Tuesday, December 20, 2011

The Way of Love by Luce Irigaray - The Sharing of Speech

On the way to proximity

Worlds require silence in order that they may say themselves, hear one another and communicate between themselves, and these worlds speak through our lips. Finding words can in this way become an infinite task, and the words do not always refer to things, where they convey toward the other, so that the direction is more important than the thing that is being said. The word becomes incarnate as the body and the flesh of what one wants to say to another, a flesh that goes beyond the body without being part of the body. This flesh being a sign of recognition of the irreducibility we have of and to each other – we encounter colour, a tone of voice, a tactile and poignant choice of word, a simple vibration in this.

An openness is called for where we admit the possibilities that lead to sharing, where, encountering our conversational second, we hold presence with a territory that is still and virgin with respect to meaning, where approach is possible, and where we do not communicate from an already constituted code or meaning. Attending to the other as we speak, adjusting according to whether the signs are perceived by the one to whom they are addressed, we enquire into whether they move him or her more deeply or through to a more blossomed level of Being.

To speak from an already known, a connivance, paralyses the becoming of the one and of the other, saying no longer speaking, but repeating the already dead. Adapted to a past need, these words no longer keep relation with desire which requires a staying in connection with both becoming, and now.

For there to be an exchange, it is essential that the other touch us, particularly through words, in this place we do not know, and where otherwise we have reduced proximity to confusion, to fusion. Holding an attitude of transcendence that surpasses the other, we will have missed the mark, and that distance distances both of us, and destroys that in which we have been touched, all the more so if we have been touched close to the source of our Being. Touching must remain sensuous, join the near, without dissolving it. Remaining as an enfolded opening between, which does not make meaning imperceptible to the other, but reveals it and prepares proximity, between us.

An interval is needed where each can find oneself again while avoiding one simply overturning the other through what is revealed of them. This interval is first of all nature, earth, water, air, fire, light. To go towards one another requires an elaboration of space-times that as Westerners we are ill-prepared for, even phenomenology does not prepare us for an encounter with the other, perhaps even drawing us away from the other, where at the extreme we might designate the other as an equal, a calculating valuation rendering their full approach absolutely impossible.

There is neither a single round dance nor play in the world, but a constitution of subjectivities that dance together through different unfoldings and refoldings. Not a silent constituting pause, appropriating and immobilising meaning. Each subject pronounces a part, each bringing to the sky it’s height and to the horizon it’s vastness, and it is in calling for an alliance that a saying is created in which the silence of the other becomes essential.

No word can name it once and for all, nor be totally foreign from it. Words creep up on the transcendental, if they do not close up upon themselves, dying. Too quickly occupying the silence between two risks veiling the meaning of it; between the two something exists that belongs to neither one nor moreover to any word, always, in some way, remaining indeterminate.

Communicating with the other unwinds from this impossible to say, speech turning toward the other in order to communicate and turning back to itself without having been able to say what it had to say. In turning back, speech attends to what one has learned from the other and to where it failed in communicating, being here dual in nature, and escaping the calculation that dominates our era.

From the multiple to the two

An already closed word, shared, is not a present communication with an other. It can seduce, or become a property or part of a tradition. It is not really shared between the two, with no shared ground of symbolic order, and the becoming of the relation is thus unsecured, a faithfulness that remains the same, no question of becoming nearer to each other, the subjects subject to a code that dominates and regulates.

An intimate communication becomes something other than a speaking appropriately for each other when the becoming of the two subjects testifies to the approach of themselves and to each other. The saying, from then on, no longer belongs to only one, each holds a part of the speech generated and unfolded, a saying starting from two that will not easily be divided again. An indispensible fidelity between the persons has been born, even while meaning quivers and always remains unstable, incomplete, unsettled and irreducible between the two.

In an exchange between two, no one can claim the whole without making exchange impossible. To refrain from a word granted in dialogue is to let an intimacy-between happen, by safeguarding a free space without violating the heart of the one or the other. The clearing of language – that vastness – is then built by two, where intimacy is possible with measure thanks to respect for each other. Encouraging the other to be other, to let them come into presence, even to lead them there, without claiming to be their foundation.
This relinquishing is a recognition and a gratitude.

The philosopher’s partner is speech itself, of which she says that it speaks only with itself – calling speech, but not another subject into encounter, a tautology, neither exchange nor dialogue. Speech as information and information as speech, an inextricable circle already in the past, silence here seeming impossible. This gained silence safeguards the virginity and integrity of the words, becoming a veil of mystery, sheltering the words in their own innocence. This veil of voluntary withdrawal is different from the veil of the language itself, the first veil saving the future to be said later, life and flesh, relation already furrowed and seeded by an always already pre-existing logos. Lost in the already pronounced and programmed, and shut off from that which should help, in becoming human.

To speak of or to  speak with

What is sought is an escape from the norms which language would program of us, a necessary creation of a new speaking. Dialogue is limited to a complicity which the poet knows not, where there is no already existing speech, where a monologue entered into as an opening must listen receptively to the other as other, who we cannot appropriate and whose speech may not be appropriated. The gesture is thus appropriation to disappropriation, demanding that the subject turn inward and learn to disappropriate the world. In order to come to a standstill in front of the irreducibility of the other, in the space of a silence which suspends one unfolding to open to another unfolding.

Appropriation then again must take place, of the language, relation to world, relation to other, requiring different proportions, differing actions, different appropriate responses.  We need to encounter language not only as a property to express needs, or describe objects, but to transform instincts and needs into shared desires. Beyond the middle stages of language development, a new way to speech may modify its intention and its path in accordance with what the age presents as the task to be accomplished. Bringing about new intimacy, where we might go in search of oneself in relation to the other, in speaking, in proximity. Speech thus would no longer name objects, penetrating into other dimensions of Being, other space and other time where it has to make its way differently.

Another era of speech is opening, the subject a stranger in her own land, turning back to radical disappropriation, keeping the senses awake in a region where the culture is unknown.

Dis-covering again astonishment, contemplation and admiration, a letting-be that is open in oneself and to the other, to unknown speech, and silence.

Ref: Irigaray, L. (2002). The Way of Love. London: Continuum. 13 – 61. 

Thursday, December 15, 2011

The Way of Love by Luce Irigaray - Introduction

In Western philosophy much has been made of philosophy as the love of wisdom, but what of the wisdom of love?

The way of love is an approach that seeks to join heart, body and mind, to bring back a sense of mysticism in philosophy, lost in time, to philosophy’s detriment. The way proposes that we read philosophy to stimulate, to cure, to return to dark existence with spirit a little more alive. It asks that we step away from a culture of monologue divorced from the real, to remit to a space where we less ‘speak about’ or ‘speak to’, from a presumption of a common universe, but rather we learn to ‘speak with’. In this way we are not so much surrounding ourselves inside-outside with a world of signifiers which separates us from the real and from all others. And it is not simply an exchange of signifiers between subjects, here, in flat, two-dimensional unity.

Objectivity describes a not-oneness, and the sensible and feelings, as subjectivities have their own descriptions, which are each worthy of our consideration and thought.  In order that we might not enact a reduction of objectivity into a sole subject, each must bring a meaning of one’s own into the dialogue, as we learn this practice, of how to ‘speak with’.

We require that we can say oneself to another without forcing upon the other one’s truth. From an interaction between subject and object a third arises, in the space generated by withdrawal that arises on the encounter with, and in, difference.

The notion of perfection of relation, as an absolute, is thus proposed here to never be completed, always becoming. The effort is expended to admitting and revealing diversity and alterity, without confusing the same as a horizon defined by death. In this same sweep, the subject-object relation eternally engaged has no past plenitude or ideal future. The vertical transcendence of the absolute – of Truth, or Idea, or Other, is substituted for a horizontal transcendence which calls for a different discourse, a completely revised logic, and a radical overhaul of the notion of perfection, itself. Mastery of nature and of the other is transformed into an elaboration of a shared universe, humanity instilling a fuller accomplishment, which is always under construction.

The unthinkable of thought is a traversing human identity, to overcome personal fullness to work together toward a more accomplished advent of spirit and humanity. To become beings capable of assuming the specificity of the real, without appropriating the other. By accepting an irrevocable split into two, within each of us, a decisive creation turns over, not to close itself up again a second time, but to recognise a forgotten difference, an irreducible difference, which separates human being itself without overcoming the division.

Never a completeness of the One, but a constitution of two worlds open and in relation to each other give birth to a third world as work in common and space-time, to be shared.

Traditional ontologies and essentialisms become liberated, transforming matter without abolishing it. Spirit becomes flesh, and flesh becomes word, interpenetrating and transmuting until that dichotomy between them no longer exists. We are two. We are one. We are One.

Ref: Irigaray, L. (2002). The Way of Love. London: Continuum. 1-12.

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Bardo of life, death, dharmata and becoming.

In a cloudless night sky, the full moon,
'The Lord of the Stars' is about to rise...
The face of my compassionate lord, Padmasambhava,
Draws me on, radiating its tender welcome.

My delight in death is far, far greater than
The delight of traders mat making vast fortunes at sea,
Or the lords of the gods who vaunt their victory in battle;
Or of those sages who have entered into the rapture of perfect absorption.
So just as a traveler who sets out on the road when time has come to go,
I will not remain in this world any longer,
But will go to dwell in the stronghold of the great bliss of deathlessness.

This, my life, is finished, my karma is exhausted, what benefit
prayers could bring has worn out.
All worldly things are done with, my life's show is over.
In one instant, I will recognise the very essence of the manifestation of my being
In the pure, vast realms of the bardo state;
I am close now to taking up my seat in the ground of primordial perfection.

The riches found in myself have made the minds of others happy,
I have used the blessing of this life to realise all the benefits of the island of liberation;
Having been with you, my noble disciples, through all this time.
The joy of sharing the truth has filled me and satisfied me.

Now all the connections in this life between us are ending,
I am an aimless beggar who is going to die as he likes,
Do not feel sad for me, but go on praying always.
These words are my heart talking,
Think of them as a cloud of lotus-blossoms, and you in your devotion
As bees plunging into them to suck from them their transcendent joy.

 Longchenpa, 14th century Dzogchen master.

Sogyal Rinpoche in 'The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying' speaks of realised masters as being like mountain eagles, soaring above life and death to see them for what they truly are in their intricate and myterious inter-relation. Proposing that they might see akin to the way that David Bohm describes reality, an 'unbroken wholeness in flowing movement', life and death merely different aspects of that one unbroken whole, movement.

The bardo teachings, thus, are suggested as revealing of death process, which is as much life process, having three stage-bodies:

1. At the culmination of the dying process, after the dissolution of the elements, senses and thought states, the ultimate nature of mind, the Ground Luminosity, is for a moment laid bare in the bardo of dying;
2. Then, fleetingly, the radiance of that mind is displayed and shines out in appearances of sound, colours and light in the bardo of dharmata;
3. Next the dead person's consciousness awakens and enters the bardo of becoming; and ordinary mind reenters and takes form in the mental body, subject to past karma and mental habit.

This three stage process describes too the manifestation of mind - an enfoldment leading to a laying bare of source, through to spontaneous radiance of light and energy and into increasing crystallisation, manifesting as a mental form.

Rinpoche points out that this process is in fact going on moment to moment within our mind, thoughts and emotions, the three-body process as described by Padmasambhava:

Within this Rigpa, the three kayas are inseparable and fully present as one:
Since it is empty and not created anywhere it is the Dharmakaya;
Since it is luminous, clarity representing the inherent transparent radiance of emptiness, it is the Sambhogakaya.
Since its arising is nowhere obstructed or interrupted, it is the Nirmanakaya.
These three being complete and fully present as one, are its very essence.

What happens in our mind, now, during life is held to occur in exactly this form in the bardo stages of death. With this in mind, three heart practices are proposed by Tsele Natsok Rangdrol, a 17th century Dzogchen master, brilliant meditations:

'Recognise this infinite variety of appearances as a dream,
As nothing but projections of your mind, illusory and unreal.
Without grasping at anything, rest in the wisdom of your Rigpa,
that transcends all concepts:
This is the heart of the practice for the bardo of this life.

You are bound to die soon, and nothing then will be of any real help.
What you experience in death is your own conceptual thinking.
Without fabricating any thoughts, let them all die into the vast expanse
of your Rigpa's self-awareness;
This is the heart practice for the bardo of dying.

Whatever grasps at appearance or disappearance, as being good or bad, is your mind.
And this mind itself is the self-radiance of the Dharmakaya, just whatever arises.
Not to cling to the risings, make concepts out of them, accept or reject them:
This is the heart practice for the bardo of the dharmata.

Samsara is your mind, nirvana is also your mind,
All pleasure and pain, and all delusions exist nowhere apart from your mind,
To attain control over your own mind;
This is the heart practice of the bardo of becoming.'

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Thorough-going Critical Realism

The development of Critical Realism from the 1970s onwards has sought to avoid the polarity of social theory's essentialised alternatives of positivism and interpretism. These two have since been supplemented by queer theory, poststructuralism, and feminism, among other tropes in social theory, and aspects of the influence of these on Critical Realism will be considered in future posts.

Bhaskar's initial intervention was concerned to establish a realist account of science.

One of Bhaskar's central tenets was that modernity has overemphasised the epistemological, reducing all question of status of existence to question about the knowledge of such existence. His 'epistemic fallacy' proposes that 'statements about being can be reduced to or analysed in terms of statements about knowledge'. Whitehead would concur: 'all difficulties as to first principles are only camouflaged metaphysical difficulties. Thus also the epistemological difficulty is only solvable by an appeal to ontology'.

Bhaskar investigates the character of ontology via transcendental arguments in 'reflection  upon what must be the case for science to be possible'. This requires positing an independent reality - 'given that science does occur, the world must be a certain way'. Rather than take a simple empiricist line, Critical Realism's transcendentalism presupposes and partially discloses that which enables the phenomena to be seen.

Shifting beyond basic facticity toward process and potentiality inherent in existence, Critical Realism makes a move that Michael Halewood lifts to the light for our witness and critique - Critical Realism divides reality up into layers, and takes a post-Kantian line, of limiting the operation of the transcendental to human thought, rather than enabling the world to transcend itself. In this way, Halewood proposes that the bifurcation of mind-in-here versus world-out-there is an unavoidable structural fault line of Critical Realism.

Depth realism, however, acts as redemptive, recouping this initial instance of dualism. The deeper generative mechanisms of world-encountering become apparent, and reality-as-it-appears is not reality-as-it-is, but, working through the appearances uncover a deeper sense of reality-as-it-really-is, with:

The 'real' - the realm of generative mechanisms that suffuse the real world;
The 'actual' - the events that manifest as the world unfolds;
The 'empirical' - the observations made by mere mortal humans of the actual, through which the operations of the real can be discerned.

Mistakes, in the form of human error, thus enter through the empirical (as can the need for research funding, a need so close to mine own heart).

These levels imply a hierarchy to reality, the emergence of one realm out of another is held by Critical Realism as constitutive of reality itself. Once this emergence occurs, new forms of self-contained reality are encountered, having their own causal mechanisms. Critical Realism attempts to deflect problems inherent in linear causation accounts by asserting that causes do exist in nature, but they are neither uniform nor unidirectional. The causes can be understood only in terms of generative, nondeterministic properties which are isolated to the experimental paradigm, and can't be abstracted into/out of full reality, which has it's own autonomous 'real' (would that economists had left their own assumptions in the realm of the laboratory! I hear you cry).

There are two more posts to come on Critical Realism, as enlivened by Halewood's critique, one evincing the possibilities of Speculative Realism, the other addressing the Whiteheadian notion of conformation.

For the moment contemplating the need to problematise the bifurcation, and/or the sense that science is an abstraction of an abstraction with an implicit transcendence of a human inquirer with consciousness is to be borne out onto the asphalt, pounded, as I take my oversized body for an Asics-shod run.

Or perhaps two.


Ref:

Halewood, M. (2011). AN Whitehead and Social Theory. London: Anthem Press.

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

The Developmental Bodhisattva - Owen Flanagan

'The bodhisattva ideal in both classical and contemporary views is a developmental one. Achieving full enlightenment and the marvelous qualities of extraordinary virtue takes time, and thus how deep or complete the wisdom or virtue achieved by a particular bodhisattva is an admit of degree. To keep things simple, as well as congenial to a defensible naturalistic Buddhism which is also consistent with a form of twenty-first century Socially Engaged Buddhism that many Westerners find attractive, conceive of the bodhisattva in this metaphysical minimalist way. She is enlightened insofar as she understands the causal dependence of everything (pratityasamutpada), the impermanence of all things (anicca), and the nature of herself as anatman, as possessed of no immutable essence that is her self. She conscientiously stays on the Noble Eightfold Path, overcomes the common mental afflictions (egoism, avarice, hatred, and the like), eventually embodies the four divine abodes, the six perfections (incredible patience, great mental acuity, extremely subtle perceptual sensitivity to the needs of others and so on). Armed with compassion, loving kindness, sympathetic joy and equanimity, she takes her battle for happiness and against suffering into the world. The bodhisattva is a courageous and virtuous moral activist, a warrior. She lives an active life of virtue, having become sufficiently enlightened to understand that in so doing she attempts to realise her full humanity and to achieve whatever excellence lies within the human range. She is flawed, incomplete, unsettled in her own skin and in her world in all the normal human ways. Being human, her being, her relations, her existence are fragile. She works to live without illusion....'

Ref:
Flanagan, O. (2011). The Bodhisattva's Brain. Boston: MIT Press. pg 29

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Divine Abodes

The Bodhisattva's Psyche

Metta


Karuna


Mudita


Upekkha







This alone - one's service to sentient beings (sattvaraddhana) is pleasing to the Tathagartas.
This alone is the actual accomplishment of one's goal.
This alone removes the suffering of the world.
Therefore, let this alone be my resolve. ~ Shantideva, "The Bodhisattva's Way of Life"

I'm reading a gorgeous book called 'The Bodhisattva's Brain' by Owen Flanagan, who had been invited to Dharamsala by the Dalai Lama, otherwise unprompted, by his writing of 'Consciousness Reconsidered' in 1992. Flanagan is a secular phenomenology-oriented neurophilosopher, who brings his fascination with the question of whether the teleological assumptions of Buddhism can be suspended to reveal 'Buddhism, naturalised', what he claims as a emprically responsible Buddhism. He has a healthy scepticism regarding the esoteric.

And the book is brilliant - bringing challenge and question to the Bodhisattva concept, enquiring into the characteristics of the vow, the interaction and interconnection of sila, samdhi and prajna, deeply enquiring into the colour of happiness and flourishing, selfless persons and being no-self.

Confucius and Aristotle are heavily drawn on to create a comparative container. There's rich discussion of the necessary and sufficient conditions for sustained happiness via analysis of different approaches to virtues and ethics, and ecological approaches to intersubjectivity abound. Nussbaum and Foucault are regularly employed for styles of approach to the phenomena.

Emptiness.

No village law, no law of market town,
No law of a single household is this -
Of all the world and all the worlds of gods
This is the only Law, that all things are impermanent.
(from the parable of the mustard seed).

Saturday, October 29, 2011

ανδρεία μήδομαι

to be courageous, to be mindful

Perseus and Andromeda



Sir Edward Burne-Jones 1886-87