Monday, November 30, 2009

'Indeed the Lord is in this place, and I knew it not.'

Genesis 28
'10 But Jacob being departed from Bersabee, went on to Haran. 11 And when he had come to a certain place, and would rest in it after sunset, he took of the stones that lay there, and putting under his head, slept in the same place. 12 And he saw in his sleep a ladder standing upon the earth, and the top thereof touching heaven: the angels also of God ascending and descending by it. 13 And the Lord leaning upon the ladder saying to him: I am the Lord God of Abraham your father, and the God of Isaac: The land, wherein you sleep, I will give to you and to your seed. 14 And your seed shall be as the dust of the earth: you shall spread abroad to the west, and to the east, and to the north, and to the south: and in you and your seed, all the tribes of the earth shall be blessed. 15 And I will be your keeper wherever you go, and will bring you back into this land: neither will I leave you, till I shall have accomplished all that I have said. 16 And when Jacob awaked out of sleep, he said: Indeed the Lord is in this place, and I knew it not.'

I'm halfway through listening to a thrilling podcast from 'Encounter', called 'Black Fire on White Fire', which is about biblical Hebrew and the intertwining of it's patterns through Judaic thought.

'Thrilling?' I hear you say, with one eyebrow raised.

Thrilling, yes, because of the distinction it makes regarding the use of language in a Christianity vs Judaism dichotomy - framed roughly as syllogistic versus dialogic approaches to 'The Word of God'. Syllogisms contain their own logical flow, a directional end is indicated, and in Christianity this is shaped by the J-man, nailed and drooping on the cross in John 19:30, uttering 'it is finished'. The messenger who (is conflated as) the message has been, and gone. The revealed truth, described as the transformation of the crucifixion in Christianity, has but one task to complete -thy will be done. Language is merely the means used to describe the all-important content, of one sandal wearer's life.

Judaism is contrasted with this - in Judaism, language is not only the vehicle, language is the transformation. In one way to me this looks like a step backward, where developmentally, it looks a little like belief or holiness is a little more closely and directly invested in the revelation that emerges from the words.

But, in the words of David Patterson from an interview in the podcast, 'In Judaism, where there's revelation, there's a question, and the question put to the first human being is 'Where are you?'.

So, another view is that the little bit of holiness, or belief, that is invested in the living translations of the text allow the text to sprout a few more leaves of possibility, to draw an awkward analogy. There's a little more openness to the co-emergence that happens when an old story is redefined in a language that morphs and changes with the people who grow and use it.

By extension I could get all carried away and propose that maybe this serves as a cue to keep our human minds a little more open as well. Twill be good to listen to the rest of the podcast, yea verily:



I think close inspection of both the transformative movement and the utopian obsession is well warranted, and feels to me to be somewhat overdue.

From whence arises this fascination with teleology and salvation? If it's an ancient vestige of a primitive mind, how come both, dressed up in different ways in our postmodern era, are still so 'at hand'?

I love the Genesis line in the title. That's something to wake up to, everyday, for sure.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Threes

Professor Robert Sternberg is a well known researcher in psychology, and he's a man with a passion for threes - that is, the theories for which he is most well known include a triarchic theory of intelligence and a triangular theory of love.

I'm recording this here 'cos I want to come back to it after I've finished digesting all of the relevant components of 'Principles of Psychological Assessment', and survived biting my nails through to the quick in sheer nervousness about my upcoming exams. There's something in here my brain can't quite catch, but that I want to give my consciousness a chance to apprehend. Maybe typing it out will help.

Sternberg's triarchic theory of intelligence proposes three fundamental aspects of intelligence - analytic, creative and practical- of which only the first is measured by mainstream tests. His investigations suggest the need for a balance between analytic intelligence on the one hand, and creative and especially practical intelligence on the other....Analytic problems tend to:

a) have been formulated by other people;
b) be clearly defined;
c) come with all the information needed to solve them;
d) have only one single right answer;
e) be disembodied from ordinary experience;
f) have little or no intrinsic interest.

Practical problems on the other hand:

a) require recognition and formulation;
b) are poorly defined;
c) require information seeking;
d) have various acceptable solutions;
e) are embedded in and require everyday experience;
f) require motivation and personal involvement.

One important form of practical intelligence is 'tacit knowledge', defined by Sternberg and his collaborators as 'action-oriented knowledge, acquired without direct help from others, that allows individuals to achieve goals that they personally value'.

Which is so very different from scaffolding and joint attention, a la Vygotsky, at least in principle.
Mm.

Regardless of the type of intelligence that is being measured - verbal, performance, visio-spatial, reasoning, ability to respond to non-verbal cues (I like this one, even though there are no nearly adequate tests for it, yet), speed-of-processing comes out as a consistent factor that can be isolated on a per-individual basis and remains relatively constant for an individual, over time.

The thing about speed and intelligence, for my mind (ha!), is not so much about ways that You Can Improve Your Speed Of Processing, as the way that it just shows up, in everyday life.

My example today comes from a lady, let's call her 'Andrea', who (and I was going to search for some euphemisms and PC terms, but that does little to dignify her with her actual challenges) is has a mental illness and is mostly homeless, to boot. We catch up for a cup of tea every now and then when we're in the same place, at the same time. Conversation with Andrea gets a little repetitive, but she caught me completely off guard today.....

Andrea: Oh and that Jane girl, you know the one, she gets onto a roll, that girl, and tells the same story, and tells it over and over and over again, and I don't like her, you know, I really don't....

Me: (all serious frown and concern) Why, Andrea?

Andrea: 'Cos she just says the same stuff all the time! (while attempting to catch my eye, and smiling lopsidedly) You know, not like someone else we know......

A thousand blessings upon Andrea, for waking me up from my slumber and sleep, and for sharing a giggle, at that.





Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Confessions from Killing the Buddha - The Rosary

I rediscovered the bliss (well, joy, maybe) of the Sorrowful Mysteries of the RC Rosary last night,
And I read about the Golden Rosary of the Tara Tantra in the Jonang tradition of the Vajrayana lineage.
Then today, there is this cartoon in the blogmag 'Killing the Buddha', of a childhood dream/(ob)session:

http://killingthebuddha.com/mag/confession/the-rosary/

Blessed be media, in all Her glorious forms,
May I never find the sentence to ex-press,
The pictures to im-press,
The daring to re-dress,
The veracity of Her Word.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Barbarism, Decadence, Intimacy and Abbott Suger

At first glance these subjects in the title look disparate. But in a two week stint of having felt submerged in studies on Emotional Intelligence, Buddhism and the multipolar Purkinje cell (and I'm not finished yet), I've listened to a 'Philosopher's Zone' podcast today which has landed me back in the world, eyes renewed, and happily appraising all of the above in a scenery that has changed, even when I've not been a part of it.

The podcast included an interview with John Armstrong, an Associate Professor in Philosophy working in the Melbourne Business School, and an author of a new book called 'In Search of Civilization: Remaking a Tarnished Idea'. It rocks that Business Schools now have resident Philosophers, and it's an outcome of a trend that John himself identifies in this interview. I like this talk because it looks at possibilities, because it nurtures a deeper understanding of the human condition than pop-culture positive psychology has available to it and because it follows a trend of linking philosophy and spirit together. This has some outcomes that I do find awkward, I'll explain these at the end.

My five favourite frames from John Armstrong's interview are:

FRAME 1: Abbott Suger

Armstrong starts with discussing his attempts to find a connection to an audience from deeply complex academic places, by approaching the attractions, or the intimacies, that particular fields or ideas hold for people. What are my feelings towards this thing? Why is this important? Where does this logically lead to?

As a guide in charting a course into a process for 'finding' the audience this way, Abbott Suger (soo-jay) is introduced, who was the leader of an abbey in France in the twelfth century. Suger felt that his abbey was of tremendous spiritual import, and so he wanted to open his arena of spiritual meaning to others. He came up with a developmental process, in which the core of religious ideals is seen as having beginning versions that can be accessed by all - for example seeing beauty and grandeur in a wine goblet can be a starting avenue into contemplating abstract notions such as spiritual beauty or intellectual beauty or ethical beauty. Suger was not a populist - he retained his own vision of true ideals, but found the means to connect these ideals to the community that surrounded him.

FRAME 2: Armstrong identified that relativism is often motivated by a type of generosity - a goodwill is built in to relativism, that is oven accompanied by sheer dismay at the shallowness of materiality. He speaks of retaining spirituality with materiality - learning how these complement each other, rather than encountering the conflict or competition of spirituality with materiality. Armstrong speaks of spiritual 'prosperity', and he's not talking about a shallow new-age 'believe it and you'll see it' mindset, rather that individual flourishing can be enhanced through living the big questions, out loud, deeply (see below).


FRAME 3: Flourishing - when Armstrong talks about 'flourishing' it's not an orientation towards happiness to which he points, but growth. He identifies a need in professional people to address the big questions in life, about 'how should we live?' but argues that no process has been put in place, yet, that assists the quest. He is looking for the place where points of contact between material aspects of the world connect to people's senses of meaning, and of purpose. Flourishing is not succcess, flourishing has negative and positive qualities, that is, flourishing here is based on the notion found in Aristotle's 'Ethics'.

FRAME 4: Barbarism and decadence - barbarism is 'strength without sensitivity' and is polarised against decadence, 'sensitivity without strength'. These are not characterised as negative qualities but rather are aspects of ourselves that we need to own a relationship with and to.

FRAME 5: Civilisation is a mechanism to help us cope with our darker selves, 'the beast in me', 'the crooked timbers of humanity', as quoted by Kant. We have to cope with our own weaknesses and incapabilities, and civilisation gives us a guide map for dealing constructively with our tendency to self-destruction.

Armstrong identifies three big characteristics of 'spiritual prosperity' that is, rich inner life - these are: attachment to higher things, a feeling and a drawing towards depth and complexity, and finally mental space where paradox can be held in mind.

I felt enlivened by listening to this podcast - I felt like 'it's okay to have big concerns!!' and I'm grateful that the author is charting a path for philosophy in an interdisciplinary space. My minor concern comes down to the philosophical use of the word 'spirituality' - where spirituality in a philosophical context seems often to get channelled into a highly individualised (dare I say Western culture-influenced) calyx, a spirited 'personality', a spirit of ideals.

Whereas Spirit, well, Spirit flows. You know?

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Song of Songs 8:6-7

'Love is strong as death,
jealousy as relentless as Sheol.
The flash of it is a flash of fire,
a flame of the Lord himself.
Love no floods can quench,
no torrents drown.'




A flame of the Lord himself.
The spark in the middle of
no thought, no sound, no sight, no hearing
No self.
That
with which
we are charged.

None, 28th Sunday of the Year: http://www.universalis.com/20091011/today.htm

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Rendering Love and Charity

Inspired by Terce and Sext on the Day of Our Lady of the Rosary, as listed at http://www.universalis.com/1100/today.htm

Both these readings for today contain pieces from 1 Corinthians 13, chapter 13 of St Paul's first Epistle to the Christian community of Corinth. These passages are often quoted when there's a need to address the subject of love scripturally, but this chapter also talks from a place of enactment. This is how we do it.

The original Greek word for 'love' used in this Chapter was αγαπη - agape, sacrifical love. By the time of the recording of the Vulgate, this had been identified with caritas - which originally meant something like the costliness of affection, or a high esteem (recorded sometimes as 'dilectio'). In our times these words have been rendered as charity, which has an emphasis more on what you give away, rather than the grace with which it is given.

Through time we reach the King James version of the Epistles, where charity, from the well-known triumvirate of 'faith, hope and charity' becomes love. Not desirous or sexual amor, but moreso the undeniable recognition of kindred humanity. A benevolence that stems from the simple fact that we both stand (sit, lie, kneel, crawl) in a suit of skin, blessed with senses that beg our brain to try to figure stuff out. Including (and most importantly) what might be goin' on inside, with each other.

So, holding that chunky bundle of information in mind, I'd like to invite you to join me for a slow reading of 1 Corinthians 13, where I've substituted the slightly unfamiliar word 'caritas' into the Douay-Rheims version of the chapter, and to let the sense of love that flows from the words pour over, into and upon you as you read this.


1 Corinthians 13

1If I speak with the tongues of men, and of angels, and have not caritas, I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal.

2And if I should have prophecy and should know all mysteries, and all knowledge, and if I should have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not caritas, I am nothing.

3And if I should distribute all my goods to feed the poor, and if I should deliver my body to be burned, and have not caritas, it profiteth me nothing.

4Caritas is patient, is kind: Caritas envieth not, dealeth not perversely; is not puffed up;

5Is not ambitious, seeketh not her own, is not provoked to anger, thinketh no evil;

6Rejoiceth not in iniquity, but rejoiceth with the truth;

7Beareth all things, believeth all things, hopeth all things, endureth all things.

8Caritas never falleth away: whether prophecies shall be made void, or tongues shall cease, or knowledge shall be destroyed.

9For we know in part, and we prophesy in part.

10But when that which is perfect is come, that which is in part shall be done away.

11When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child. But, when I became a man, I put away the things of a child.

12We see now through a glass in a dark manner; but then face to face. Now I know I part; but then I shall know even as I am known.

13And now there remain faith, hope, and caritas, these three: but the greatest of these is caritas.



Prophecies in part, knowledge in part, desire to overcome the gap, in full, willingness to stay, and listen, and learn, and understand, that's agape.



With a sniff of postmodernity in the reckless pursuit of the paradox:
that
love can never be enough,
communication can never be perfect,
and I cannot be you.

Sunday, October 4, 2009

Unlike other things alive -
Birds that wing their way through the air
Fish that in chill waters dive
Beasts that tread the earth
and leave their footprints there -
Man, by reason made aware,
Solely judges and discerns;
Man approaches angels
by the things he learns.

Francesco Stelluti
in Galileo Galileo's Assayer, 1623