Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Allowing the Moment to Sing

'Language, on the other hand, has a specificity that no other system based on differences possesses: it divides (signifier/signified) and joins (modifier/modified = sentence); it is sign-communicating-sociality, "musicating" this dividing-joining movement involves exploding rhythm into division, of course, but also into juncture: into the metaphoric-metonymic slippage that corrugates lexemic items and lifts even the signifier/signified censorship; but especially, into the juncture of logic and sentence where socio-symbolic order is rebuilt and ignores anything to do with the previous, underlying (semic, morphemic, phonic, instinctual) explosion. Intervening at the level where syntactic order renders opaque the outlay underlying the signifying practice; intervening at the point where sociality constitutes itself by killing, by throttling the outlay that keeps it alive - that means intervening precisely when the sentence pulls itself together and stops. The problem is to raise and transform this very moment, to allow it to sing'. (p 168)

'Networks of alliteration establish trans-sentence paths that are superimposed over the linear sequence of clauses and introduce into the logical-syntactic memory of the text a phonic-instinctual memory. They set up associative chains that crisscross the text from the beginning to end in every direction'. (p 169)



Ref:

Kristeva, J. (1941). Desire in language. New York: Columbia University Press.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Natural Therapy

There are some books that, once I invest in the words, and engage in the text, deeply, I end up in dialogue with the book, with my whole body. These are goosebump books. There's goosebumps, there's back of the neck hackle-raises, there's realising that I'm holding the book like the book has become part of my body - where it ends, and I begin, whither I know not, as I sail through pedestrian crossing, through parkland, into the cafe where I don't have to look up, to place my order. I do not have the book, the book has me, I'm completely in it's thrall. The world becomes vivified, deeply, through the lens of these words, this hardcover.

Thus it is for Robert Kegan's "The Evolving Self: Problem and Process in Human Development". I am enamored with this book. I think it's last chapter should be required reading for every psychotherapist, every psychology undergraduate.

This is an extract that explores the nature of the 'holding environment', or 'culture of embeddedness' relevant to the different psychosocial development stages, for those that Kegan deigns as 'evolutionary guests' (I love this re-frame of the psychology office client). It's worth reading for the call that it places, to psychologists, to take an active role in attending to the presence of these cultures outside of the practice, if not leading the way, in establishing deeper social engagement with them, at a community level. These cultures are the basis for what he calls 'psychological amniocentesis', or, more simply, 'natural therapy'.


'Does the mothering culture attend to the newborn; does it provide a warm, close, comforting physical presence, does it accept the infant's utter dependence upon and merger with it? And does the mothering context, at the appropriate time, recognise and promote the toddler's emergence from this embeddedness; does it resist trying to meet the child's every need; does it stop nursing and reduce carrying; does it acknowledge the child's displays of independence and willful refusal; can it tolerate becoming 'other' to the child? And does it remain in some way that permits the child to recover it as other; does it avoid prolonged separation or psychological abandonment during the period of transition?

Does the parenting culture acknowledge and nurture the child's capacity for fantasy; does it accept the child's intense attachments and rivalries within  the family, can it accept the child's psychological dependence on, and merger with, the interior workings of the parents. Does the parenting context, at the appropriate time, recognise and promote the child's emergence from embeddedness; does it begin to hold the child responsible for her behaviours; locate and designate the source of the child's thoughts and feelings in the child; does it exclude the child from the inner workings of the marriage, from the marriage bed, from the home during school hours; does it acknowledge the child's displays of self-sufficiency and self-possessedness; can it tolerate becoming 'other' to the child? And does it remain in some way that permits the child to recover it as other; does it avoid falling apart at just that time as the child is differentiating from it?

Does the role-recognising culture support and acknowledge the child's tests and exercises of self-sufficiency, competence, and role differentiation; does the family or school give the child and opportunity to speak and be listened to in the public life of that institution, especially in it's decisions; is there an opportunity for personal responsibility, definition, control? Does the family or school seek to discover and support at least one involvement in which the child might have a continuing opportunity for successful self-display? Can it tolerate the child's confusion of it with the maintenance of the child's competence, the prosecution of the child's own needs? And does the culture recognise and promote the adolescent's emergence from embeddedness; does it contradict the validity or acceptability of a self-sufficiency that will not take others into account; does it insist that the adolescent hold up her end in trusts and agreements; does it look for the report of interior states rather than exterior dispositions, can it accept becoming relativised on behalf of a new identity and a new identification? And does the role-recognising culture remain in some way that permits the growing person not only to repudiate it, but to recover it?

Does the culture of mutuality acknowledge and support the person's capacity for collaborative, self-sacrificing, closely attuned, idealised interpersonal relationships? Does it share the person's internal subjective states, moods, feelings, innermost thoughts? Can it tolerate the person's confusion of it with herself? Does it recognise and promote the person's emergence from embeddedness in interpersonalism; does it resist being fused with, insist on recognising the person as distinct while still acknowledging the possibility and value of closeness; does it require the person to assume responsibility for her own initiatives and preferences, for her own psychological self-definition; and can it permit itself to be relativised on behalf of this emerging personal authority? Are  there at least some interpersonal partners who remain during the process of transition to take some role in the new psychological landscape?

Doe the culture of self-authorship acknowledge and support the person's exercises of psychological self-definition; does it confirm the person's gathering sense of herself as the origin of her meanings and purposes; does it recognise her as a player in a public arena in which she can exercise her personal powers, need for achievement and self-enhancement; does it give him work that allows him to exercise influence, wield power, assume responsibility; does it offer the opportunity for loyalty to, and investment in, some system of belief; can it accept the person's identification of its shared meaning with himself or herself?  Does it recognise and promote the person's emergence from embeddedness in independent self-definiton; does it insist on some relationship to the person who is running the psychic administration, refusing to accept mediated, nonintimate, form-subordinated relationships? Does the culture of ideology allow itself to be relativised on behalf of the bigger context which roots and co-regulates forms, systems, organisations? And do the ideological supports remain at the very time the person is separating from this identification with them?

And does the culture of intimacy acknowledge and support the exercise of interdependence (even interdependent self-definition), the surrender of (and play with) the form bound autonomous self, the counterpointing of identities?'


 The italics are mostly mine - it's been interesting to watch my hands, as I've typed this - to watch where I was agitated, where energised, where empassioned. The body, in dialogue.

The ego, to continue to transcend, this in all things, is mine, too. :)

Ref:

Kegan, R. (1982). The Evolving Self. Harvard: University Press.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Rumination

I go back over,
things I could have said differently, ways I could have been, differently, situations I would rather have seen as being, differently.

I go back over,
Six weeks of a sort of half-starved, half-baked madness, all halves, no wholes. Blackness lacking of billow, consuming dark fire from within, here. Movement not dared, nor scream, nor gasp.
A pulse, and a cough.

I go back over,
Six months of an irresolute leaning, into neither grace nor definition, barely human, bared teeth, baring animal. Curled up within, some self sense, there must be some, sleeps tightly, not dressed. A motion mechanical, a movement not engaged, just borne. Pay me not, beautiful lover, I know not from which lens you see, nor the goods which you reap, open mouthed, closed eyed.
Belong not, to me.

I go back over,
Six seasons, not undone by time nor tempest, just bare of self-sense, bare of me. Absorbed in my little square screen of escape, reality harsh-edged and narrow, when I stretch up off the seat, through her portal. Too hard & heavy to pick up, too soft and unmalleable to be bothered, eating.
A tree, and a glimmer.
Too long forgotten.

I go back over,
A life cobbled together out of bare strings of selfhood, of six years, since I lost my family, punishment borne of losing them, for the difference, had it but been. A blank, cold, void, office hours unchecked, black suit and severe hair adorned, no self esteem, no sarcasm, no wit. Death wish, revisited. Breathing less each year, skin more translucent, scrabbling with fingernails against sandstone, for a sense of purpose, give me teaching, give me psychology, give me connection. Six years not unaccompanied by my beloved birth family, but not rested for understanding, for the difference, either.

I wake now as rarely, before, the cold sunlight of dawn slips her appearance under my eyelids, controlled crying unabated, next door.  I pad about in the back garden of her chill welcome, arms wrapped about, sniffing for life again, drawing grass, dirt and weed up, between my toes. Let me breathe. I know not all the means by which circumstance flung me against you, dear morning.  

I suffer under your weight no more.
 Let me breathe.

Monday, October 4, 2010

A subject is hostage - via Levinas

Walking in and sitting down,
And I am stunned that you are here;

Bare cheek catches lamplight, shone from above,
Bare heart caught, watchfulness, of person.

Stretching to infinity, this sense
of Other, in the third, apportioned
in time, in responsibility, in justice.

You do not do, you do not do,
and here I
am,
otherwise,

not me, not this, not you, not mine, not us, not ours,
and yet here,
again,
not over.

'Vulnerability, exposure to outrage, to wounding, passivity more passive than all patience, passivity of the accusative form, trauma of accusation suffered by a hostage to the point of persecution, implicating the identity of the hostage who substitutes himself for others; all this is the self, a defecting or defeat of the ego's identity. And this, pushed to the limit, is sensibility, sensibility as the subjectivity of the subject. It is a substitution for another, one in place of another, expiation'. ~ Levinas, Otherwise than Being

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Psychological Stepping Stones - Word and Meaning Empowerment

The name of this empowerment has a much deeper significance than the literal understanding of it. It is an empowerment where the student encounters the subject that is none other than herself, through the words spoken to her by her teacher. There is a rich array of symbols, illustrative images and allegory used as a means of self-discovery, and the student is presented these in the form of a question. It is:

'the empowerment that the ecstatic intensity, on this level where the last trace of duality has been dissolved by the progressive intensification of the four lighting up phases in Being's sheer lucency, on it's way to recover and display it's dynamics. Having reached it's final destiny, and firmly occupied in it's rightful place, the ecstatic intensity rests in it's envelope of precious spontaneous thereness, in it's own bed.'

Guenther, p69.

I sort of smile at this point. This is all we are given, regarding this empowerment.

As a conclusion though, it is noted by Gunther that there is an internal logic to the four empowerments, such that each one deconstructs the traps built into a person's cybernetic existence, and aids the person in seeing the world anew, rather than seeing what she usually sees in a confirmatory manner.

As noted by Klongschen rab'byamspa:

'If a person who is so fortunate as to embark on these empowerments as steps in his mental-spiritual growth does not, right at the beginning, on the level of exteriority, cut off the conceptual-propositional thought patterns, the fictions concerning the phenomenal, and the cognitive operation will not be stopped in their proliferations; if, on the level of his interiority, he does not gather them up into the non-conceptual-nonpropositional dimension of thought, his psychic potential will not set out on it's path of enhanced integration and intensified awareness; if, on the level of the arcane dimension, he does not cut off all that went before but what is still more nonconceptual and nonpropositional, the lamps will not come up to be the path; and if, on the level of unsurpassable reality, he does not encounter Being's beingness in himself by what is utterly nonconceptual-nonpropositional, his visionary path will not be bright.'

Part of what I love about this Dzogchen material is that I get to make up half the meanings thus attributed to the descriptive words. Alive in spontaneous Being-ness, with question marks after the meaning-ness. :)

Guenther, H. (2005). Meditation Differently. India: Shri Jainendra Press.

Saturday, August 7, 2010

The Body at Death

There are two ways that the body can disappear at the time of death: The Body of Illusion and the rainbow body. For the Body of Illusion, luminosity and prana are united in ye shes (wisdom), and while the being is still in the defiled karmic body, this body can perform many kinds of miracles for the good of others. Finally at the moment of death the subtle prana of wisdom joins again with luminosity, and the vajra body is achieved.

At this point, the karmic body, made of gross elements, disappears and the corpse disappears into what might be called 'cosmic particles'. The rainbow body, on the other hand, is accomplished by the means of the 'great transference'.

The practices of trekcho followed by thogyal, precede this transference. At the fourth and ultimate stage of thogyal, the substance of the body, which is a combination of the elements, is refined and transferred into the subtle form of these elements, which is luminous coloured light. Only the hair and fingernails, which are the impurities of the body, remain behind. However, the person does not actually die, but transfers into a body of light, or rainbow form. This body is active and can only be seen by those with clarity of vision.

- adapted from pg 210, Notes, 'Women of Wisdom' by Tsultrim Allione.

I have been reading Western accounts of the choices and final acts that we take and make, or are given, in a 'good' death. I'm deeply drawn to working with age and death, with our human experience as we encounter both inevitabilities, with the ways that suffering can be alleviated, perhaps somewhat dispelled, through care.
Persistently, in the Vajrayana tradition, I am encouraged to look deeply into the luminosity and suchness, that permeates, even here, at death. I encounter my own death, the decay of the body, I learn to play a part of release, anicca anatta, dukkha, here in every moment and projected, into that one time, too. I learn the means by which palliative care may be extended to others - with a little polemic raised by those nearby to me lately about the word, I hesitate to use it, but compassion, in informed action, applies here, as nowhere.

My imagination has returned to life, in a way, by virtue of this book 'Women of Wisdom' by Lama Tsultrim - the Kagyu school of which she is a more than able teacher speaks to the part of my heart that makes my decisions grounded on dreams, visions, and the space of dharmas.

Even in death, even in death.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

The Sign and the Symbol

An incredibly beautiful photo of Julia Kristeva graces her book, ‘Desire in Language’. A feminist, literary theorist, turned psychoanalyst, turned philosopher, in this book she reviews literary works and incredible art by Giotto and Bellini, to bring us a semiotic understanding of expression and post-Heideggerian dialectic.

I’ve extracted these paragraphs below from Kristeva’s essay on ‘The Bounded Text’ for a few reasons:

1.  She discusses the Western cultural shift between sign and symbol, which, as a 21st century member of an Order grounded on a spirituality birthed within Catharism, there is a historio-geographical link that I think is pertinent to understanding our initiation prayers;

2. There’s a paper by Susanne Cook-Greuter and Beena Sharma that is being presented this weekend at the Integral Theory Conference, called ‘Polarities and Ego Development’. I see a parallel-to-progression in what is charted as culturally historical by Kristeva, of the Mediaeval Period in this chapter, with developments that are available to us in this age, individually in adult development, as proposed by Cook-Greuter and Sharma. Core to understanding each trope (and they’re not from the same fields) is grasping an initiating dualism – an energetic rift, of a sort, birthing distinction, polarity, birthing language. We’re given to turn from symbol to sign, and from sign to nonlinear map, a healing of tensions, which shift to become unbounded from a given, finite hierarchy.

I think, far, far too much.

Inspired by Kristeva’s paragraphs: 

‘The second half of the Middle Ages (thirteenth to fifteenth centuries) was a period of transition for European culture: thought based on sign replaced that of symbol. A semiotics of the symbol characterised European society until the thirteenth century, as clearly manifested in this period’s literature and painting. It is, as such, a semiotic practice of cosmogony; these elements (symbols) refer back to one (or several) unrepresentable and unknowable universal transcendences; univocal connections link these transcendences to the units evoking them; the symbol does not resemble the object it symbolises; the two spaces (symbolised and syboliser) are separate and do not communicate.

The symbol assumes the symbolised (universals) as irreducible to the symboliser (it’s markings).
Mythical thought operates within the sphere of the symbol through symbolic units (units of restriction) in relation to the symbolised universals. The symbol’s function, in it’s vertical dimension, is thus one of restriction. The symbol’s function, in it’s horizontal dimension (the articulation of signifying units among themselves) is one of escaping paradox; one could even say that the symbol is horizontally antiparadoxical; within it’s logic, two opposing units are exclusive. The good and the bad are incompatible – as are the raw and the cooked, the honey and the ashes, et cetera. The contradiction, one it appears, immediately demands resolution. It is thus concealed, ‘resolved’ and therefore put aside.

The key to a symbolic semiotic practice is given from the very beginning of a symbolic discourse, the course of a semiotic development is circular since the end is programmed, given in embryo, from the beginning (whose end is the beginning) because the symbol’s function (ideologeme) antedates the symbolic utterance itself. Thus are implied the general characteristics of a symbolic semiotic practice: the quantitative limitation of symbols, their repetition, limitation and general nature.

From the thirteenth to the fifteenth century, the transcendental unity supporting the symbol, it’s otherworldly casing, it’s transmitting focus – was put into question. Until the end of the fifteenth century, theatrical representations of Christ’s life were based on both the canonical and apocryphal Gospels or the Golden legend (I need to look up ‘The Mysteries’ dated c. 1400 published by Achille Jubinal in 1837. Hmm.) By the fifteenth century, scenes devoted to Christs public life – the transcendental foundation evoked by the symbol appeared to capsize. This heralds a new signifying relation, between the real and the concrete. In thirteenth century art, prophets were contrasted with the apostles, whereas by the fifteenth century, the four evangelists were no longer set against the four prophets, but against the four fathers of the Latin Church (Augustine, Jerome, Ambrose, Gregory). The miniature replaced the cathedral, and the serenity of the symbol was replaced by the strained ambivalence of the sign’s connection, which lays claim to a resemblance and identification of the elements it holds together, while first postulating their radical difference. Whence the obsessive insistence on the theme of dialogue between two irreducible but similar elements (dialogue – generator of the pathetic and psychological) in this period of transition. For example, the fourteenth century abounds in dialogues between God and the human soul; the Dialogue of the Crucifix and the Pilgrim as one example. Through this movement the Bible was moralised.

The sign that was thus outlined retained the fundamental characteristic of the symbol – irreducibility of terms, of the referent to the signified, of the signified to the signifier, and of all the units of the signifying structure, itself. The ideologeme of the sign is like that of the symbol – it is dualist, hierarchical and hierarchising. A difference between sign and symbol can be seen horizontally as well as vertically – within vertical function, the sign refers back to entities both of a lesser scope and more concretised than that of the symbol. They are reified universals become objects. Put into a relationship within the structure of a sign, the entity under consideration is transcendentalised and elevated to the level of theological unity. The semiotic practice of the sign assimilates the metaphysics of the symbol and projects it onto the ‘immediately perceptible’. Valorised in this way, the ‘immediately perceptible’ is transformed into an objectivity – [I love this sentence, TN] the reigning law of discourse in the civilisation of the sign.

In horizontal function, the units in a signs semiotic practice are articulated as metonymical concatenation of deviations from the norm, signifying progressive creation of metaphor. Oppositional terms, always exclusive, are caught within a network of multiple deviations (surprises in narrative) giving an illusion of open structure, with arbitrary ending.

Art is thus programmed by a closed, dyadic process, whereby the referent-signified-signifier hierarchy is instituted and the oppositional dyads are interiorised. The articulation of the terms resolves the contradiction.‘

Kristeva, J. (1941) Desire in Language. New York: Columbia University Press