Walking in and sitting down,
And I am stunned that you are here;
Bare cheek catches lamplight, shone from above,
Bare heart caught, watchfulness, of person.
Stretching to infinity, this sense
of Other, in the third, apportioned
in time, in responsibility, in justice.
You do not do, you do not do,
and here I
am,
otherwise,
not me, not this, not you, not mine, not us, not ours,
and yet here,
again,
not over.
'Vulnerability, exposure to outrage, to wounding, passivity more passive than all patience, passivity of the accusative form, trauma of accusation suffered by a hostage to the point of persecution, implicating the identity of the hostage who substitutes himself for others; all this is the self, a defecting or defeat of the ego's identity. And this, pushed to the limit, is sensibility, sensibility as the subjectivity of the subject. It is a substitution for another, one in place of another, expiation'. ~ Levinas, Otherwise than Being
Monday, October 4, 2010
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
Psychological Stepping Stones - Word and Meaning Empowerment
The name of this empowerment has a much deeper significance than the literal understanding of it. It is an empowerment where the student encounters the subject that is none other than herself, through the words spoken to her by her teacher. There is a rich array of symbols, illustrative images and allegory used as a means of self-discovery, and the student is presented these in the form of a question. It is:
'the empowerment that the ecstatic intensity, on this level where the last trace of duality has been dissolved by the progressive intensification of the four lighting up phases in Being's sheer lucency, on it's way to recover and display it's dynamics. Having reached it's final destiny, and firmly occupied in it's rightful place, the ecstatic intensity rests in it's envelope of precious spontaneous thereness, in it's own bed.'
Guenther, p69.
I sort of smile at this point. This is all we are given, regarding this empowerment.
As a conclusion though, it is noted by Gunther that there is an internal logic to the four empowerments, such that each one deconstructs the traps built into a person's cybernetic existence, and aids the person in seeing the world anew, rather than seeing what she usually sees in a confirmatory manner.
As noted by Klongschen rab'byamspa:
'If a person who is so fortunate as to embark on these empowerments as steps in his mental-spiritual growth does not, right at the beginning, on the level of exteriority, cut off the conceptual-propositional thought patterns, the fictions concerning the phenomenal, and the cognitive operation will not be stopped in their proliferations; if, on the level of his interiority, he does not gather them up into the non-conceptual-nonpropositional dimension of thought, his psychic potential will not set out on it's path of enhanced integration and intensified awareness; if, on the level of the arcane dimension, he does not cut off all that went before but what is still more nonconceptual and nonpropositional, the lamps will not come up to be the path; and if, on the level of unsurpassable reality, he does not encounter Being's beingness in himself by what is utterly nonconceptual-nonpropositional, his visionary path will not be bright.'
Part of what I love about this Dzogchen material is that I get to make up half the meanings thus attributed to the descriptive words. Alive in spontaneous Being-ness, with question marks after the meaning-ness. :)
Guenther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.
'the empowerment that the ecstatic intensity, on this level where the last trace of duality has been dissolved by the progressive intensification of the four lighting up phases in Being's sheer lucency, on it's way to recover and display it's dynamics. Having reached it's final destiny, and firmly occupied in it's rightful place, the ecstatic intensity rests in it's envelope of precious spontaneous thereness, in it's own bed.'
Guenther, p69.
I sort of smile at this point. This is all we are given, regarding this empowerment.
As a conclusion though, it is noted by Gunther that there is an internal logic to the four empowerments, such that each one deconstructs the traps built into a person's cybernetic existence, and aids the person in seeing the world anew, rather than seeing what she usually sees in a confirmatory manner.
As noted by Klongschen rab'byamspa:
'If a person who is so fortunate as to embark on these empowerments as steps in his mental-spiritual growth does not, right at the beginning, on the level of exteriority, cut off the conceptual-propositional thought patterns, the fictions concerning the phenomenal, and the cognitive operation will not be stopped in their proliferations; if, on the level of his interiority, he does not gather them up into the non-conceptual-nonpropositional dimension of thought, his psychic potential will not set out on it's path of enhanced integration and intensified awareness; if, on the level of the arcane dimension, he does not cut off all that went before but what is still more nonconceptual and nonpropositional, the lamps will not come up to be the path; and if, on the level of unsurpassable reality, he does not encounter Being's beingness in himself by what is utterly nonconceptual-nonpropositional, his visionary path will not be bright.'
Part of what I love about this Dzogchen material is that I get to make up half the meanings thus attributed to the descriptive words. Alive in spontaneous Being-ness, with question marks after the meaning-ness. :)
Guenther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.
Saturday, August 7, 2010
The Body at Death
There are two ways that the body can disappear at the time of death: The Body of Illusion and the rainbow body. For the Body of Illusion, luminosity and prana are united in ye shes (wisdom), and while the being is still in the defiled karmic body, this body can perform many kinds of miracles for the good of others. Finally at the moment of death the subtle prana of wisdom joins again with luminosity, and the vajra body is achieved.
At this point, the karmic body, made of gross elements, disappears and the corpse disappears into what might be called 'cosmic particles'. The rainbow body, on the other hand, is accomplished by the means of the 'great transference'.
The practices of trekcho followed by thogyal, precede this transference. At the fourth and ultimate stage of thogyal, the substance of the body, which is a combination of the elements, is refined and transferred into the subtle form of these elements, which is luminous coloured light. Only the hair and fingernails, which are the impurities of the body, remain behind. However, the person does not actually die, but transfers into a body of light, or rainbow form. This body is active and can only be seen by those with clarity of vision.
- adapted from pg 210, Notes, 'Women of Wisdom' by Tsultrim Allione.
I have been reading Western accounts of the choices and final acts that we take and make, or are given, in a 'good' death. I'm deeply drawn to working with age and death, with our human experience as we encounter both inevitabilities, with the ways that suffering can be alleviated, perhaps somewhat dispelled, through care.
Persistently, in the Vajrayana tradition, I am encouraged to look deeply into the luminosity and suchness, that permeates, even here, at death. I encounter my own death, the decay of the body, I learn to play a part of release, anicca anatta, dukkha, here in every moment and projected, into that one time, too. I learn the means by which palliative care may be extended to others - with a little polemic raised by those nearby to me lately about the word, I hesitate to use it, but compassion, in informed action, applies here, as nowhere.
My imagination has returned to life, in a way, by virtue of this book 'Women of Wisdom' by Lama Tsultrim - the Kagyu school of which she is a more than able teacher speaks to the part of my heart that makes my decisions grounded on dreams, visions, and the space of dharmas.
Even in death, even in death.
At this point, the karmic body, made of gross elements, disappears and the corpse disappears into what might be called 'cosmic particles'. The rainbow body, on the other hand, is accomplished by the means of the 'great transference'.
The practices of trekcho followed by thogyal, precede this transference. At the fourth and ultimate stage of thogyal, the substance of the body, which is a combination of the elements, is refined and transferred into the subtle form of these elements, which is luminous coloured light. Only the hair and fingernails, which are the impurities of the body, remain behind. However, the person does not actually die, but transfers into a body of light, or rainbow form. This body is active and can only be seen by those with clarity of vision.
- adapted from pg 210, Notes, 'Women of Wisdom' by Tsultrim Allione.
I have been reading Western accounts of the choices and final acts that we take and make, or are given, in a 'good' death. I'm deeply drawn to working with age and death, with our human experience as we encounter both inevitabilities, with the ways that suffering can be alleviated, perhaps somewhat dispelled, through care.
Persistently, in the Vajrayana tradition, I am encouraged to look deeply into the luminosity and suchness, that permeates, even here, at death. I encounter my own death, the decay of the body, I learn to play a part of release, anicca anatta, dukkha, here in every moment and projected, into that one time, too. I learn the means by which palliative care may be extended to others - with a little polemic raised by those nearby to me lately about the word, I hesitate to use it, but compassion, in informed action, applies here, as nowhere.
My imagination has returned to life, in a way, by virtue of this book 'Women of Wisdom' by Lama Tsultrim - the Kagyu school of which she is a more than able teacher speaks to the part of my heart that makes my decisions grounded on dreams, visions, and the space of dharmas.
Even in death, even in death.
Sunday, August 1, 2010
The Sign and the Symbol
An incredibly beautiful photo of Julia Kristeva graces her book, ‘Desire in Language’. A feminist, literary theorist, turned psychoanalyst, turned philosopher, in this book she reviews literary works and incredible art by Giotto and Bellini, to bring us a semiotic understanding of expression and post-Heideggerian dialectic.
I’ve extracted these paragraphs below from Kristeva’s essay on ‘The Bounded Text’ for a few reasons:
1. She discusses the Western cultural shift between sign and symbol, which, as a 21st century member of an Order grounded on a spirituality birthed within Catharism, there is a historio-geographical link that I think is pertinent to understanding our initiation prayers;
2. There’s a paper by Susanne Cook-Greuter and Beena Sharma that is being presented this weekend at the Integral Theory Conference, called ‘Polarities and Ego Development’. I see a parallel-to-progression in what is charted as culturally historical by Kristeva, of the Mediaeval Period in this chapter, with developments that are available to us in this age, individually in adult development, as proposed by Cook-Greuter and Sharma. Core to understanding each trope (and they’re not from the same fields) is grasping an initiating dualism – an energetic rift, of a sort, birthing distinction, polarity, birthing language. We’re given to turn from symbol to sign, and from sign to nonlinear map, a healing of tensions, which shift to become unbounded from a given, finite hierarchy.
I think, far, far too much.
Inspired by Kristeva’s paragraphs:
‘The second half of the Middle Ages (thirteenth to fifteenth centuries) was a period of transition for European culture: thought based on sign replaced that of symbol. A semiotics of the symbol characterised European society until the thirteenth century, as clearly manifested in this period’s literature and painting. It is, as such, a semiotic practice of cosmogony; these elements (symbols) refer back to one (or several) unrepresentable and unknowable universal transcendences; univocal connections link these transcendences to the units evoking them; the symbol does not resemble the object it symbolises; the two spaces (symbolised and syboliser) are separate and do not communicate.
The symbol assumes the symbolised (universals) as irreducible to the symboliser (it’s markings).
Mythical thought operates within the sphere of the symbol through symbolic units (units of restriction) in relation to the symbolised universals. The symbol’s function, in it’s vertical dimension, is thus one of restriction. The symbol’s function, in it’s horizontal dimension (the articulation of signifying units among themselves) is one of escaping paradox; one could even say that the symbol is horizontally antiparadoxical; within it’s logic, two opposing units are exclusive. The good and the bad are incompatible – as are the raw and the cooked, the honey and the ashes, et cetera. The contradiction, one it appears, immediately demands resolution. It is thus concealed, ‘resolved’ and therefore put aside.
The key to a symbolic semiotic practice is given from the very beginning of a symbolic discourse, the course of a semiotic development is circular since the end is programmed, given in embryo, from the beginning (whose end is the beginning) because the symbol’s function (ideologeme) antedates the symbolic utterance itself. Thus are implied the general characteristics of a symbolic semiotic practice: the quantitative limitation of symbols, their repetition, limitation and general nature.
From the thirteenth to the fifteenth century, the transcendental unity supporting the symbol, it’s otherworldly casing, it’s transmitting focus – was put into question. Until the end of the fifteenth century, theatrical representations of Christ’s life were based on both the canonical and apocryphal Gospels or the Golden legend (I need to look up ‘The Mysteries’ dated c. 1400 published by Achille Jubinal in 1837. Hmm.) By the fifteenth century, scenes devoted to Christs public life – the transcendental foundation evoked by the symbol appeared to capsize. This heralds a new signifying relation, between the real and the concrete. In thirteenth century art, prophets were contrasted with the apostles, whereas by the fifteenth century, the four evangelists were no longer set against the four prophets, but against the four fathers of the Latin Church (Augustine, Jerome, Ambrose, Gregory). The miniature replaced the cathedral, and the serenity of the symbol was replaced by the strained ambivalence of the sign’s connection, which lays claim to a resemblance and identification of the elements it holds together, while first postulating their radical difference. Whence the obsessive insistence on the theme of dialogue between two irreducible but similar elements (dialogue – generator of the pathetic and psychological) in this period of transition. For example, the fourteenth century abounds in dialogues between God and the human soul; the Dialogue of the Crucifix and the Pilgrim as one example. Through this movement the Bible was moralised.
The sign that was thus outlined retained the fundamental characteristic of the symbol – irreducibility of terms, of the referent to the signified, of the signified to the signifier, and of all the units of the signifying structure, itself. The ideologeme of the sign is like that of the symbol – it is dualist, hierarchical and hierarchising. A difference between sign and symbol can be seen horizontally as well as vertically – within vertical function, the sign refers back to entities both of a lesser scope and more concretised than that of the symbol. They are reified universals become objects. Put into a relationship within the structure of a sign, the entity under consideration is transcendentalised and elevated to the level of theological unity. The semiotic practice of the sign assimilates the metaphysics of the symbol and projects it onto the ‘immediately perceptible’. Valorised in this way, the ‘immediately perceptible’ is transformed into an objectivity – [I love this sentence, TN] the reigning law of discourse in the civilisation of the sign.
In horizontal function, the units in a signs semiotic practice are articulated as metonymical concatenation of deviations from the norm, signifying progressive creation of metaphor. Oppositional terms, always exclusive, are caught within a network of multiple deviations (surprises in narrative) giving an illusion of open structure, with arbitrary ending.
Art is thus programmed by a closed, dyadic process, whereby the referent-signified-signifier hierarchy is instituted and the oppositional dyads are interiorised. The articulation of the terms resolves the contradiction.‘
Kristeva, J. (1941) Desire in Language. New York: Columbia University Press
Saturday, July 31, 2010
Phenomenology via Kupers per Merleau Ponty
With Merleau Ponty, per Kupers in the paper listed below, phenomenology undergoes a radical return to the body and to embodiment as the basic nexus of human living, where we always already are situated in meaningful inter-relationship.
Merleau-Ponty’s overall ambition was to disclose the roots of rationality and Being, through extending Husserl’s account of the ‘lived body’ to include a body that experiences and is experienced, thus overcoming Cartesian dualism. For Merleau-Ponty, the body is already lived, meaningful, relational and intentional. He not only rejects referentialist-representationalism, following Heidegger, he builds an anti-foundationalist, anti-essentialist, non-reductive ‘open media’ account of embodiment, rearticulating the relationship between subject and object.
Returning to the life-world and things themselves, for Merleau-Ponty, is going back to the way we experience before we begin to theorise. We are embodied as subjects into an inter-subjective and inter-objective continuum, an embedded existence. Interestingly, Kupers proposes that as unruly and unpredictable realities, per Merleau-Ponty, bodies themselves are de-centering, providing a less-than-perfect means of boundary building, for subjectivity.
We learn to move our bodies pre-reflectively, and thus there is a level of intentionality below our explicit acts, manifesting itself in bodily engagement that is our primary rapport with the world.
‘A movement is learned when the body has understood it, that is, when it has incorporated itself into its world, and to move one’s body is to aim at things through it, it is to allow oneself to respond to their call’ (Merleau-Ponty, 1962)
An operative intentionality establishes and utilises secret bonds of correspondence and interdependency, which constitute our reciprocal involvements. The interaction thus inferred within an ever-present world frame opens up an orientation to a post-dualistic ontology in Merleau-Ponty’s late works. Seeing the pre-personal, the personal and the interpersonal as chiasmic, intertwined and reversible, we are allowed the possibility of understanding phenomena with greater profundity. The patterns of meaningful being and action exist neither in the mind nor in the external world, they are ‘in-between’, an inter-relationality of individual, social and trans-subjective practices.
‘Within this fleshly being the in-between is as ‘fullness of void’ understood as a creative and fulfilling emptiness.’
It is via this in-between, which is the birth place of intertwined individual identity, that we encounter social and inter-objective knowledge, realities and creative relationships. With this kind of relational ontology, a proto-integral interpretation becomes available, of phenomenology as precipitating a birth into an awareness easily identified as 'Integral'.
Kupers, W. (2009). The Status and Relevance of Phenomenology for Integral Research: Or Why Phenomenology Is More and Different than an ‘Upper Left’ or Zone #1 Affair. Integral Review, 5(1), 51 – 95.
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
The Aim of Attention
'The goal of attention, or shamatha, practice is to become aware of awareness. Awareness is the basis, or what you might call the “support,” of the mind. It is steady and unchanging, like the pole to which the flag of ordinary consciousness is attached. When we recognize and become grounded in awareness of awareness, the “wind” of emotion may still blow. But instead of being carried away by the wind, we turn our attention inward, watching the shifts and changes with the intention of becoming familiar with that aspect of consciousness that recognizes Oh, this is what I’m feeling, this is what I’m thinking. As we do so, a bit of space opens up within us. With practice, that space—which is the mind’s natural clarity—begins to expand and settle. We can begin to watch our thoughts and emotions without necessarily being affected by them quite as powerfully or vividly as we’re used to. We can still feel our feelings, think our thoughts, but slowly our identity shifts from a person who defines him- or herself as lonely, ashamed, frightened, or hobbled by low self-esteem to a person who can look at loneliness, shame, and low self-esteem as movements of the mind.'
-Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche, The Aim of Attention (Summer 2009)
The whole article was really worth it's easy reading....
Tuesday, July 20, 2010
Psychological Stepping Stones - Knowledge Through Appreciation Empowerment
This empowerment aims at assisting the student to feelingly envision, and envision feelingly, the dynamics of Being as the masculine-feminine ‘polarity’, as occuring in their rapturous lovemaking. She is given to understand the varying degrees of delight as they are blended within the body, as a multi-levelled system. The vision occurs between between rapture in ecstatic intensity, and the everyday-'I', and the idea is to give a tangible sensuous form through the vision, where the masculine and feminine address and disclose to each other their embodied sexuality:
‘Being’s coming to presence and being interpreted as world is the reification of it’s being in a supramundane world, where bliss reigns supreme, and in it
Being’s amorously frolicking pristine awareness triumphs as bliss supreme.
By engaging n the passionate desire between ‘activity’ and ‘appreciation’ emancipation is won; therefore you too
Engage and participate in this ceaseless amorous frolicking!
Therein lies bliss supreme.’
Both Being’s coming-to-presence and interpretation as an environing world and it’s organismic life forms in it’s totality, since time before time, are understood to have endured in what is it’s linear transformation of deiform energies, that presences itself in men and women. Their bonding in ‘activity' and 'appreciation’ expresses itself in bliss. By this bliss do we come to know the superthought-intentionality of the Victorious One (one’s own ecstatic intensity, identifiable as bliss supreme).
There is a symmetry break that marks Being’s open state coming-to-presence and actual radiant closed state, the envelope into which Being wraps itself as itself, it’s ‘ownmostness’. Because of it’s dynamics inherited from the virtual state, a further bifurcation takes place, into the realm of gods and goddesses. Any symmetry break implies an increase in complexity that carries with it the challenge to ‘get to the source or origin of it’. The feminine here plays a vital role (and here I had been trying to steer clear of feminist discourse, huh).
In her capacity of expressing and Being the expression of Being’s openness/nothingness, a spaciousness and a mystery, she is able to open up the unformed with it’s immense wealth of open possibilities or to offer value perception or appreciative awareness that is active as an inspiration and is revered in its role as ‘heroine’. The rousing of masculine activity in response, that is made to express itself in the four dynamic regimes of psychic energy interchange results in self-transcendence, in bliss supreme. Bliss supreme goes beyond the four postulates of existence and nonexistence, eternalism and nihilism, and thus is known as four delights (I love this!)
Through this empowerment the student is made to move not simply from one aspect ‘appreciative’ to another one ‘pristine awareness’ as if one was higher, but they learn to live, harmoniously, with both at the same time.
Perhaps showing either his own stripes or the stripes of the tradition he describes, Gunther here has identified ‘women’ (actually – I’ve interposed the term 'feminine' and stripped out the comment that is sort of chauvinistic) approximately as sex objects. In some way this is meant to be reconciled by a quote that he gives from the Klong-gsal (a Dzogchen text) which, is actually a quote I need to apply to my own self, objectified:
Despising a woman is tantamount to denigrating Being’s spaciousness, and
Withdrawing yourself from pleasure you court the deepest hell.
With what value, and how deep goes, a commitment, to the self?
Gunther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)