Thursday, September 15, 2011

Sinking

Fallen
Legs out from under, flat out

Earth element
She tickles and teases backs of legs
Arms, body
Her jealous fronds
Tease and glide
Ants, tiny legs, buzzing insect
Creep, hover, love,
Into skin
Sensuous

Sun rains down
Feel, become
Intensity

Forehead expansive through shoulder thigh toe
Millions of tiny red and white in-beams
Shudder
Deep joy, radiance, right back.

Lungs fill and
Sink, deeper in her supple, pliant, forgiving
Encompassing pervading enthralling
Beingness

Ecstacy, rage, bliss
Mute

One.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Hegel on death

'Death, as we may call that unreality, is the most terrible thing....But the life of Mind is not one that shuns death, and keeps clear of destruction; it endures death, and in death maintains it's being. It only wins to its truth when it finds itself utterly torn asunder. It is this mighty power....Spirit is this power only by looking the negative in the face, and dwelling in it....the magic power that converts the negative into being' ~ The Phenomenology of Mind

In Recognition

Once, as the prophet Elijah was walking along, he met Lilith and her host. He said to her: O Lilith, whither do you go with your unclean host? And she replied: My Lord Elijah, I am about to go to the woman who has born a child to bring her to the sleep of death, to take the child born to her away from her, to drink its blood, to suck the morrow from its bones and to leave its flesh over. Elijah answered and said: I place you under a great ban, so that you may be turned into a speechless stone through the will of God. And Lilith said: My Lord, for God's sake, lift this spell so that I might fly away. I swear in the name of God that I will avoid the paths that lead to a woman with a newborn child. Whenever I see or hear my name, I will disappear at once. I will tell you my secret names. Whenever you pronounce these neither I nor my host will have the power to enter the house of a woman in childbirth and torment her. I swear to you to reveal my names so that you may write them down and hang them in the room where the newborn child lies...Whosoever knows these names, and writes them down, ensures that I will flee from the newborn child.'
~ Jewish Babylonian myth of Lilith

Recognition is so organic to the human experience of feeling in existence that its ubiquitous presence goes unseen. It is naturally present from the moment of birth, that first exquisite moment of eye-to-eye contact between mother and baby at birth.

Recogniton confirms our very humanity, ourself, to self.

Jessica Benjamin uses sunlight as a metaphor for recognition - the essential element for a plant's constant transformation of substance.

Near-synonyms for recognition, dance, such:

- affirm
- reverie
- acknowledge
- know
- accept
- understand
- empathise
- take in
- tolerate
- appreciate
- see
- find familiar
- become intimate with
- love

Recognition brings to life, in the kernel of recognition is the endless play into ongoing integration, even in death, even in death.

Longing for Recognition


One of the distinctive contributions of Benjamin’s theory is to insist that intersubjectivity is not the same as object relations, and that 'intersubjectivity' adds to object relations the notion of an external Other, one who exceeds the psychic construction of the object in complementary terms. What this means is that whatever the psychic and fantasmatic relation to the object may be, it ought to be understood in terms of the larger dynamic of recognition. The relation to the object is not the same as the relation to the Other, but the relation to the Other provides a framework for understanding the relation to the object. The subject not only forms certain psychic relations to objects, but the subject is formed by and through those psychic relations. Moreover, these various forms are implicitly structured by a struggle for recognition in which the Other does and does not become dissociable from the object which is psychically represented. This struggle is represented by a desire to enter into a communicative practice with the Other in which recognition takes place neither as an event nor a set of events, but as an onging process, one that also poses the psychic risk of destruction. Whereas Hegel refers to a 'negation' as the risk that recognition always runs, Benjamin retains this term to describe the differentiated aspect of rationality: the other is not me, and from this distinction, certain psychic consequences follow....For Benjamin, humans form psychic relations with Others on the basis of a necessary negation, but not all of those relations must be destructive. Whereas the psychic response that seeks to master and dispel that negation is destructive, that destruction is precisely what needs to be worked through in the process of recognition.





Adapted from:

Ayers, M. (2011). Masculine shame: from succubus to the eternal feminine. London: Routledge.

Butler, J. (2000). Longing for Recognition: Commentary on the Work of Jessica Benjamin. Studies in Gender and Sexuality, 1:27.


Monday, August 15, 2011

Resistance

'....until he sees that absolutely everything he does is resistance, he will secretly continue to move away, to grasp, to seek, and thus to totally prevent the discovery. He will move away without realising he is moving away. If he doesn’t see that all his actions are resistances, he will still believe that there is some move he can make to get to unity consciousness. Until he sees that everything he does is nothing but a moving away, he will simply continue to move away. He will think that he has a choice, an alternative, something to do, some way out. And so he continues to make a move – a move which is always away – and thus a move which erects a barrier to unity consciousness which was not there to begin with.

But at the very point he sees that everything he does is a resistance, a looking away and a moving away, then he has no choice but to surrender. He cannot however, try to do this, or try not to! We have seen that this doesn’t work at all, for both tries are just more moving-away. Rather, it happens itself, spontaneously, when he sees nothing he can do, or not do, will work, because unity is always already the case. The very seeing of the resistance is the dissolution of the resistance, an acknowledgement of the prior unity.

Once this primal resistance begins to dissolve, one’s separate self dissolves with it. For it is not that you, on the one hand, see your moving away , on the other. It might start this way, with you as a separate self seeing the resistance as an activity of yours. But as you begin to see that everything that you do is a resistance, you start to see that even your feeling of being a separate self ‘in here’ is also nothing but a resistance. When you feel yourself, all you feel is a tiny inner tension, a subtle contraction, a subtle moving away. The feeling of self and the feeling of moving away are one and the same. But as this becomes obvious, there are no longer two different feelings here, no longer an experience on one hand and having an experience on the other hand, but only one, single, all-pervasive feeling – the feeling of resistance. You don’t feel this resistance, you are this feeling of resistance. The feeling of self condenses into the feeling of resistance, and both dissolve.

Thus, to the extent this primal resistance dissolves, your separation from the world also dissolves. There spontaneously comes a deep and total surrender of resistance, of the unwillingness to gaze upon the present in all its forms, and thus a dissolution of the boundary you erected between inside and outside. When you no longer are resisting present experience, you no longer have a motive to separate yourself from it. The world and the self return as one single experience, not two different ones.....

 Further, when we are no longer moving away from experience, experience no longer seems to move past us. To no longer resist the present is to see that there is nothing but the present – no beginning, no end, nothing behind it, nothing in front of it. When the past of memory and the future of anticipation are both seen to be present facts, then the slats to this present collapse. The boundaries around this moment fall into this moment, with nowhere else to go. Said an old Zen master,

My self of long ago,
In nature non-existent:
Nowhere to go when dead,
Nothing at all.

Ref:

Wilber, K. (1979).No Boundary: Eastern and Western Approaches to Personal Growth. Boulder: Shambala.

Sunday, August 7, 2011

Absolute Spirit - Hegel and Aurobindo

 Kant ignited a revolution in philosophy with his doctrine of transcendental idealism, which asserted that consciousness is not only receptive in character, but also is constitutive of it’s experiential contents, accomplished through an a priori threefold synthesis in sensation, imagination an cognition.

The original unity of apperception is the unified self-consciousness, or ‘I think’, that accompanies every act of experience. This is not subjective consciousness, per Kant, rather, it is transcendental, objective and impersonal consciousness which itself is presupposed by the empirical, subjective and individual ego.

Hegel appropriates the shape of this logic-based impersonal unity into something he calls ‘Absolute Spirit’, that which sits as a supreme metaphysical category of the highest generality. Its character defines a universal consciousness which entirely creates and projects its own experiential contents and reabsorbs them as self-mediated identity-in-difference. This Absolute is derived as the culminating product of the dialectical process which sublates all abstract opposites, overcoming all one-sided thought determinations at the same time as preserving their ideal moments as a concrete totality.

For Hegel, this moment represents the unification of the knowing subject with that which is known, making possible a true knowledge of ‘things in themselves’, that which Kant had denied.

Theologically, this notion of Absolute also represented the Holy Trinity for Hegel, insofar as the self-differentiated identification of nature and God, or man and the divine, is drawn.

Aurobindo, in the 20th century, appropriated this Hegelian notion of Absolute Spirit, and employed it to radically restructure the architectonic framework of Vedanta into contemporary European terms. It should be noted for Aurobindo that the Absolute was not an outcome of dialectical process, rather, it is a description of an experience of the superconscient phases of awareness, identifiable in yogic concentration, meditation, and contemplation. The Absolute is not a rational or logical consciousness, for Aurobindo, rather, it is a supramental mode of awareness through which Spirit undergoes involution, from Supermind, to Overmind, to Intuitivemind, Illuminedmind, Highermind and physical mind, itself – a felt totality.

Aurobindo’s Absolute raises from the identity of Being (Sat) through radiant supramental intuitive awareness (Chit) to supreme bliss (Ananda). Thus all manifestations of the Absolute have ontological, epistemological and axiological properties.

The categorical scheme of Charles Sanders Pierce also echoes these qualities – of Firstness (aesthetic value), Secondness (existence) and Thirdness (logical structure).

Spirit then, for Hegel and Aurobindo, if not directly, Pierce, is the dynamic three-fold process of the Absolute as a self realising universal consciousness which undergoes a cycle of self-differentiation and self-reconciliation. Hegel criticised the idea of the Absolute as a static oneness as portrayed by Parmenides, Spinoza, Judaism and Vedanta, arguing that it is an attenuated abstraction from the concrete activity of living Spirit which is a triadic process of passing over into otherness and the subsequent restoration of primordial unity now enriched by a moment of difference. The Absolute contains and comprehends three moments in which it posits itself:  eternal Being in and with itself, in the form of universality; the form of manifestation or appearance, Being for another; and the form of return from appearance (Idea, Nature and Spirit).

Idea equates to God in his eternity before the creation of the world – the pure, self-thinking thought. In the second moment, Idea is projected outwards onto Nature, an unconscious system of intelligence, which subsequently undergoes a dialectical self-development, ending in a return to full consciousness of itself as the eternal Absolute.

Heidegger later picks up on the second moment and characterises Being of the Absolute as self-revealing, self-manifesting, coming to presence through emergent blossoming radiating outwards into luminous, lucid Openness.

More than a Creator God, this God has mediation of self with self, this apparent otherness, of Nature, is the very life of Spirit. Spirit multiplies itself into an intersubjective comm-unity of individuals who achieve higher stages of self-realisation precisely through their mutual recognition of one another. For Hegel:

‘It is the real return of self into self [through searching into otherness] which alone makes the depths of God.’ (Hegel, Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion)

Here is Hegel’s structure of the Christian Trinity - God as Spirit differentiates Himself from Himself, posits an other, and becomes man in order to become God.

Aurobindo radically recasts Vedantic ontology in the terminology of this Hegelian living Spirit, through the introduction of a Supermind, the Real-Idea. Supermind is the integral creative consciousness which mediates Satchitananda and the world – the extension of the Absolute into space and time, both static and dynamic.
For Aurobindo, the involution and evolution of Spirit occurs through an ontological spectrum called the ‘Sevenfold Chord of Being’ – the lower hemisphere of Matter-Life-Mind, the middle principle of Supermind through to Satchitananda.

This differs from orthodox Vedanta in several respects. While Shankara viewed world creation to be merely conventional reality and cosmic illusion, dissolved on realisation of the ultimate reality as static Brahman, Sri Aurobindo regards this as fully real. Shankara describes the world as a delusory superimposition of names and forms upon Satchitananda, Sri Aurobindo maintains that reality represents a transformation of consciousness-force, where the lower hemisphere consists in a dazzling panorama of aesthetic value-experience, ultimately itself supreme bliss.

‘From Delight all beings arise, by Delight they exist and grow, to Delight they return.’ (Sri Aurobindo, The Life Divine)

Aurobindo also makes a crucial distinction between higher and lower maya – lower maya is the gross, separated realm, whereas the higher maya represents the illumined supramental experience of all phenomena, the inexhaustible play, or lila, of creative consciousness, all in each and each in all, nonobstruction between the many and the one in the realm of Consciousness-only.

AN Whitehead’s process cosmology comes to mind here as the interfusion of unit-events composed of felt-intensities, arising out of vectoral prehensions (feeling transmissions) and creative synthesis (fusion of many to one).

Aurobindo distinguishes three ‘poises’ of the Absolute – the Transcendent, sheer unity beyond creation, The Universal, where all events occur  simultaneously, and the Individual, the moment of sheer diversity, ordinary mind, successive minutes.

In contrast to Hegel’s system, Aurobindo’s has no return inherent in it’s logical structure, rather, the ecstatic dance of Shiva that characterises lila, spontaneousness, adventure, experimentation, emergent novelty and unpredictability guide it’s expansion. Aurobindo’s evolutionary theory posits a non-linear emergence of something evolutionary principles as different to mind as mind is to life, principles which supercede mentation (principles hinted at by the Supermind concept).

Important to note too is Aurobindo’s Neo-Vedantic theory of integration – where the higher emergent principles function to ‘raise up’ the lower hemisphere of mind, life and matter, and thus transform existence, itself. This is not dissimilar to Hegel’s sublation, which contains three meanings – to overcome (abstract polarities), to preserve (one sided ideal moments from the polarities), to ‘raise up’, into richer, more comprehensive categories.

Ref:
Odin, S. (1981). Sri Aurobindo and Hegel on the involution and evolution of Absolute Spirit. Philosophy East and West, 31:2, 179 – 191.

Friday, August 5, 2011

Be-tailed Cousins and Phantasms of the Soul

An exhibition, a breathtaking one, of Gabriel von Max. Beautiful, vivid, dark, brooding. 
Showing at the Frye Museum, Seattle, until October, 2011.

Sybille, 1857

Seer, 1859

Per Aspera, 1898

Madonna at the Cross

Hexe, from Faust, 1879

Mephisto, as Faust, 1879

The Anatomist

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Risking Recognition

"When Hegel introduces the notion of recognition in the section on lordship and bondage in The Phenomenology of Spirit, he narrates the primary encounter with the Other in terms of self-loss. "Self-consciousness...has come out of itself...it has lost itself, for it finds itself as an other being". One might understand Hegel to be describing merely a pathological state in which a fantasy of absorption by the Other constitutes an early or primitive experience. But he is saying something more. He is saying that whatever consciousness is, whatever the self is, will find itself only through a reflection of itself in another. To be itself, it must pass through self-loss, and when it passes through, it will never be "returned" to what it was. To be reflected in or as another will have a double significance for consciousness, however, since consciousness will, through the reflection, regain itself in some way. But it will, by virtue of the external status of reflection, regain itself as external to itself, and hence, continue to lose itself. Thus the relationship to the Other will invariably be ambivalent. The price of self-knowledge will be self-loss, and the Other poses the possibility of both securing and undermining self-knowledge. What becomes clear, though, is that the self never returns to itself free of the Other, that it's relationality becomes constitutive of who the self is."

"Negation is a destruction that is survived."

Ref: 

Butler, J. (2010). Longing for Recognition in (K Hutchings and T Pulkkinen, Eds) Hegel's Philosophy and Feminist Thought: Beyond Antigone?. New York: Palgrave. p. 109 - 132.