces set on different tiers of chrono-time infect each other, in part through periodic emergence of new and surprising capacities for autopoesis when such collisions occur, in part through patterns of reverberation back and forth between collision and autopoesis during periods of disequilibrium.

A world of becoming is not only open to an uncertain degree, but each temporal force field in it periodically encounters an outside that affects it profoundly. Transcendence, for those that embrace it, typically demands an idea of the outside.

The relative stability or equilibrium of the force fields within may be disturbed by varied means - a powerful virus jumps species, a period of capitalist growth accelerates climate change, a group of devout Christians encounter Buddhism and become thus irreversibly transformed in view, and so on.

Dwelling in fecund moment where the layered past communicates with a new encounter, something second to the new is ushered into the world, filtered by duration and touched by the sensitivity and intelligence with which it is engaged. It cannot be represented before it appears - it has no shape to represent. It first emerges as a sense and later as an idea, and for all we know the change between may be comparable to the passage of carbon, from nonlife to life. The latter is certainly irreducible to that from which it emerged.

There is something deep and still in here, about causation through resonance, about the nature of disequilibrium, induced.  

Ref:
Connolly, W.E. (2010). Belief, Spirituality and Time, in Varieties of Secularism in a Secular Age (Edited by Michael Warner, Jonathan VanAntwerpen, Craig Calhoun), Cambridge: Harvard University Press: 126-144.

Friday, April 15, 2011

Absolute Subjectivity

From Никола́й Алекса́ндрович Бердя́ев, Nikolai Berdyaev, Russian Orthodox theologian and existential philosopher:


'Spirit is never an object; nor is spiritual reality an objective one. In the so-called objective world there is no such nature, thing, or objective reality as spirit. Hence it is easy to deny the reality of spirit. God is spirit because he is not object, because he is subject....In objectification there are no primal realities, but only symbols [emphasis mine]. The objective spirit is merely a symbolism of spirit. Spirit [as absolute subject] is realistic while culture and social life are symbolical. In the object there is never any reality, but only the symbol of reality. The subject alone has reality'.


I've been deeply entranced recently by the inward turn, spoken of by the mystics, and the means by which symbol is absorbed into a deepened, stilled sense - where symbol becomes reality. To attempt to explain this, one way to view the sacraments, in the Christian tradition, is not as symbol, but as living reality - the bread and the wine becoming the skeleton, the bare naked bones, of spirit, present, here manifest on earth. One way to think of anamnesis is not just as memory of the stories and travails of Jesus' life, but through manifest existence as replicated in memory, through time, all universally is present, as sacred, each moment both revealed and unrevealed, as the unborn, unbegotten, unknown One.


It's not the case that all traditions point in the same direction. It is the case that at a certain level, the reality that is revealed becomes subsumed into an all encompassing vista - and there is a realisation beyond this (beyond Witness), where the sense of vista is removed, and the never-not-present eternally begotten now permeates consciousness.


This is my first real attempt at writing about some of the themes here from my own perspective. I apologise to the extent that my mangled use of English (and perhaps Russian) may have infringed upon your sensibilities.

Quote sourced from:

Wilber, K. (1977). The Spectrum of Consciousness. Wheaton, Illinois: Theosophical Publishing House. p. 82.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Bergson on ego - dynamic identity

I enjoy this quote from Bergson for the way that he calibrates the concept of ego, here. There are implications for integral's identification/disidentification/reintegration fulcrums, as well as the formation of state-stages, all contained in this one neat paragraph, for my thinking:

'Pure duration is the form which the succession of our conscious states assumes when our ego lets itself live, and when it refrains from separating it's present state from its former states. For this purpose it need not be entirely absorbed in the passing sensation or idea; for then, on the contrary, it would no longer endure. Nor need it forget its former states: it is enough that, recalling these states, it does not set them alongside its actual state as one point alongside another, but forms both the past and the present states into an organic whole, as happens when we recall the notes of a tune, melting, so to speak, into one another'. (Bergson, 2001, p.100)

In this way, the past, present and future are blended into a unity, without denial, without subordination. The past, present and future can be apprehended perhaps as a movement, a deepening and ripening of quality and intensity. Non-spatialised, non-representational, distinctly felt. Bergson's concept of identity does not entail the concept of a separate entity - free from autopoiesis, all boundaries, all concepts of boundaries, are broken, and direct experience in-forms meaning. Fluid processes, affective responses, the body and the mind, all at once, present, is identity.

When I come across something like this there is this thrill that runs through my whole being - more subtle than an 'aha!' moment, I become more alive by virtue of what I am given to see.


Ref:

Bergson, H. (2001). Time and Free Will: An Essay on the Immediate Data of Consciousness. New York: Dover

Monday, February 28, 2011

Transtradition Criticism - April DeConick


April DeConick has a blog called 'The Forbidden Gospels', which is thoroughly worth visiting, not only to pay respects, shall we say, for the wisdom and insight that she brings to apocryphal scripture, but also for her deep appreciation for the knotty postmodern legacy encountered in the fields of the humanities (I'm right in her target audience, here).

Here are her comments as she approaches 'What Science Offers the Humanities: Integrating Body and Culture' (2008) by Edward Slingerland:

'To return to Slingerland. He argues that postmodern theory has swept through the Academy, leaving us suspicious of any truth-claim and with "a conviction that the distinguishing mark of sophisticated scholarship is an ability to engage with a prescribed pantheon of theorists" rather than serious study of primary texts. What was fun at first "has left us with an intellectual hangover" (2008, 1), luxuriating in language for language's sake.

I couldn't agree more. In my opinion, we are stranded in a place of nowhere, immobilized by disembodied discourses, authorless and textless, outside of history. With nothing empirical, with no sameness, we are lost in a jumble of difference. We are left to describe what we see as ours, with no power to interpret beyond this. Even these meager descriptions are left in an ethical vacuum to be siphoned off and co-opted to support nefarious purposes.

The Humanities are dying and we are the ones who are responsible to save them.

The big question is HOW? Slingerland offers a solid solution. He says that we need to get our act together and learn from scientists how human beings operate, particularly as embodied cognitive beings. He demonstrates how humanists operate within outdated models of anthropology, and need to come to terms with the fact that science has discovered fundamental things about the human being. That we need to take embodiment seriously or be doomed to spinning tales inside of tales.

In Slingerland's words: "The fact that these body-minds are, have always been, and will always continue to be part of the world of things effectively short-circuits the epistemological skepticism that permeates postmodern thinking. A nondualistic approach to the person promises no privileged access to eternal, objective truths, but is based upon the belief that commonalities of human embodiment in the world can result in a stable body of shared knowledge, verified (at least provisionally) by proofs based on common perceptual access. By breaching the mind-body divide - by bringing the human mind back into contact with a rich and meaningful world of things - this approach to the humanities starts from an embodied mind that is always in touch with the world, as well as a pragmatic mode of truth or verification that takes the body and the physical world seriously" (2008, 8).'

Read it all in her post:

Check out the book on Amazon:

Monday, February 21, 2011

Prior to anéantissement, separation

Because I read this earlier today, and she nails it.

'For insofar as I ask of Love something for myself on account of love, I will be with myself in the life of the spirit, in the shadow of the sun where one cannot see the subtle images of the drawing power of divine Love and of the divine generation'.

Marguerite Porete ~ The Mirror of Simple Souls.

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Phantasy

'But I want to interpret your midnight dreams, and unmask that phenomenon, your night. And make you admit that I dwell in it as your most fearsome adversity. So that you can finally realise what your greatest ressentiment is. And so that with you I can fight to make the earth my own, and stop allowing myself to be a slave to your nature. And so that you stop wanting to be the only god.' (Irigaray, 1991; cf Nietzsche, 1954)

Ref:
Anderson, P.S. (1998). A Feminist Philosophy of Religion, Massachusetts: Blackwell Publishers.