Friday, July 31, 2009

The Wisdom of Selflessness

Tonight at the Vajrayana Institute, Geshe Samten continued teaching Lama Tsong Khapa's Lam Rim Chen Mo, 'The Special Insight on the Path of Enlightenment'. This week we read about the path of training in analytical meditation, which is pursued after stability has been reached in calm abiding meditation. The intuitive hits that I got around several of my stuckness-es inspired a Chariots of Fire style knees-up run this evening (ah, here's my mojo...).

Anyway.

One key learning for me has been that dharma words have quite specific meaning in Buddhist discourse.

'Emptiness' is a good example, and was a key to most of my revelations tonight.

Geshe Samten started out advising us to debate and discuss these ideas, to interrupt and to argue, while he was teaching us the points of distinction between the commentaries on the text from the great teachers. By virtue of this discursive practice, he argued that we 'bring the memory alive', and are in a better position to analyse our own interpretation of the texts once we have listened to and understood other people's perspectives.

Chapter 7, 'Why Insight Is Needed', starts from our achievements in concentrated meditative serenity, which include non-discursiveness, clarity and the delightful and blissful physical and mental benefits of these two. While these are wonderful achievements, bodhisattvas throughout time who wish to be liberated from samsara realise that concentration itself cannot eliminate the conception of the self. Concentration does not reveal profound meaning, or wisdom.

Wisdom is the dawn of knowledge that obliterates the seeds of confusion. Wisdom is proposed to come from being 'one who listens to others', this one who will then be 'free from aging and death'.

Buddha proposed this idea, of listening to others, to refute the notion that we can develop a notion of selflessness from within ourselves.

Selflessness takes on a critical meaning here too. In my recent posts, I've been rattling on about the deconstruction of the ego, about how I never felt I had a very strong ego because I've felt as though I've been most grounded when I hold other people's needs as quite dear. My take on ego could be loosely termed as a form of 'selflessness', although not a very pious form of selflessness, at that. My reified selflessness looks like an empty cardboard cutout after tonight, where I now understand selflessness in terms of the Lam Rim text. This is an emptiness of the self, both as a person, and emptiness of a self as an experience of all phenomena. Ultimately here, there is boundless groundlessness. This can be clarified by analysing the characteristics of an object across many levels of reality:

- the reality of it's gross form - shape, colour, size;
- the reality of it's subtle impermanence - realised through inferential cognising, or logic;
- the final reality of the emptiness of the object, where no analysis can be continued beyond this point, the collapse of logic;
- and finally, seeing all these things, the dawn of knowledge of special insight into emptiness, which eliminates the seeds of ignorance.

Here's another important point: the seeds of ignorance are in the grasping. Grasping, with the mind, is the delimiter on samsara and nirvana. That self of me, who wants to know all about everyone elses needs, she's still grasping, still identified. The cycle of samsara is continued. This notion can be logically followed all the way to generosity, to great compassion and loving kindness and joyous effort, all of which are noble and worthy and fulfilling, but none of which can break the cycle of samsara, as none of them directly engage with the root of ignorance and confusion. In terms of the Lam Rim, it could only be the opposite of ignorance, the opposite of confusion, a light for these darknesses, that stancds a chance of dispelling their vile traps. Only the total opposite of a conditioned mind can eliminate ignorance.

The wisdom of selflessness eliminates the root of cyclic existence.

I like it. And I love running.

Monday, July 27, 2009

Terce - the third hour in Roman reckoning

Avoid getting into debt, except the debt of mutual love. If you love your fellow men you have carried out your obligations. Love is the one thing that cannot hurt your neighbour; that is why it is the answer to every one of the commandments. Romans 13:8,10

Saturday, July 25, 2009

Detranscendentalisation - Hegel via Habermas

'Hegel's preferred mode of explanation refers to various forms of mutual recognition. From early on, he chooses 'being in love with and being loved by somebody' as a key to analysing the modern version of the classical Aristotlean notion of ethical life. In a love relationship, the object of recognition is the character and natural individuality of an entire, sexually attractive person. The passionate relation itself is described as 'being for the other' (Sein fur Anderes) which gives the lover in turn 'the satisfaction of having one's own essence in the other'. In a symmetrical relation the point of mutual recognition is that the two persons involved seem to sacrifice their independence; but in fact each gains a new kind of independence by coming to recognise, in the mirror of the eyes of the other person, who he or she is. Both become for themselves the kind of characters they mutually attribute to each other. Both gain awareness of their individuality by seeing their own images reflected in the dense and deep exchange of an intimate interpersonal relation.'

Habermas, J. (1999). From Kant to Hegel and Back again – The Move Towards Detranscendentralization. European Journal of Philosophy, 7 (2), 129 - 157

Thursday, July 23, 2009

Interiority

Have you ever looked at a photo of somebody that you loved, who has disincarnated from the earth, and found yourself smiling at that photo, just as you would if you met them on your front doorstep?

I've had reason, lately, to spend some time thinking about this - when someone leaves our mortal earth, when I'm most sharply aware, and hurting, over the sense of all of this life-ness that I'm graced to be a part of, but the other being no longer has access to, when a part of my life has been absorbed with time spent with this person, what of the persons interiority gets left behind, here, on earth, amongst us?

Interiority becomes apparent in the sharing, the moments of co-existence, that we have between us, these moments that let me know bits about who that person is, on the inside. Revealed this way, interiority has many layers. There's the outer level, of actions-in-common, of ten-pin bowling games, of hours spent in geography class learning about tundra, of passing the black pepper grinder at the dinner table. There's the limbic level, of likes and dislikes in common, parmesan cheese, Julian Clary, was Red, White or Blue reaallly the best movie? There's the time spent enjoying each others company, comfortably silent on a long drive, passionately ranting about Intervention policy, all of these.

There's that level further down, of deeply knowing, of resonating with, each others fears, anxieties, dreams, visions. There's the shredding heartbreak of having been through a shared trauma, or sharing the raw, cold edged playground bench that we've sat on together on the other side of it. For some people there's fifty years of marriage that captures the shared time/space corner where you can see the movements of one partner echoed in the other as they help each other make dinner in the kitchen. Words can't account for that level of knowing. 'Love' doesn't quite capture the earthed-connectedness that I sense when I hit this core of knowing with another human being. It's not an interaction, it's a tune, a pattern ingrained and intertwined, hummed in the moment.

It's stunning to me to sit in an observant space and actually watch my own responses to other people. No two, no two, of my intonations, my eye-brow raises, my hand gestures, my big-arsed or sneaky-Machiavellian smiles are the same for each person that I am blessed to encounter in a day. Every interaction between two human beings is it's own language. Every single one.

So when I smile back at that photo, of that person now departed, I think that smile might reflect back to the world a small component of the interiority of that other human being. Without myth, without channelled spirits, without resorting to Freudian psychology, pheremonal biology or game theory, we all, each of us, carry around this vast accumulation of a lifetime spent experiencing the interiority of others.

En-souled.

To be honest, there's not much about our world that I can honestly say makes me want to be a better person. This awareness, that I'm sort of a living representative of those people I love so deeply, who have passed from this world, does a lot for helping me to do what I've heard termed recently as 'suck it in'.

Maybe that's X-gen code for inspiration.

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

On the Memorial of Mary Magdalene


In the 'Secrets of Mary Magdalene', (edited by D. Burstein and A.J. De Keijzer, 2006) former Catholic priest James Carroll heralds Pope St Gregory I (the Great) (d.604) as instrumental in recasting the role of Mary Magdalene as a harlot, as a sinful woman, as the scourge of unworthy thoughts of those celibate monks and priests of the church. Through a series of homilies, St Gregory describes 'the perfume of her flesh', 'the hair to set off her face', 'the proud mouth that kisses the Lord's feet', a scandalous woman, an 'ideal of virtue that drew (her) heat from being a celibate's vision'.

But it's possible, I think, that James Carroll's vehemence may represent a personal struggle. As I read St Gregory's Homily this morning in the Divine Office, Mary's desire, the fire of love that melts the soul, echoes to me as a prayer, in and of itself. Keep on searching.


See what you think:

Ref: http://www.universalis.com/readings.htm

When Mary Magdalene came to the tomb and did not find the Lord’s body, she thought it had been taken away and so informed the disciples. After they came and saw the tomb, they too believed what Mary had told them. The text then says: The disciples went back home, and it adds: but Mary wept and remained standing outside the tomb.

We should reflect on Mary’s attitude and the great love she felt for Christ; for though the disciples had left the tomb, she remained. She was still seeking the one she had not found, and while she sought she wept; burning with the fire of love, she longed for him who she thought had been taken away. And so it happened that the woman who stayed behind to seek Christ was the only one to see him. For perseverance is essential to any good deed, as the voice of truth tells us: Whoever perseveres to the end will be saved.

At first she sought but did not find, but when she persevered it happened that she found what she was looking for. When our desires are not satisfied, they grow stronger, and becoming stronger they take hold of their object. Holy desires likewise grow with anticipation, and if they do not grow they are not really desires. Anyone who succeeds in attaining the truth has burned with such a great love. As David says: My soul has thirsted for the living God; when shall I come and appear before the face of God? And so also in the Song of Songs the Church says: I was wounded by love; and again: My soul is melted with love.

Woman, why are you weeping? Whom do you seek? She is asked why she is sorrowing so that her desire might be strengthened; for when she mentions whom she is seeking, her love is kindled all the more ardently.

Jesus says to her: Mary. Jesus is not recognised when he calls her “woman”; so he calls her by name, as though he were saying: Recognise me as I recognise you; for I do not know you as I know others; I know you as yourself. And so Mary, once addressed by name, recognises who is speaking. She immediately calls him rabboni, that is to say, teacher, because the one whom she sought outwardly was the one who inwardly taught her to keep on searching.

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Purity, Danger and Paradox

The final installment from Chapter 3, 'Mystics and Ascetics' from Matthew Bagger's 'The Uses of Paradox' begins with Mary Douglas.

Mary Douglas explores what she calls ‘a sociology of the uses of logic’, delving into an apprehension of what is ‘right and necessary in social relations’. Searching for stability and psychological consonance, we see people vest nature and reason with the authority to regulate social discourse.

Douglas parallels societies responses to hybrids and anomalies that arise in the classification of animal to the attitudes to outsiders held by those societies.Those that view the incorporation of outsiders as enriching will venerate the outsiders and view them as auspicious, while a social group that finds it’s external boundaries threatened by outsiders will abominate anomalies and view them as dangerous.

The biases that form around these beliefs by outsiders enlist emotional energy – abominable beasts shock and viscerally offend, sacred mediators, on the other hand, evoke awe and reverence. If we categorise ‘paradox’ as one of these taxonomic anomalies, we reflect the different responses that can be seen in attitudes towards paradox that are held by the mystics and ascetics. As an encountered ‘alien’, paradox can be brought within the recognised boundaries of the cognisable, or be left beyond the pale.

Bagger’s theory is far more psychological than Douglas’ functionalist thesis, and Bagger proposes that the availability bias of cognitive psychology is evident in human attitudes towards paradox. As could be expected to occur in line with the human capacity to, well, think, experimental evidence shows that merely drawing attention to the potential cause of an event will increase the likelihood that people will identify that potential cause as an actual cause of an event.

In regards to attitudes to anomalies, then, the more subjectively important the external boundary is to a person, the more it is available to their consciousness, and so a generalised attitude to paradox (paradox as an ‘outsider’) could be expected to include that paradox as a threat, which leads to an orientation towards cognitive asceticism, where the dirty, unclear thoughts of paradox get cleaned up, or shipped out.

Note in this context paradox becomes extraordinarily useful for legitimating a social vision, because paradox now functions to exemplify the dangers (or at the other end of the spectrum, rewards) of crossing social boundaries.

Bagger proposes that in order to preserve his argument, he must establish that 1) correlations do exists between attitudes towards outsiders and attitudes towards paradox and 2) demonstrate the direction of causality as running from the attitude to outsiders to the attitude to paradox.

Pseudo-Dionysius’corpus is purported to provide just such evidence – Pseudo-Dionysius argues that God’s powers of purification, illumination and perfection are symbolically reflected in the hierarchy of angels and the hierarchy organising the church. The church, as an image of the Divine, is divided into distinctive orders and powers to reveal that the activities of the divinity are preeminent for the utter holiness and purity, permanence and distinctiveness of their orders. He actually argues that the threat of pollution protects the conformity of the orders, and so for Pseudo-Dionysius, the cosmic order serves to legitimate a social order revealing that his mystical theology does not differ in reflecting his social preoccupations.

The whole purpose of the ecclesiastical hierarchy and liturgy of the church is to initiate people. Salvation can only occur through divinisation, which consists as much as possible of being ‘like and in union with God’. So the very reason for having the social group becomes to bring others into the group, carefully controlled, of course, if the group is to retain it’s character. Pseudo-Dionysius dogmatically reminds us that the ‘impure’ people would defile the sacred teachings – deacons, in fact, are charged with the task of purging the uninitiated, and maintaining the external boundary of the group. The deacons are given responsibility of the doors, and postulants must submit to total purification before they can be allowed to come into the presence of the sacred.

Pseudo-Dionysius views paradoxes congenially – a sacred cognitive mediator that provides occasion for union with the divine. His mystical cognitive practice transforms the self by invoking awe and reverence at the moment of realisation of the immanence of God in all of creation, decentering selfish desires and promoting an identification with God’s wider perspective.

While for Pseudo-Dionysius positive attitudes to incorporation of outsiders produces a bias that views paradox as revelatory, Kirkegaard’s focus on boundaries and limits requires in his understanding that unless one confronts the possibility of offence at the Christian paradox, one is not essentially Christian. Paradox for Kirkegaard arouses emotion that we could identify as expected in approaching the abominable. The paradox is not merely vexing, it is horrible, appalling and offensive. Kirkegaard yokes this to his ascetic suffering – indeed, for Kirkegaard, paradox becomes the pus that hagiographers insist Catherine of Siena chose to drink – both try to overcome offense to transform themselves in relation to God.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

The Dark Light

More from Matthew Bagger's 'The Uses of Paradox' - Chapter 3 on 'Mystics and Ascetics'.

Nicholas of Kues(Cusa) was a 15th century German Roman Catholic cardinal, whose writings include mystical treatises and philosophical and mathematical contributions. He was the first to use concave lenses to fix short-sightedness. Personally, on this fact alone I should probably be blessing him as a saint.

Exploring the idea that the absolute maximum cannot be a maximum relative to something else in his ‘De docta ignorantia’, Cusa hits on the idea that there is nothing lesser than the absolute maximum – but this, indeed becomes the absolute minimum! God as the absolute maximum is the transcendent simplicity, prior to contradictories, the enfolding (complicatio) of all and the unfolding (explicatio) of all. God transcends reason (ratio), which imposes names and operates by means of names and their opposites. ‘Learned ignorance’ consists in exploiting and then transcending all words, ‘every act of reason’ to ‘ascend to simple intellectuality to see God incomprehensibly'. The effort of human intelligence should be to raise itself to that simplicity where contradictories coincide.

Pseudo-Dionysius and Nicholas of Cusa differ from Hegel in that they both think that the deeper knowledge attained through paradox remains ineffable, whereas Hegel, in pursing the speculative, tries to articulate it. The awe, mystery and piety are what the mystic takes to be revelatory – the resistance to language lends to the paradoxes the sense that they have extraordinary cognitive content to disclose.

The Christian concept of mystery includes both doctrines regarding truth as well as on the very intelligibility of which one must take on faith. Mystery connotes that some truths resist rational articulation – there is a second order cognition that assures against absurdity to reduce first-order dissonance.

In Buddhism, the Madhyamaka texts portray anupalabdhidharmaksanti (intuitive tolerance of the incomprehensibility of all things) as enabling the development of prajna (intense knowing) and aryajnana (holy intuition), that is, enabling a transcendent cognitive state that discloses the ultimate truth about reality. This is necessary to the bodhisattva path, where the individual encountering the Madhyamaka doctrine of the emptiness of all things must paradoxically realise that the doctrine itself therefore must also be empty. Cultivation of tolerance of incomprehensibility allows for the ease of dissonance that the doctrine of emptiness would otherwise arouse.

John of the Cross pursues cognitive asceticism using Pseudo-Dionysius’ darkness and illumination imagery. Following the path of purgation, illumination and union, a night to the senses is the first dark night that is proposed, where, in the ‘Ascent of Mount Carmel’, St John describes the purgation of desires for worldly goods and attachments. The second night of the journey by the soul to union with God is passed by way of faith – that is, as ‘dark as night to the understanding’. Will and memory too are subject to total annihilation, a ‘death to the natural self’ is undertaken. The third night is the destination, God – described as the dark of dawn before the onset of illumination by God’s incomparable light, in ‘The Dark Night’.

Nurturing cognitive dissonance appears to be a key to St John’s Dark Nights – rigorous self denial, coupled with the faith that if God is darkness, we too must be prepared to enter into this darkness, purging the understanding in pursuit of the incomprehensible. For John, the vertigo of self-contradiction induced by faith abets detachment.

Entering deeply into the experience of faith, in and of itself, is what St John proclaims as the path to true mystical experience of God –

‘For not only does it give no information and knowledge, but, as we have said, it deprives us of all other information and knowledge, and blinds us to them, so that they cannot judge it well. For other knowledge can be acquired by the light of the understanding, but the knowledge that is of faith is acquired without the illumination of the understanding, which is rejected for faith’.

Thus, the soul is left resigned, detached and annihilated, self reliance is eliminated, and now it is prepared for union with God. We are humbled.

Note that we are humbled in a different way to that proposed by Kirkegaard, of perpetual martyrdom – St John proposes that after purgation, there is the illumination, the dawning of God.