Monday, February 28, 2011

Transtradition Criticism - April DeConick


April DeConick has a blog called 'The Forbidden Gospels', which is thoroughly worth visiting, not only to pay respects, shall we say, for the wisdom and insight that she brings to apocryphal scripture, but also for her deep appreciation for the knotty postmodern legacy encountered in the fields of the humanities (I'm right in her target audience, here).

Here are her comments as she approaches 'What Science Offers the Humanities: Integrating Body and Culture' (2008) by Edward Slingerland:

'To return to Slingerland. He argues that postmodern theory has swept through the Academy, leaving us suspicious of any truth-claim and with "a conviction that the distinguishing mark of sophisticated scholarship is an ability to engage with a prescribed pantheon of theorists" rather than serious study of primary texts. What was fun at first "has left us with an intellectual hangover" (2008, 1), luxuriating in language for language's sake.

I couldn't agree more. In my opinion, we are stranded in a place of nowhere, immobilized by disembodied discourses, authorless and textless, outside of history. With nothing empirical, with no sameness, we are lost in a jumble of difference. We are left to describe what we see as ours, with no power to interpret beyond this. Even these meager descriptions are left in an ethical vacuum to be siphoned off and co-opted to support nefarious purposes.

The Humanities are dying and we are the ones who are responsible to save them.

The big question is HOW? Slingerland offers a solid solution. He says that we need to get our act together and learn from scientists how human beings operate, particularly as embodied cognitive beings. He demonstrates how humanists operate within outdated models of anthropology, and need to come to terms with the fact that science has discovered fundamental things about the human being. That we need to take embodiment seriously or be doomed to spinning tales inside of tales.

In Slingerland's words: "The fact that these body-minds are, have always been, and will always continue to be part of the world of things effectively short-circuits the epistemological skepticism that permeates postmodern thinking. A nondualistic approach to the person promises no privileged access to eternal, objective truths, but is based upon the belief that commonalities of human embodiment in the world can result in a stable body of shared knowledge, verified (at least provisionally) by proofs based on common perceptual access. By breaching the mind-body divide - by bringing the human mind back into contact with a rich and meaningful world of things - this approach to the humanities starts from an embodied mind that is always in touch with the world, as well as a pragmatic mode of truth or verification that takes the body and the physical world seriously" (2008, 8).'

Read it all in her post:

Check out the book on Amazon:

Monday, February 21, 2011

Prior to anéantissement, separation

Because I read this earlier today, and she nails it.

'For insofar as I ask of Love something for myself on account of love, I will be with myself in the life of the spirit, in the shadow of the sun where one cannot see the subtle images of the drawing power of divine Love and of the divine generation'.

Marguerite Porete ~ The Mirror of Simple Souls.

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Phantasy

'But I want to interpret your midnight dreams, and unmask that phenomenon, your night. And make you admit that I dwell in it as your most fearsome adversity. So that you can finally realise what your greatest ressentiment is. And so that with you I can fight to make the earth my own, and stop allowing myself to be a slave to your nature. And so that you stop wanting to be the only god.' (Irigaray, 1991; cf Nietzsche, 1954)

Ref:
Anderson, P.S. (1998). A Feminist Philosophy of Religion, Massachusetts: Blackwell Publishers.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Anéantissement

'. . . a ravishing expansion of the movement of divine Light is poured into


the Soul and shows to the Will [the rightness of what is . . . in order to

move the Soul] from the place where it is now and ought not to be and

render it back to where it is not, whence it came, there where it ought

to remain. Now the Will sees . . . that it cannot profit unless it departs

from its own will. And thus the Soul parts herself from this will and the

Will parts itself from such a Soul and then renders itself and gives and

goes back to God, there where it was first taken, without retaining anything

of its own. . . .' - Marguerite Porete, Mirror of Simple Souls
 

Friday, December 31, 2010

Wesenmystik - 'mysticism of being'

On June 1, 1310, a woman called Marguerite Porete was burned at the stake in Paris, charged with heresy and refusing to recant her work, 'Le Mirouer des simples ames anientes et qui seulement demourent en vouloir et desir d'amour' (The Mirror of Simple Annihilated Souls and Those Who Remain in Will and Desire of Love). Somewhere, there is a call, in me, repeated, to her spirituality, to her story.

Her story, simply, will not let me go.

This is the first in a series of posts that reflects my utter absorption with, and in, her work - her explication of nient - nothingness - and of a radical, to me somewhat nondual, path, the path of annihilation of the soul, and the self, in love.

I've found a profound article by Patrick Wright, called 'Marguerite Porete's Mirror of Simple Souls and the Subject of Annihilation'. I'm enamoured with this article because it attempts to undo Porete via Lacan and Kristeva, and then reverses the speculum. Postmodernism is thoroughly run through, via the lens of a premodern text, which is reflexively & necessarily explicated, in a postmodern frame. This article has given me hours of material to contemplate:

'Porete's inquisitors branded her a pseudo-mulier ('fake woman') which was also later said of Joan of Arc. The precise meaning of this phrase is ambiguous, but it suggests the importance of gender in the trial, for one may assume the label names an anxiety provoked by a woman who is morethan/less than a woman in the traditional medieval sense. Porete's assertions of innate nobility, her erudition in theological matters, the boldness of her mystical assertions...and her widespread sharing of ideas would have been transgressive even fro a man. But Porete's stance is more unruly, as she is a woman writing in the vernacular, her approval [from clergy - TN] complicating her semi-religious role between ecclesiastical and lay communities. And nowhere is this observed better than by Gilbert of Tournai, a Franciscan, who writes, betraying anxiety over the unclassifiable, 'There are among us women whom we have no idea what to call, ordinary women or nuns, for they live neither in the world nor out of it'.

'...Wesenmystik suggests a resistance to identity. She was not a nun, nor cloistered or attached to a specific house; she shared the beguines' liminal status, but was a solitary, a peripatetic without earthly ties. Moreover, though her book imbibed broader influences, such as courtly lyric and Neoplatonism, it calls for annihilation of the self in order to attain total fusion with God: "It is fitting, says Love, that this Soul be similar to the Godhead, for she is transformed into God". This idea is more grandiose than that of the beguines, who, by and large, strove modestly for imitatio Christi, or the identification with the humanity rather than the divinity of Christ.'

Next post: The dialogic of the decentered subject of postmodernism, and how this can be related to Porete's mirror symbolism.

Yum. :)

Ref:
Wright, P. (2009). 'Marguerite Porete's Mirror of Simple Souls and the Subject of Annihilation'. Mystics Quarterly, 35, 3-4, 63 - 100.

Saturday, December 11, 2010

Raido

He's altered since the spring
I thought you should know
We can get the implications
And these sentiments outgrown 
But nobody needs to worry
On this little red book I am sold
I am a space suit in a heart-shaped continent now 
Equal to Shiva then
I began to prostitute myself
I've turned a rainbow on
To shift back to consequence
I need not understand it

He's altered since I took him
From my museum wall
Fell over on a train
Talking to my sentiments outgrown
I do not harm myself
Over his beauty anymore
It's just a space suit in a heart-shaped continent now
Equal to Jesus when
We all began to prostitute ourselves 
I've turned to Raido
For a shift back to consequence
Who need understand it?

From all other worlds I refuse to withdraw
But I'm clutching, anointing, little boys made of...
Who do I need to tell?
Why do I care who knows?
Who need understand?
I believe I have changed
Who need understand 
The error in my way?

It's always the voices
I choose to ignore
Brazen indifference
Or a peach-coloured squall
No love, it never came
But in great affection
I hold him in a space suit
Equal to Jesus
But he'd rather prostitute himself
I've turned to Raido
You need not understand it
You need not understand 

Andromeda

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Allowing the Moment to Sing

'Language, on the other hand, has a specificity that no other system based on differences possesses: it divides (signifier/signified) and joins (modifier/modified = sentence); it is sign-communicating-sociality, "musicating" this dividing-joining movement involves exploding rhythm into division, of course, but also into juncture: into the metaphoric-metonymic slippage that corrugates lexemic items and lifts even the signifier/signified censorship; but especially, into the juncture of logic and sentence where socio-symbolic order is rebuilt and ignores anything to do with the previous, underlying (semic, morphemic, phonic, instinctual) explosion. Intervening at the level where syntactic order renders opaque the outlay underlying the signifying practice; intervening at the point where sociality constitutes itself by killing, by throttling the outlay that keeps it alive - that means intervening precisely when the sentence pulls itself together and stops. The problem is to raise and transform this very moment, to allow it to sing'. (p 168)

'Networks of alliteration establish trans-sentence paths that are superimposed over the linear sequence of clauses and introduce into the logical-syntactic memory of the text a phonic-instinctual memory. They set up associative chains that crisscross the text from the beginning to end in every direction'. (p 169)



Ref:

Kristeva, J. (1941). Desire in language. New York: Columbia University Press.