Critical realism (CR) attempts to link facts and values, so disastrously split from each other by David Hume in the 18th century and affirmed via reification of Kantian dualism with it's own suggestion of deep incompatibility between an account of action that recognises a type of moral imperative and causal explanation. Working an edge of Aristotlelian teleology, and following Marx, CR accept a distinction between man-as-s/he-happens-to-be and man-as-s/he-could-be-if-s/he-realised-an-essential-nature and begins to articulate a substrate of social interaction in which we are all involved, although we perhaps less than half realise it.
Emancipation comes through awakening ever more deeply into knowledge of the social ties that bind, and bind. Aligning facts and values, redeeming elements of social process in accordance with object domains without attempting to reduce them to an ontological truth, claiming a purpose to life in the ever deepening awakening of the sheer value of life, with an appreciation for social life, itself.
Society is proposed by Roy Bhaskar to have a form with specific modes of operation that are distinct from those that are present right now in this moment, and too society is continually reproduced in activity as an outcome of human agency. All social practices have aspects that both liberate and restrain. Bhaskar proposes four planes within which social activity takes place:
- Material transactions with nature - nature for Bhaskar includes man-made artifacts - weapons for example have a social meaning and play a role in structuring social life. CR rejects a divide between the material and the social, and insists that all human activity takes place within a material reality that must be encountered and that may be changed as a result of human action.
- Intra/intersubjective activity - this is the realm of our shared norms, our shared symbols in language.
- Social roles - for CR, we each play multiple roles in society that may be enacted in one point in time. What governs the dynamic of the role is intersubjective understanding, although intersubjective understanding in no way completely determines the role.
- Personal intersubjectivity - specific individuals will align themselves in different ways within intersubjective understandings and thus will self-determine, in the practice of roles.
As the dynamic of social life unfolds, the interplay between these four planes, in a lattice-work, changes.
Bringing Pierre Bourdieu's notion of the habitus to this planar model of Bhaskar's gives the ground through which we come to understand the liberative potential of CR. The habitus per Bourdieu has an objective nature in social structures that shape behaviour in a social field. In personal to social relation, the power of the habitus as subjective and socio-cultural relative derives in it's thoughtlessness and habituatedness. Per Bourdieu, the habitus is 'the internalisation of reality and the externalisation of internality' (Bourdieu, 1977).
Thus there are agents, functioning in a habitus, engaged via relations, all of which produce social practices. Roles, relations structure and perhaps even understanding may function in ways that are opaque to consciousness.
Social sciences, and CR in particular, thus become essential in reclaiming the ground not only of the hermeneutic, but also of ourselves as beings. Emancipation in this model refers not to freedom from all constraints, but rather it can be understood as the transition from unwanted, unnecessary and repressive states.
We're no longer reduced to the postmodern Foucauldian notion that all knowledge is power, and knowledge is oppressive. With CR, we become born again into a loving, creative and mutually influential play, with one another, consciously forming and re-forming social connection that might heal, social connection that ultimately, liberates.
Ref:
Bourdieu, P. (1977). Outline of a Theory of Practice, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bhaskar, R.A., 2002, Reflections On Meta-Reality: A Philosophy for the Present, New Delhi: Sage.
Saturday, January 28, 2012
Friday, January 6, 2012
The Way of Love by Luce Irigaray - Rebuilding the World
Horizontal and vertical transcendence
Each of us as selves are memory which is preserved both for our own becoming and for our future encounter with the other. The relation to one another, as well, is preserved in memory - corresponding not solely to an internal element held by each one, but as an undertaking-with, of complex and subtle nature. Paradox is present where our spiritual evolution is ensured through memory, and yet we forget ourselves, stepping into and beyond the abstract space of memory, where the memory is incurred thanks to relation to the other in difference. With you, I forget me.
In every reflection it is the case that we risk the loss of the volume and the asymmetry of being, which is living. We risk glorious image and large spectacle, a certain attachment that does not serve Dasein. Vision risks the loss of the abiility to perceive the real, the living volume always unfinished, mobile, in becoming. Something of binocular vision is abandoned with an image, and with it the articulation of difference between self and other, alterity lost in a specular play that is not perceived as such.
The mirror or speculum suspends time in an indeterminate space - personhood frozen, ossified, in what it is presumed to be. Sages have sensed the difficulty of leaving aside constructed tradition, not dissimilar to this constructed personhood, and entering into a relation with another, who is carrying out the same gesture of reception. To return to relatedness at the level of tradition or the level of the person is to regain the evolution of time, and we find a way, together, of going and coming to the past and the future without forgetting the present. Founded upon need and desire, fidelity to self and other, and remembering and planning. The present is the necessary space of the experience of singularity, even in difference.
Thus to dwell is a fundamental trait of the human condition. While recognising that dwelling necessitates construction, of language, and poetry, not merely for it's own purpose, but in cultivation of the living as that which does not grow by itself. Vertical and horizontal blossoming, transcendence, depends on this. The house that is built is not primarily a refuge from the storm nor a hollowed out space where the divine once-was, it is a space where the horizon of the already lived and defined reopens. Where the bridges between past, present and future and passages between self and other can be elaborated.
No external measure can validate what is built, no standard existent can judge the task, the interior work entirely ascertained in the blossoming of Dasein in the self, the other, the whole of the world, of dwelling. The divine lies in each of us, and precisely between us, all around us, celestial and terrestrial, dialectical link in the spiritual becoming of each one. Heart itself is the indestructible link, sustained in the movements both lowest and highest.
The intimate requires separate dwellings
Alternating in move and rest, towards and withdrawn, irradiating spirit and subtle energy, a duration is woven where the two are intertwined, and a nonlinear dwelling is incurred. Time and space become translucent, open, mere dwelling placed as a letting be and a letting come. Through desire we encounter the gift offered of the other, and ourselves gathered in the embrace of their welcome. Space here is not dimension-distance, the inner expanse encountered in each other's view radiates across more than time, more than space, generative of curve, enveloping and enveloped. No homogeneous definition can suffice.
An estrangement from the other, an inwards turn to the self, brings the other into a space of mystery, announced as alterity, in an act of touching, knowing 'I am different from you, here, and we connect'. Drawing near necessitates allying two intimacies, not submitting one to the other. Attraction is awakened in the difference between the two worlds, the mystery, one to the other. To cover another with figments of imagination is to necessitate theft but to maintain an approach. Proximity here is not as with proximity to things, a secrecy in mystery can be maintained by both parties, not just one. A shift beyond poetic dwelling is called on.
An approach to each other will advance step by step towards un-covering, of oneself and the other, re-opening the place in which each one in a moment takes shelter to prepare for an encounter. Receiving oneself, here, there is a turning back, a modifying, to transform the dwelling in order to better live Dasein and to secure the memory of becoming of self, other, the whole world.
Approach is only possible in the irreducible difference of the other. Something comes to pass which is not entirely one's own or the others, and which speaks of what the bringing together of two worlds produces. What in this way occurs gives itself to each one inasmuch as each wants to welcome it, and to secure its memory.
The beloved is sheltered in the silence of the heart, in the restraint of gesture, it's inward gathering. Of letting be and letting grow in withdrawal towards a proximity with oneself, which always, in part, remains nocturnal and silent. Too, the other cannot be reduced to a substratum from which we elaborate our own culture - we advance to the other in darkness, the disclosure of their coming never revealed in the light of day. Other beings remain multiple in what is - never fully or completely integrated into our world, of a language with which we are never fully conversant. We must prepare the place and in no way preserve an identity for the other, without becoming.
The name of the other
Union with the other is never complete, on pain of no longer existing. Difference demands the relinquishing of the whole, and fidelity requires that we relinquish immediate fullness in order to obtain fruit which is never permanent or at the disposal of one of the two, alone. In fusion a lightning strike of love can reopen the path to proximity otherwise overgrown with attachment.
If they remain free and faithful to themselves, the call of the name of the other enacts a gathering of self, rather than a mere availability to to the gaze. The name of God here represents the transfer of the other into the beyond, the guarantor of alterity, the space of our entering into relation, there is no reduction into the One available here, but emergence, Heidegger's 'fold' the staying-shape of the one within which the other cannot be contained, preventing the closing of the fold. Eternally open.
What I know is always already partial, already foreign to the core of Being from which the other draws the organisation of the becoming of their existence, entering into the presence of the present. The attentive approach of the other gives me a real and a meaning still to come, now unknown to me. The other appears as we each withdraw into the self, a gesture which includes opening to the other, in the same instant - the other doesn't just appear because I speak them.
From the other irradiates a truth which we receive without the source being visible - we indirectly perceive that from which the other elaborates meaning, the light then reaching us illuminating both the subject and the world, opening possibilities, elaborating space and time, a site of existing, it's space beyond. In life we can source sense of shared destiny in mortality, throwing off games and mere symbol, accepting not only the irradiation that emanates from the other, but too that we can be guided by the other, in fidelity to ourselves.
The Nothingness that Separates Us
For humans, the gesture of gathering oneself up to open oneself out is much more difficult than it is for, say, flowers. We must learn to not to artificially hold ourselves open with language, how to be in the pulsation of difference, between self and other, such that we maintain, authentically, the opening. Philia, friend-love, in the tension and release, renouncing appropriation without limits in order to let the other be.
In the space of dialogue between-two, nihilism finds positive fulfilment, calling into question one's own world so as to bring into existence and access the world of the other. Not to destroy the yesterday but to view into the future of the most possible and most perfect blossoming.
The practice of the negative as insurmountable and absolute subjectivity is what safeguards the site of difference, and thus connection. Instead of working to secure the world of one's own, the maintenance of the negative allows us to restore the nothing that separates us. This nihilism lies in a real that has always been, a real that calls to question our values and gives access to a new epoch of think/feeling.
Consciousness, not merely as knowing but extending to and beyond the other, encountering the unknown becomes the chance of entering into presence, the light that then shines is that of an intimate sun that supports life and makes it grown without illumination in diurnal light. Consciousness is too of the interior, illuminating the flesh and being illumined by it, able now to take a nocturnal perspective on itself. Illumination is not a separation, but a return to the hearth, a hearth to be linked with each one, not shaped for our own purpose, but linked in being, a care and a letting be. To be calm and to be changing, each providing the other with confirmation of boundary without imposition in any form, supports beyond the horizon of legal system, or linguistic frameworks.To comprehend this moment in history, we will encounter deep connection with all subjectivity, not bearing the imprint of the gaze of the witness.
Light never illuminates the whole without paralysing becoming, we need a view raised in acceptance of the balancing play, the dance between shadow and light. Light uncovers, for a moment, the figure of the whole, returning in darkness to difference, in the very next instant. The human too dances this space turning inside and outside on pain of losing their humanity. Surpassing this matter is not the question - rather the transformation of it into beauty, the transubstantiation into the divine, is the nature of illumination in contemplation.
The light that someone radiates is not necessarily perceived by the one who gives it to be seen, perhaps a proof that mortals are destined for light but for light in it's effects, not an intrinsic peace, or joy. We extend toward the proposal that touch lies invisible in everything, including seeing, touch which allows a drawing back into oneself, that intimate light, touch which is also the illumined-illuminating encounter with the other, overflowing from one's own world to taste another's brightness. This light which we call God, faithful to the nothingness that God guarantees. A nothingness which is precisely and everywhere, not nothing.
Each of us as selves are memory which is preserved both for our own becoming and for our future encounter with the other. The relation to one another, as well, is preserved in memory - corresponding not solely to an internal element held by each one, but as an undertaking-with, of complex and subtle nature. Paradox is present where our spiritual evolution is ensured through memory, and yet we forget ourselves, stepping into and beyond the abstract space of memory, where the memory is incurred thanks to relation to the other in difference. With you, I forget me.
In every reflection it is the case that we risk the loss of the volume and the asymmetry of being, which is living. We risk glorious image and large spectacle, a certain attachment that does not serve Dasein. Vision risks the loss of the abiility to perceive the real, the living volume always unfinished, mobile, in becoming. Something of binocular vision is abandoned with an image, and with it the articulation of difference between self and other, alterity lost in a specular play that is not perceived as such.
The mirror or speculum suspends time in an indeterminate space - personhood frozen, ossified, in what it is presumed to be. Sages have sensed the difficulty of leaving aside constructed tradition, not dissimilar to this constructed personhood, and entering into a relation with another, who is carrying out the same gesture of reception. To return to relatedness at the level of tradition or the level of the person is to regain the evolution of time, and we find a way, together, of going and coming to the past and the future without forgetting the present. Founded upon need and desire, fidelity to self and other, and remembering and planning. The present is the necessary space of the experience of singularity, even in difference.
Thus to dwell is a fundamental trait of the human condition. While recognising that dwelling necessitates construction, of language, and poetry, not merely for it's own purpose, but in cultivation of the living as that which does not grow by itself. Vertical and horizontal blossoming, transcendence, depends on this. The house that is built is not primarily a refuge from the storm nor a hollowed out space where the divine once-was, it is a space where the horizon of the already lived and defined reopens. Where the bridges between past, present and future and passages between self and other can be elaborated.
No external measure can validate what is built, no standard existent can judge the task, the interior work entirely ascertained in the blossoming of Dasein in the self, the other, the whole of the world, of dwelling. The divine lies in each of us, and precisely between us, all around us, celestial and terrestrial, dialectical link in the spiritual becoming of each one. Heart itself is the indestructible link, sustained in the movements both lowest and highest.
The intimate requires separate dwellings
Alternating in move and rest, towards and withdrawn, irradiating spirit and subtle energy, a duration is woven where the two are intertwined, and a nonlinear dwelling is incurred. Time and space become translucent, open, mere dwelling placed as a letting be and a letting come. Through desire we encounter the gift offered of the other, and ourselves gathered in the embrace of their welcome. Space here is not dimension-distance, the inner expanse encountered in each other's view radiates across more than time, more than space, generative of curve, enveloping and enveloped. No homogeneous definition can suffice.
An estrangement from the other, an inwards turn to the self, brings the other into a space of mystery, announced as alterity, in an act of touching, knowing 'I am different from you, here, and we connect'. Drawing near necessitates allying two intimacies, not submitting one to the other. Attraction is awakened in the difference between the two worlds, the mystery, one to the other. To cover another with figments of imagination is to necessitate theft but to maintain an approach. Proximity here is not as with proximity to things, a secrecy in mystery can be maintained by both parties, not just one. A shift beyond poetic dwelling is called on.
An approach to each other will advance step by step towards un-covering, of oneself and the other, re-opening the place in which each one in a moment takes shelter to prepare for an encounter. Receiving oneself, here, there is a turning back, a modifying, to transform the dwelling in order to better live Dasein and to secure the memory of becoming of self, other, the whole world.
Approach is only possible in the irreducible difference of the other. Something comes to pass which is not entirely one's own or the others, and which speaks of what the bringing together of two worlds produces. What in this way occurs gives itself to each one inasmuch as each wants to welcome it, and to secure its memory.
The beloved is sheltered in the silence of the heart, in the restraint of gesture, it's inward gathering. Of letting be and letting grow in withdrawal towards a proximity with oneself, which always, in part, remains nocturnal and silent. Too, the other cannot be reduced to a substratum from which we elaborate our own culture - we advance to the other in darkness, the disclosure of their coming never revealed in the light of day. Other beings remain multiple in what is - never fully or completely integrated into our world, of a language with which we are never fully conversant. We must prepare the place and in no way preserve an identity for the other, without becoming.
The name of the other
Union with the other is never complete, on pain of no longer existing. Difference demands the relinquishing of the whole, and fidelity requires that we relinquish immediate fullness in order to obtain fruit which is never permanent or at the disposal of one of the two, alone. In fusion a lightning strike of love can reopen the path to proximity otherwise overgrown with attachment.
If they remain free and faithful to themselves, the call of the name of the other enacts a gathering of self, rather than a mere availability to to the gaze. The name of God here represents the transfer of the other into the beyond, the guarantor of alterity, the space of our entering into relation, there is no reduction into the One available here, but emergence, Heidegger's 'fold' the staying-shape of the one within which the other cannot be contained, preventing the closing of the fold. Eternally open.
What I know is always already partial, already foreign to the core of Being from which the other draws the organisation of the becoming of their existence, entering into the presence of the present. The attentive approach of the other gives me a real and a meaning still to come, now unknown to me. The other appears as we each withdraw into the self, a gesture which includes opening to the other, in the same instant - the other doesn't just appear because I speak them.
From the other irradiates a truth which we receive without the source being visible - we indirectly perceive that from which the other elaborates meaning, the light then reaching us illuminating both the subject and the world, opening possibilities, elaborating space and time, a site of existing, it's space beyond. In life we can source sense of shared destiny in mortality, throwing off games and mere symbol, accepting not only the irradiation that emanates from the other, but too that we can be guided by the other, in fidelity to ourselves.
The Nothingness that Separates Us
For humans, the gesture of gathering oneself up to open oneself out is much more difficult than it is for, say, flowers. We must learn to not to artificially hold ourselves open with language, how to be in the pulsation of difference, between self and other, such that we maintain, authentically, the opening. Philia, friend-love, in the tension and release, renouncing appropriation without limits in order to let the other be.
In the space of dialogue between-two, nihilism finds positive fulfilment, calling into question one's own world so as to bring into existence and access the world of the other. Not to destroy the yesterday but to view into the future of the most possible and most perfect blossoming.
The practice of the negative as insurmountable and absolute subjectivity is what safeguards the site of difference, and thus connection. Instead of working to secure the world of one's own, the maintenance of the negative allows us to restore the nothing that separates us. This nihilism lies in a real that has always been, a real that calls to question our values and gives access to a new epoch of think/feeling.
Consciousness, not merely as knowing but extending to and beyond the other, encountering the unknown becomes the chance of entering into presence, the light that then shines is that of an intimate sun that supports life and makes it grown without illumination in diurnal light. Consciousness is too of the interior, illuminating the flesh and being illumined by it, able now to take a nocturnal perspective on itself. Illumination is not a separation, but a return to the hearth, a hearth to be linked with each one, not shaped for our own purpose, but linked in being, a care and a letting be. To be calm and to be changing, each providing the other with confirmation of boundary without imposition in any form, supports beyond the horizon of legal system, or linguistic frameworks.To comprehend this moment in history, we will encounter deep connection with all subjectivity, not bearing the imprint of the gaze of the witness.
Light never illuminates the whole without paralysing becoming, we need a view raised in acceptance of the balancing play, the dance between shadow and light. Light uncovers, for a moment, the figure of the whole, returning in darkness to difference, in the very next instant. The human too dances this space turning inside and outside on pain of losing their humanity. Surpassing this matter is not the question - rather the transformation of it into beauty, the transubstantiation into the divine, is the nature of illumination in contemplation.
The light that someone radiates is not necessarily perceived by the one who gives it to be seen, perhaps a proof that mortals are destined for light but for light in it's effects, not an intrinsic peace, or joy. We extend toward the proposal that touch lies invisible in everything, including seeing, touch which allows a drawing back into oneself, that intimate light, touch which is also the illumined-illuminating encounter with the other, overflowing from one's own world to taste another's brightness. This light which we call God, faithful to the nothingness that God guarantees. A nothingness which is precisely and everywhere, not nothing.
Ref: Irigaray, L. (2002). The Way of Love. London: Continuum. 137 – 174.
Die, die, die
Die, die, die in this love.
If you die in this love your soul will be renewed.
Die, die, don’t fear the death of that which is known.
If you die to the temporal you will become timeless.
Die, die, cut off those chains
that hold you prisoner to the world of attachment.
Die, die, die to the deathless and you will be eternal.
Die, die, come out of this cloud.
When you leave the cloud,
you will be the effulgent moon.
Die, die, die to the din and noise of mundane concerns.
In the silence of love you will find the spark of life. ~ Jalalludin Rumi
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
Emptiness
This post is partnered by the one entitled 'Not-two, not one'. Both are outcomes of a meditative practice borne by virtue of some material from the Core Integral: Essential Integral modules, this on state-stage awareness via the Wilber-Combs lattice. This present post calls forth the essence of my sense of the causal state structure-stage instances, the 'Not-two, not one' post is what I encounter in the space described by the nondual state structure-stage instances.
With deep thanks to Kell, because you asked about the nature of my Facebook post, of the same material.
New realms of seeing have opened up, in that simple question from you, these small ways that we make each other real.
Breathing into the nothingness of the void as the source of all being,
equally giving forth, the rise and fall.
Peace, as cessation of desire and needs
grows, the sense that everything is empty, open and still.
The path of cessation of suffering is the path to liberation,
pursuing anything else is a distraction, know that
the void calls on all.
This realm of stillness and clarity is deeply empowering,
self and other, you and I, intertwined, eternal. The one freedom.
All elements, all phenomena, all beings, the entire kosmos, are just this:
simple, pure and empty. Free.
And apprehend, all, the all, at rest,
deep peace through endless levels of realisation.
The eternal, timeless and unborn, here, is the true essence of the world of form.
Involution and evolution cease
and find their source in this place of radical emptiness,
emerging as pure unqualifiable awareness.
Resting as vast, transparent clarity, an undying being returning
to the source in every moment.
Like the winds softly whispering at sunrise intuition calls,
and says
go further,
do not stop here,
do not become attached to the stillness.
Do not forget your true nature.
All is transient, insubstantial,
one with a pure, luminous and subtle light.
Resting as witness, with pure awareness and pure openness,
the entire world arises as consciousness, utterly free.
I am
vast,
infinite,
open,
never born and never dying.
Adapted from: Core Integral, 'States', Wilber-Combs Lattice
Monday, January 2, 2012
The Way of Love by Luce Irigaray - Thanks to Difference
Returning to the question of the unthought is indispensable in answering to what it is to encounter human becoming – though the task is made difficult by the extent to which the unthought can also paralyse our ability to act, to be able to see in a certain sphere. Too it is often the case that this void of the unthought is covered over in the production of a discourse that does not see it, and the thus void deepens. Between forgotten Being and one fixed in language, the connecting bridge is cut.
The silence of between-two in listening to each other is not built upon emptiness of concept ,nor relentless flight between past and future in an ever widening circle. Rather, there is a difference between subjects to be encountered in the becoming of an elliptical dialectic, where each subject is recognisable in their alterity, referencing the other. The qualities and sources of impulse, resistance, withdrawal and restraint determine the shape of the ellipsis, and perfection of the shape comes through Beings interweaving attention to the other and to the contribution made in fidelity to the self, wherever possible securing a reference to the other, in speech act.
Here, mastery of the whole eludes each one, each one eclipsed by the other, in turn, invisibility and silence taking part in becoming. The body too, is not separated from the process, but is a part of the transformation and transfiguration of thinking, a recognition of the body as the source and the dwelling of Being, the blood-body link with other and others, with past and present and future being.
The other and the link with the other can never be cordoned off as a negativity, rather, there is a pretension to the Absolute, found in our own interior identities, through which we must accept the negative as marking an insurpassable limit, an unqualifiable unknown, in regards to the existence of the other in their difference.
Difference is safeguarded, in a way, as we integrate it into a transcendent and more accomplished level of being. This path is to discover the relational nature of Being, itself, linking Being and the human being. As a child wins autonomy and thus discovers what it is to enter into a relation with another, we can recover one element of this movement that becomes lost and forgotten to us in human life-time, difference itself. Humanness, as not one but two, two who are not halves nor complementary or opposed, but who can maintain a relation with respect to their difference(s).
Subjective becoming is then an ellipsis which describes the recouperation of all forgotten differences; where the rational scientist may allow that life form exists on a far flung planet and too that a lover, within his own home, who begins from a logic that is not his own, is himself, in being and becoming. The horizons extend ever outwards, thinking must always be birthed anew, and in a new language, of new shape.
Each human is, thus, in it’s beginning, at least, two, a twoness of difference, both Being and being in one identity. As for human couples, the being-Being relationship cannot be defined in an ultimate unity – this end is not defined completely by either one or the other and besides, escapes representation.
A + nonA = more than, and but, One.
This difference cannot take place inside a whole already constituted by thought of singular identity. It does not suffice to move back behind the closure of this world to find some whole truth – an emptiness must be opened, in our thinking such that attraction, that palpitation in difference, can emerge, fields of forces that rediscover each other in reality before representations paralyse and falsify this energy as a given of the real.
The Trilogy of the Real
It is possible to reduce this difference into a relation of simple naturalness or fulfilment of a biological destiny, in the case of sexual relation between beings of difference as man and woman; reproduction. Identity subsumed to animality.
Rather, taking account of the accomplishments of the subjects, individually, discloses dual reality, and a third, of their relation, emerges. These as three are never independent of each other, and cannot be founded on a single relation to a single sameness. No mirror fully captures this trilogy. Faithfulness to the real is more critical than definitive denomination of it. Welcoming the new consistently disclosed by the presence of the other must replace enclosure in knowledge already and historically acquired. None of the three worlds will be unresponsive to the arrival of newness; and no third party can, from the outside, administer or govern the relation of the three.
From the real one is, the perceptions one makes, and the existence in relation with the other each subject carries the gathering of the real present in the world.
In this way we participate in growth, in complex growth and cultural becoming in relation. Each subject comes to an utter standstill, before the other, respectful of the irreducible alterity of the other, helping each other’s growth as far as is appropriate to the beginning real, for each, faithful, to our own real, in acting.
The meeting point is thus shaped as a listening to the other, and returning to the other their own, original nature, pure and true. Relation is maintained in difference, and in this way, it is helpful to encounter difference, the other, within the space of one’s own interiority, without reducing that inner relation to one of finality, of expectation of conformity on behalf of the outer other. We cannot steal another’s energy to accumulate unfolding of our own Being. To hold the other as one at our disposal is to fail in human identity, to become a machine in the service of technique, a technologist in illusory relation.
Making/Letting Be
In this way we return to allowing an initial real to blossom, without substituting a product of technique for it, placing the causal within ourselves. Caring, for the emergence of our own becoming which is the encounter with coexistence, with other living beings – engendered by at least one, and strictly speaking two, in the beginning. Attending to our own singularity calls here the belongingness of the world, and the age in which we exist, these most-nearnesses, which are often directly assimilated into the self, in pluralism predominant in our time not even race or gender might distinguish our humanness. To restore allowable contrast, we must find difference within our own interiority, nurture other-being, in this blossoming space. Difference in soul-space, an unveiling of difference within as-me, accepted. Difference in making, and letting, be.
A new temporality of becoming might then emerge, articulated in attuning and attunement, to letting be and constructing, adjusted for each relation, interior being and exterior being. A duration enunciated where each moment consists in new encounter, in either relation, weaving, two voices, one never used for the production of the other, conjoining, rather two ways of safeguarding and cultivating truth. Each one has a role, to preserve and protect the other.
Engendered
It is not by overcoming distances that we find proximity to the other, the self or the world. It is rather the capacity to stay in oneself and proceed from oneself, while recognising the role of the other in blossoming, or becoming, that we might call engendering, of the providence of the self.
In body and soul, we originate from another from whom we must differ, as mother, and too with whom we must find alliance. This process, engendering, continues our whole lives, we do not become separated containers available for all that is poured in, the initial relation is never abolished.
The soul is not an empty space situated in being – the soul is already received, engendered, the space of the soul is already inhabited. A letting-grow takes place, in which the subject is conscious, and participates, both engendered and engendering. A child is engendered but as a conscious adult we must continue this process of separating and alliance in difference.
To blossom presupposes recognising the one who has engendered you, and remaining grateful, toward her. A place opens, where growth is not limited to what is given but expands, with receptivity, transforming instinctive attraction into manifestation according to what is appropriate for the desiring and desired of each, love both mortal and divine. The present always as an encounter-between in a space safeguarded by our attraction, an offering made by each one in the invitation to meet. Body and soul enter in, and the work of becoming oneself is intertwined with that of the other, where visible and invisible alternate.
What was designated as representation and symbol is here given over to presence in clear and utter relation, released for their obliteration of what is real. Releasing the pretension of knowing the other. Releasing what is proper or appropriate to only one, remaining faithful to the real, and to soul, in the free play of consciousness which is the spirit of all peoples. Poetry, illumined.
Ref: Irigaray, L. (2002). The Way of Love. London: Continuum. 98 - 136.
Wednesday, December 28, 2011
Causal - the immovable cause that moves all things
From Book One - 'The Depths of the Divine', by Ken Wilber
'The Causal
In the subtle level, the Soul and God unite; in the causal level, the Soul and God are both transcended in the prior identity of Godhead, or pure formless awareness, pure consciousness as such, the pure Self as pure Spirit (Atman = Brahman). No longer the 'Supreme Union' of God and Soul, but the 'Supreme Identity' of Godhead. As Meister Eckhardt put it 'I find in this breakthrough that God and I are one and the same'.
As we will see, this pure formless Spirit is said to be the Goal and Summit and Source of all manifestation. And that is the causal.
Going within and beyond even this pure Source and pure Spirit - which is totally formless, boundless, unmanifest - the Self/Spirit awakens to an identity with, and as all Form, all manifestation (gross, subtle and causal), whether high or low, ascending or descending, sacred or profane, manifest or unmanifest, finite or infinite, temporal or eternal. This is not a particular stage among other stages - not their Goal, not their Source, not their Summit - but rather the Ground or Suchness or Isness of all stages, at all times, in all dimensions: the Being of all beings, the Condition of all conditions, the Nature of all natures. And that is the Nondual.
I have chosen Meister Eckhardt and Sri Ramana Maharshi to illustrate both of these 'stages' (causal and nondual), since we find in both of them not only a breakthrough to the causal, but also through the causal to the ultimate or Nondual, and as inadequate and misleading as words here invariably are, at least an indication of these two 'movements' can be clearly and unmistakably discerned in both of these extraordinary sages.
Sri Ramana Maharshi (echoing Shankara) summarises the 'viewpoint' of the ultimate or Nondial realisation:
The world is illusory;
Brahman alone is Real;
Brahman is the world.
The first two lines represent pure causal-level awareness, or unmanifest absorption in pure or formless Spirit,; line three represents the ultimate or nondual completion (the union of the Formless with the entire world of Form). The Godhead completely transcends all worlds and thus completely includes all worlds. It is the final within, leading to the final beyond - a beyond that, confined to absolutely nothing, embraces absolutely everything.
Eckhardt begins by pointing to the need, first and foremost, for a transcendence or 'breakthrough' (a word he coined in German) from the finite and created realm to the infinite and uncreated source or origin (the causal) a direct and formless awareness that is without self, without others and without God.
'...For in this breakthrough I discover that I and God are one. There I am what I was, and I grow neither smaller nor bigger, for I am an immovable cause that moves all things.
Therefore am I also unborn, and following the way of my unborn being I can never die. Following the way of my unborn being I have always been, I am now, and shall remain eternally.'
In order for God and the Soul to exist, there must be a duality or separation between them, and this duality, says Eckhardt, obscures the primordial Godhead:
'When I stood still in my first cause, there I had no God and was cause of myself. There I willed nothing, I desired nothing, for I was a pure Being in delight of the truth. There I stood, free of God and of all things. But when I took leave from this state and received my created being, then I had a God.'
This Godhead is radically free of any finite or created thing, whether of matter or nature or minds or vision s or soul or God. Eckhardt refers to this as completely transcendental, free, or unmanifest state by words such as 'Abyss', 'unborn', 'formless', 'primordial origin', 'emptiness', 'nothingness'.
...
This emptiness is not a theory. Even less is it poetry (which I have often heard). Nor is it a philosophical suggestion. It is a direct apprehension (direct 'experience' is not quite right, since it is free of the duality of subject and object, and since it never enters the stream of time and thus is never 'experiential' in any typical sense) - free of thoughts, free of dualities, free of time and temporal succession:
'I speak therefore of a Godhead from which as yet nothing emanates and nothing moves or is thought about. Even if the soul were to see God insofar as he is God or insofar as God can be imagined or insofar as he is a thought, this same insufficiency would be there. But when all images of the soul are taken away and the soul is only the single One, then the pure being of the soul finds resting in itself the pure, formless Being of the divine...
Neither space nor time touch this place. Nothing so much hinders the soul's understanding of God as time and space. Time and space are parts of the whole, but God is one. So if the soul is to recognise God, it must do so beyond space and time. For God is neither this nor that in the way of manifold things of earth, since God is one. if the soul wants to know God, it cannot do so in time. For so long as the soul is conscious of time and space or any other object, it cannot know God.
Know then that all our perfection and all our bliss depend on the fact that the individual goes through and beyond all creation and all temporality and all being, and enters the foundation that is without foundation. they must arrive at forgetfulness of objects and no-self consciousness - and there must be absolute silence there and stillness.'
In this state of formless and silent awareness, one does not see the Godhead, for one is the Godhead, and knows it from within, self-felt, not from without, as an object. The pure Witness cannot be seen, for the simple reason that it is the Seer (and the Seer itself is pure Emptiness, the pure opening or clearing in which all objects, experiences, things and events arise, but which itself merely abides). Anything seen is just more objects, more finite things, more images or concepts or visions, which is exactly what it is not.'
Ref. Wilber, K. (2000). Sex, Ecology and Spirituality: The Spirit of Evolution. Boston: Shambala Publications. 309-313.
'The Causal
In the subtle level, the Soul and God unite; in the causal level, the Soul and God are both transcended in the prior identity of Godhead, or pure formless awareness, pure consciousness as such, the pure Self as pure Spirit (Atman = Brahman). No longer the 'Supreme Union' of God and Soul, but the 'Supreme Identity' of Godhead. As Meister Eckhardt put it 'I find in this breakthrough that God and I are one and the same'.
As we will see, this pure formless Spirit is said to be the Goal and Summit and Source of all manifestation. And that is the causal.
Going within and beyond even this pure Source and pure Spirit - which is totally formless, boundless, unmanifest - the Self/Spirit awakens to an identity with, and as all Form, all manifestation (gross, subtle and causal), whether high or low, ascending or descending, sacred or profane, manifest or unmanifest, finite or infinite, temporal or eternal. This is not a particular stage among other stages - not their Goal, not their Source, not their Summit - but rather the Ground or Suchness or Isness of all stages, at all times, in all dimensions: the Being of all beings, the Condition of all conditions, the Nature of all natures. And that is the Nondual.
I have chosen Meister Eckhardt and Sri Ramana Maharshi to illustrate both of these 'stages' (causal and nondual), since we find in both of them not only a breakthrough to the causal, but also through the causal to the ultimate or Nondual, and as inadequate and misleading as words here invariably are, at least an indication of these two 'movements' can be clearly and unmistakably discerned in both of these extraordinary sages.
Sri Ramana Maharshi (echoing Shankara) summarises the 'viewpoint' of the ultimate or Nondial realisation:
The world is illusory;
Brahman alone is Real;
Brahman is the world.
The first two lines represent pure causal-level awareness, or unmanifest absorption in pure or formless Spirit,; line three represents the ultimate or nondual completion (the union of the Formless with the entire world of Form). The Godhead completely transcends all worlds and thus completely includes all worlds. It is the final within, leading to the final beyond - a beyond that, confined to absolutely nothing, embraces absolutely everything.
Eckhardt begins by pointing to the need, first and foremost, for a transcendence or 'breakthrough' (a word he coined in German) from the finite and created realm to the infinite and uncreated source or origin (the causal) a direct and formless awareness that is without self, without others and without God.
'...For in this breakthrough I discover that I and God are one. There I am what I was, and I grow neither smaller nor bigger, for I am an immovable cause that moves all things.
Therefore am I also unborn, and following the way of my unborn being I can never die. Following the way of my unborn being I have always been, I am now, and shall remain eternally.'
In order for God and the Soul to exist, there must be a duality or separation between them, and this duality, says Eckhardt, obscures the primordial Godhead:
'When I stood still in my first cause, there I had no God and was cause of myself. There I willed nothing, I desired nothing, for I was a pure Being in delight of the truth. There I stood, free of God and of all things. But when I took leave from this state and received my created being, then I had a God.'
This Godhead is radically free of any finite or created thing, whether of matter or nature or minds or vision s or soul or God. Eckhardt refers to this as completely transcendental, free, or unmanifest state by words such as 'Abyss', 'unborn', 'formless', 'primordial origin', 'emptiness', 'nothingness'.
...
This emptiness is not a theory. Even less is it poetry (which I have often heard). Nor is it a philosophical suggestion. It is a direct apprehension (direct 'experience' is not quite right, since it is free of the duality of subject and object, and since it never enters the stream of time and thus is never 'experiential' in any typical sense) - free of thoughts, free of dualities, free of time and temporal succession:
'I speak therefore of a Godhead from which as yet nothing emanates and nothing moves or is thought about. Even if the soul were to see God insofar as he is God or insofar as God can be imagined or insofar as he is a thought, this same insufficiency would be there. But when all images of the soul are taken away and the soul is only the single One, then the pure being of the soul finds resting in itself the pure, formless Being of the divine...
Neither space nor time touch this place. Nothing so much hinders the soul's understanding of God as time and space. Time and space are parts of the whole, but God is one. So if the soul is to recognise God, it must do so beyond space and time. For God is neither this nor that in the way of manifold things of earth, since God is one. if the soul wants to know God, it cannot do so in time. For so long as the soul is conscious of time and space or any other object, it cannot know God.
Know then that all our perfection and all our bliss depend on the fact that the individual goes through and beyond all creation and all temporality and all being, and enters the foundation that is without foundation. they must arrive at forgetfulness of objects and no-self consciousness - and there must be absolute silence there and stillness.'
In this state of formless and silent awareness, one does not see the Godhead, for one is the Godhead, and knows it from within, self-felt, not from without, as an object. The pure Witness cannot be seen, for the simple reason that it is the Seer (and the Seer itself is pure Emptiness, the pure opening or clearing in which all objects, experiences, things and events arise, but which itself merely abides). Anything seen is just more objects, more finite things, more images or concepts or visions, which is exactly what it is not.'
Ref. Wilber, K. (2000). Sex, Ecology and Spirituality: The Spirit of Evolution. Boston: Shambala Publications. 309-313.
Friday, December 23, 2011
Way of Love by Luce Irigaray - Being with the Other
The Creation of the Verb
Walking into the space of being with the other, a different way of speaking is required from that which we already know. Demanding that we forget words as previously defined, moving beyond the frontier of the word, and asking language itself how it might accede to proximity.
Making a new way in loving speech cannot go by a history of loves of a whole people, these collective imperatives stretch too far beyond the personal. Rather, indirect ways of advancing might emerge, beyond the interlacings of an existing saying to the unsheltered crossroads where the other awaits, with meaning unknown.
Almost everything must be rebuilt in this relation, and speech can help to change levels both vertically and horizontally. In order to listen to the other, to open one’s heart horizontally, to attain oneself in the springing forth of the intimate without obstructing the path that we might return to source.
Verbs outlay traces, sketch perspectives and broach horizons, both of the subject and in the infinitive, that still undifferentiated, common energy. Active and passive, interrogative and injunctive, verbs build a bridge between two subjects or two moments, or aspects of the self. The verb is the instrument of construction of the subject, of the world, of relation with the other, marking out paths, building scaffolding and transportation.
Every construction is unique, and sets the ground for uniqueness – human consciousness is not awakened nor quenched in speaking ‘like everyone else’. Where a subject does not have within themselves the source of their own movement, and they are locked in descriptors or nouns, they lose their quality as subject, a mechanism pronounced by an energy that is not free.
The substantive, or the noun, can be seen to immobilise time, a kind of ideal in designating, a merging once and for all with an arbitrary sound force and matter. Nouns are not that which corresponds to present meaning for a subject who might utter their own perceptions, affects or desires.
A word can be a treasure, a passing of discovery from one to another. In this way they would not be a communion in the already said, which would rather paralyse in an illusion of speaking, background noise impregnating the flesh of the word. We must learn to speak not from the already-existent, but to succeed in transforming what emerges into saying. It is not possible to learn once and for all how to speak, each moment should be a radical injunction in newness, inventing a new speaking moment to moment, listening with radically new ears.
If the other calls out to me, it is certainly not thanks to naming that I will succeed in entering into relation with him. And it is not a word that will allow me to approach him, especially since the approach must be bilateral, I not only approach you, but we must approach one another. And we risk the noun-word taking away this togetherness, words that both deliver and conceal meaning and do not represent at any rate the attraction or desire, a wanting for which we still have to invent words while continuing to listen to the other.
Letting Be Transcendence
The distance from the other can be considered as an interior space which is available to welcome their words. The distance can never be fully overcome, no matter the clearing of a prioris, freeing from solipsistic certitude or arranging of silence. The interval is never covered, always to be passed through, maintained, and started, anew. Transcendence between us demands an interval woven of air and flesh, fecund in graces. Air rather than emptiness, inhabited by vibration, space to live, grow and speak with modulating sound, crying and whispering. Shouting. Drawing from it what we each need, nourishing as it becomes part of our flesh and the flesh of our words. Air crossing the limits of our different worlds, permitting communion.
To approach each other is not to live in the one neighbourhood but to encounter the diverse alien of the other, no matter the treasure-words and flower-words that might seduce the senses into commonality. Even the unity of the self must be compromised by mediations in order to be constituted, here we can see easily that there is a co-belonging in a whole which maintains togetherness, even in differentiation.
To deeply experience this co-belonging implies leaving representative thought and letting go into the Being which already inhabits us, constitutes us and surrounds us. Difference itself in times provides the necessary mediations to constitute Being, even if we presume to believe we maintain complete stillness. We are always partly open to the world, even where we turn to history as more fixed than God, the divine that guides steps towards difference always without any possibility of completely and actually experiencing it.
The ground of being less admits a multiplicity of interweavings within which man could dwell, both safeguarded and enclosed. Yet the ground may be constituted in relation, an unthought hypokeimenon of the subject, a double ground which the subject does not reach when losing hold, because the constitution of the subjects Being prevents a return there. Yet we arrange subjects in front of ourselves in relation, this is our task. Without our mother, there is no engendering or birth, no awakening of consciousness, her role in Being is not nothing, although it is frequently unthought or unconscious.
‘The end is the beginning’, yes, although this statement forgets the beginning for the end, leaving it in the unthought, and this is an important part of the relation between subjects. Returning to the mother does not permit the reclaiming of Being or the ground, return can only be dialecticised in a different way – an engendering where one emerges from the other and the other from the one in a recovering of all being brought into the world, all coming into the world. The veiling of this difference is the evoking of a will to know nothing of one’s own birth. The origin of Being begins with being in-relation-with and being born-of.
In this primitive moment of consciousness of our substitutive role, we find ourselves unconstituted, unsheltered from constructions, perhaps more alone and naked when others draw near when he steps back too so as to be capable of not assimilating the one who enters his world. The one who arrives is an event on a horizon, for a welcoming to be real one must step beyond one’s own horizon to question the unknown who comes.
No event more unveiling of oneself and Being can happen. To get to the other we must go around our own world which takes us to the return to the origin of our own world, but only in this way can we open ourselves to the other who will never have a site in the origin. The unity of being with the other becomes the unity of relation with the other, which accounts for their difference. A unity that is open and has its own autonomy. The unity is a creation, a work elaborated from an attraction between two, a desire and an already conceived ‘with the other’.
This relation cannot be subordinated to own pleasure, on pain of fragmenting human being, itself. If the Being of only one of the two elements is taken as the only pole of division, relation with the other becomes impossible, an amputated Being, annihilating the other and the virgin space between them. What safeguards a between two is an opening in fidelity to self and other in their irreducibility.
Thought then represents the building of a bridge between two subjects, each bringing a singular contribution proper to oneself and appropriate to the other. You are not empty of content, and the intention which animates us must take account of our relation, constructing the objectivity of our subjectivity in the space with the other, as human/s. Subjectivity is relational. An interior reserve, which permits listening, welcoming and a response which respects the relation can be constructed. Another relation to space and time must be built, space for differences to be transformed in time into a kind of spiritual matter, human being existing only in relational becoming.
The link to Being thus becomes at a minimum, dual, and identity is not an equation between thinking and Being, but rather a known difference between two subjectivities, even if they are internal and not constituted as two distinct humans. Identity takes root in becoming, and is not appraised by similitude but rather is compelled by care of the human, and care of the other.
Identity too becomes the unveiling of a still closed sky, approaching a world of co-belonging, the dialogue between living subjects or subjectivities opening and closing in each moment the question of what Being is. Indirectly we appear to each other in faithfulness to ourselves, always transfiguring in appearance according to an interiority which is invisible but which accounts for you as other. We can never fully say ourselves.
Being in relation with the other
To continue our own human becoming we need to introduce a dialectic in our own subjectivity which examines and sets in place transformation even while we are partially blind to Being. The becoming conscious implicates a turning-back of the subject into the subject, making occasion for an unveiling.
Relation with the other cannot exist without a similar gesture of reciprocal recognition, looking to the space we make available for common mediation between our two subjectivities. We do not start from emptiness or nothing, as we enter this space, in the same way we do not start from emptiness when we re-visit our own history seeking deeper consciousness.
Identity needs to be approached not merely as emerging from same with itself, but as a co-belonging , a being-in-relation. It calls out a new grammar of thinking, going back to the foundations that serve as both a floor and a roof for Western metaphysics. In the old, the world that man constructs exiles him from himself, the little bit of Being that was allowed preserved in a small patch of glimpsed sky in a remote universal.
In the dimension of ourselves where Being still quivers identity is never definitively constituted. Identity is elaborated in relation with the other, a giving and receiving where life is not paralysed in multiple deaths, but is fed back to us in the continual death to the self-that-was, from outside ourselves.
For Hegel the absolute truth is that which knows itself and not that which is thought by a subject who announces that he knows himself absolutely. Being is thought from an exterior, an external perspective, where the task is not so much to ascend in absolute thought without reference to the flesh that is devoted to its service, but rather, to transubstantiate in this relation and in relation to the other the dialectical process, which enriches the becoming of woman, as woman.
Ref: Irigaray, L. (2002). The Way of Love. London: Continuum. 62 - 97.
Walking into the space of being with the other, a different way of speaking is required from that which we already know. Demanding that we forget words as previously defined, moving beyond the frontier of the word, and asking language itself how it might accede to proximity.
Making a new way in loving speech cannot go by a history of loves of a whole people, these collective imperatives stretch too far beyond the personal. Rather, indirect ways of advancing might emerge, beyond the interlacings of an existing saying to the unsheltered crossroads where the other awaits, with meaning unknown.
Almost everything must be rebuilt in this relation, and speech can help to change levels both vertically and horizontally. In order to listen to the other, to open one’s heart horizontally, to attain oneself in the springing forth of the intimate without obstructing the path that we might return to source.
Verbs outlay traces, sketch perspectives and broach horizons, both of the subject and in the infinitive, that still undifferentiated, common energy. Active and passive, interrogative and injunctive, verbs build a bridge between two subjects or two moments, or aspects of the self. The verb is the instrument of construction of the subject, of the world, of relation with the other, marking out paths, building scaffolding and transportation.
Every construction is unique, and sets the ground for uniqueness – human consciousness is not awakened nor quenched in speaking ‘like everyone else’. Where a subject does not have within themselves the source of their own movement, and they are locked in descriptors or nouns, they lose their quality as subject, a mechanism pronounced by an energy that is not free.
The substantive, or the noun, can be seen to immobilise time, a kind of ideal in designating, a merging once and for all with an arbitrary sound force and matter. Nouns are not that which corresponds to present meaning for a subject who might utter their own perceptions, affects or desires.
A word can be a treasure, a passing of discovery from one to another. In this way they would not be a communion in the already said, which would rather paralyse in an illusion of speaking, background noise impregnating the flesh of the word. We must learn to speak not from the already-existent, but to succeed in transforming what emerges into saying. It is not possible to learn once and for all how to speak, each moment should be a radical injunction in newness, inventing a new speaking moment to moment, listening with radically new ears.
If the other calls out to me, it is certainly not thanks to naming that I will succeed in entering into relation with him. And it is not a word that will allow me to approach him, especially since the approach must be bilateral, I not only approach you, but we must approach one another. And we risk the noun-word taking away this togetherness, words that both deliver and conceal meaning and do not represent at any rate the attraction or desire, a wanting for which we still have to invent words while continuing to listen to the other.
Letting Be Transcendence
The distance from the other can be considered as an interior space which is available to welcome their words. The distance can never be fully overcome, no matter the clearing of a prioris, freeing from solipsistic certitude or arranging of silence. The interval is never covered, always to be passed through, maintained, and started, anew. Transcendence between us demands an interval woven of air and flesh, fecund in graces. Air rather than emptiness, inhabited by vibration, space to live, grow and speak with modulating sound, crying and whispering. Shouting. Drawing from it what we each need, nourishing as it becomes part of our flesh and the flesh of our words. Air crossing the limits of our different worlds, permitting communion.
To approach each other is not to live in the one neighbourhood but to encounter the diverse alien of the other, no matter the treasure-words and flower-words that might seduce the senses into commonality. Even the unity of the self must be compromised by mediations in order to be constituted, here we can see easily that there is a co-belonging in a whole which maintains togetherness, even in differentiation.
To deeply experience this co-belonging implies leaving representative thought and letting go into the Being which already inhabits us, constitutes us and surrounds us. Difference itself in times provides the necessary mediations to constitute Being, even if we presume to believe we maintain complete stillness. We are always partly open to the world, even where we turn to history as more fixed than God, the divine that guides steps towards difference always without any possibility of completely and actually experiencing it.
The ground of being less admits a multiplicity of interweavings within which man could dwell, both safeguarded and enclosed. Yet the ground may be constituted in relation, an unthought hypokeimenon of the subject, a double ground which the subject does not reach when losing hold, because the constitution of the subjects Being prevents a return there. Yet we arrange subjects in front of ourselves in relation, this is our task. Without our mother, there is no engendering or birth, no awakening of consciousness, her role in Being is not nothing, although it is frequently unthought or unconscious.
‘The end is the beginning’, yes, although this statement forgets the beginning for the end, leaving it in the unthought, and this is an important part of the relation between subjects. Returning to the mother does not permit the reclaiming of Being or the ground, return can only be dialecticised in a different way – an engendering where one emerges from the other and the other from the one in a recovering of all being brought into the world, all coming into the world. The veiling of this difference is the evoking of a will to know nothing of one’s own birth. The origin of Being begins with being in-relation-with and being born-of.
In this primitive moment of consciousness of our substitutive role, we find ourselves unconstituted, unsheltered from constructions, perhaps more alone and naked when others draw near when he steps back too so as to be capable of not assimilating the one who enters his world. The one who arrives is an event on a horizon, for a welcoming to be real one must step beyond one’s own horizon to question the unknown who comes.
No event more unveiling of oneself and Being can happen. To get to the other we must go around our own world which takes us to the return to the origin of our own world, but only in this way can we open ourselves to the other who will never have a site in the origin. The unity of being with the other becomes the unity of relation with the other, which accounts for their difference. A unity that is open and has its own autonomy. The unity is a creation, a work elaborated from an attraction between two, a desire and an already conceived ‘with the other’.
This relation cannot be subordinated to own pleasure, on pain of fragmenting human being, itself. If the Being of only one of the two elements is taken as the only pole of division, relation with the other becomes impossible, an amputated Being, annihilating the other and the virgin space between them. What safeguards a between two is an opening in fidelity to self and other in their irreducibility.
Thought then represents the building of a bridge between two subjects, each bringing a singular contribution proper to oneself and appropriate to the other. You are not empty of content, and the intention which animates us must take account of our relation, constructing the objectivity of our subjectivity in the space with the other, as human/s. Subjectivity is relational. An interior reserve, which permits listening, welcoming and a response which respects the relation can be constructed. Another relation to space and time must be built, space for differences to be transformed in time into a kind of spiritual matter, human being existing only in relational becoming.
The link to Being thus becomes at a minimum, dual, and identity is not an equation between thinking and Being, but rather a known difference between two subjectivities, even if they are internal and not constituted as two distinct humans. Identity takes root in becoming, and is not appraised by similitude but rather is compelled by care of the human, and care of the other.
Identity too becomes the unveiling of a still closed sky, approaching a world of co-belonging, the dialogue between living subjects or subjectivities opening and closing in each moment the question of what Being is. Indirectly we appear to each other in faithfulness to ourselves, always transfiguring in appearance according to an interiority which is invisible but which accounts for you as other. We can never fully say ourselves.
Being in relation with the other
To continue our own human becoming we need to introduce a dialectic in our own subjectivity which examines and sets in place transformation even while we are partially blind to Being. The becoming conscious implicates a turning-back of the subject into the subject, making occasion for an unveiling.
Relation with the other cannot exist without a similar gesture of reciprocal recognition, looking to the space we make available for common mediation between our two subjectivities. We do not start from emptiness or nothing, as we enter this space, in the same way we do not start from emptiness when we re-visit our own history seeking deeper consciousness.
Identity needs to be approached not merely as emerging from same with itself, but as a co-belonging , a being-in-relation. It calls out a new grammar of thinking, going back to the foundations that serve as both a floor and a roof for Western metaphysics. In the old, the world that man constructs exiles him from himself, the little bit of Being that was allowed preserved in a small patch of glimpsed sky in a remote universal.
In the dimension of ourselves where Being still quivers identity is never definitively constituted. Identity is elaborated in relation with the other, a giving and receiving where life is not paralysed in multiple deaths, but is fed back to us in the continual death to the self-that-was, from outside ourselves.
For Hegel the absolute truth is that which knows itself and not that which is thought by a subject who announces that he knows himself absolutely. Being is thought from an exterior, an external perspective, where the task is not so much to ascend in absolute thought without reference to the flesh that is devoted to its service, but rather, to transubstantiate in this relation and in relation to the other the dialectical process, which enriches the becoming of woman, as woman.
Ref: Irigaray, L. (2002). The Way of Love. London: Continuum. 62 - 97.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)