Monday, April 6, 2009

Palm Sunday

Image: 'Corella' by Tony Wellington

An unusual trinity.

With fortunate and importunate events happening as they will, I did not get to attend Mass on Palm Sunday.

What I did get a little time to do, was to loaf for a bit in the local park and oggle the corellas. I'm no ornithologist, but in my 34 years I've seen an incredible growth in the variety of native bird species that inhabit Sydney. Possibly this has something to do with urbanisation patterns, and the re-growth of 200 years worth of foliage that we sort of thoughtlessly shredded in colonising this pretty little harbour. We didn't have corellas when I was a kid. We do, now.

Corellas look like cockatoos, but sound like a Nokia 5110 with the volume on 'loud'. There were two in particular that had me entranced. These two were having some sort of dominance stoush - I'm not sure if the wing display and hop-step dance they performed is peculiar to the species, or was developed specifically for the purposes of their bird-argument, but the call and response echo of it intensified as the minutes passed. It looked like these two were going to perform their own imitation of shredding.

A third bird, who had been peacefully rooting up the grasses nearby, flys over and dramatically lands, overwhelming both of my dancers with her (deliberately chosen) swoop. She's not impressed with these two who look like they're about to peck each other's throats out. She walks in little semi-circles to separate them, waits to see that they're not eyeing each other off, then for all intents and purposes, appears to demonstrate the correct behaviour, pecking serenely once again at the ground.

One of the original two, obviously under the impression that she's distracted now, goes again for the jugular of the second, one foot up. She's onto it like flypaper, screeching out an 'I'm NOT impressed!' birdwarning. They eventually get the hint, and take up her example, rooting and chit-chattering peaceably once again.

An unusual trinity.

If I had been to Roman Catholic mass, the readings would have included Mark's Jesus, on the cross, screaming out 'Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani'. (God, god, why have you forsaken me). It's Jesus in his most human moment, appearing momentarily to have lost connection with the trinity, the Holy Spirit that connects him, the Son, to the Father.

If I had made it to Mass at the Parish of St Uriel , I would have listened to the intonation of 'Hekas, Hekas, Este Bebeloi' (far, far from here, be the profane). It's an instruction from the human level made to um, nefarious influences, to take their party vibes somewhere else for a while, divine presence is about to be at hand.

Two forms of implied Trinity, so different, but with such similiar syllable count, described in words. One form of Trinity, separating, but unifying, expressed in the behaviour of corellas. Three trinities, all orthogonal, sure, but united, somehow, on my Palm Sunday.

Saturday, March 28, 2009

Thick Greasy Life

As when old father Nilus gins to swell
With timely pride aboue the Aegyptian vale,
His fattie waues do fertile slime outwell,
And ouerflow each plaine and lowly dale:
But when his later spring gins to auale,
Huge heapes of mudd he leaues, wherein there breed
Ten thousand kindes of creatures, partly male
And partly female of his fruitfull seed;
Such vgly monstrous shapes elswhere may no man reed.

(The Faerie Queene 1.1.21 by Edmund Spenser)

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Religion and the Urge

Pascal Boyer, an anthropologist who studies the transmission of cultural knowledge, points out that it is a common temptation to search for the origin of religion in general human urges, such as the desire to define a moral system or explain natural phenomena.

So here is a list of commonly posited reasons for the origin of religion, and a suggested possible alternative viewpoint:

Do not say..... Religion answers people's metaphysical questions.
But say........... Religious thoughts are activated when people deal with concrete situations (this death, this crop, this birth).


Do not say.....Religion is about a transcendent God.
But say...........Religion is about a variety of agents - ghouls, ghosts, spirits, ancestors, deities that are in direct interaction with people.


Do not say.....Religion allays anxiety.
But say...........It generates as much anxiety as it allays (vengeful ghosts, aggressive gods are as common as protective deities).


Do not say.....Religion was created at time t in history.
But say...........There is no reason to think that the various thoughts we call 'religious' appeared in human culture all at the same time.


Do not say.....Religion explains natural phenomena.
But say...........Most religions actually produce more salient mysteries than explanations of natural phenomena.


Do not say.....Religion explains mental phenomena.
But say...........In places where religion is not called on to explain them, mental phenomena are not intrinsically mystical or supernatural.


Do not say.....Religion is about morality and salvation of the soul.
But say...........Salvation is peculiar to a few doctrines and unheard of in most other religions.


Do not say.....Religion creates social cohesion.
But say...........Religious commitment can be used as a signal of coalitional affiliation, but coalitions create secession just as often as integration.


Do not say.....Religious claims are irrefutable.
But say...........There are many irrefutable statements that no one believes; plausability to certain people is the factor of interest.


Do not say.....Religion is irrational, regressive and superstitious.
But say...........Commitment to imagined agents does not really relax or suspend ordinary mechanisms of belief formation; indeed it can provide important evidence for their functioning (and therefore should be studied attentively).



From: Boyer, Pascal. "Religious thought and behaviour as by-products of brain function", Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7, no. 3 (2003): 119-24

Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Oedipus - Dr. Roger Brooke


On a rainy Saturday night a couple of weeks ago, I was graced with an opportunity via the CG Jung Society of Sydney to listen to a comprehensive talk by Dr. Roger Brooke about how the Oedipus complex features through psychological development in the human life span.

Specifically, Dr. Brooke proposes a widened definition from the typical Freudian interpretation of Oedipus to incorporate the Oedipus complex as a cluster of family relationships from which the gender identity and sexual orientation of a given family member is constituted. Because this is a developmental framework, cultural and linguistic variables are incorporated into an embodied sense of identity, with endless permutations arising in terms of personality and disposition as represented in each individual.

As an archetypal pattern, the speaker proposed that a universal situation of psychic transformation is imbued into the cultural symbolic representations that individuals construct as an interface to the wider world.

(in plain English that means that in my head, as a kid, my Da became a complex combination of Mike Brady, Alan Alda, Heidi's grandpapa and Captain Von Trapp. Someone that I fell in love with, and so, at the grand old age of six, I had to 'oust' Ma, which was doubly as hard as it would be for my brothers to fall in love with Ma and, erm, 'eliminate' Da, because Ma is my primary attachment figure, as much as she is the boys'.)

The core module of this construct is the triad that the child first encounters in the world - Mother, Father, child. The shape of the child's inner life that emerges is attributable to, but not reducible to, the experiences that the child first has with it's primary carers.

What was revelationary for me in this talk was the reminder that the reaction formations and repression activity that is key to understanding the Freudian psychodrama is represented in an extremely limited way in actual interpersonal communication. The Mother/Father/child triad becomes the basis for the fantasy life of the child - so a dreamscape that included patricide, for example, may manifest as a refusal by the child to listen to the father figure.

The revelation was important to me because, courtesy of Integral Life Practice, I've found myself characterisable as a 'shadow-hunter' - that is, in ways almost paranoid, I'm looking for projections that I'm making as I'm speaking or thinking about another precious human being. These shadow projections that I'm searching for typically have a familial orientation, because I firmly believe that nurture, in these terms, accounts for much of what we call personality, and so would have a big role in what I might be construing about somebody else's actions. This talk made me aware that this type of shadow search is identifiably superficial - I might skim the surface of something useful, but ultimately there's a deeper level of engagement that I'll be seeking from other human beings than will be analysable from a conversation over drinks on a Friday night.

Dr. Brooke takes the Oedipus complex, that side of ourselves that thinks that we can triumph over the Father to win the Mother (for he hints that the Electra complex might have as little validity as the field evidence would seem to imply) and proposes that the adult sense of self that we locate through our gender, identity and sexuality, the omnipotence that is implied, are gains born of an immense personal loss. In childhood, this loss is made up of the awareness, for example, that the child can't always have Mother's attention, and so from here the birth of consciousness is initiated. This loss of omnipotence is ritualised in circumcision, and the loss is necessary for an experience of limited, but real authority as is found in the loving embrace, and in the capacity for sexual love.

By comprehending this separation, and by virtue of the taboo of incest, Dr Brooke proposes that instinctual energy is liberated into our cultural life. The renunciation that we undertake of our incest instinct gives us, as adults, a relationship to our own psychic interiority, our own desires. We're forced to be come aware of our desire because of the unavailability of our most significant other.

The Jungian perspective shines through here in the proposition that our creativity is not only inspired by our positioning and role in our original family triad but also by an inner desire, or instinct, to individuate. For example - Freud saw the life of St Francis of Assisi as the life of neurotic compromise. Jung says that the life of St Francis of Assisi represented the highest fulfilment of that one human existence, and would say that the inner drive of St Francis needs to be understood on it's own terms.

Opposites are understood to be integrated into the psyche with the resolution of the incest complex, with personality transformation and a higher state of consciousness enacted in both:

- regression and progression
- action and receptivity
- ego strength and ego sacrifice
- resilience and flexibility.

There were some great portraits of the Mother and Father archetypes as well - the source of non-verbal understanding, the holding and contentment, freedom from critique and open and bounded embrace where all seems possible of the Mother contrasted with the language and symbolic satisfaction through thought and values, and a structured executive function of the Father (doesn't that just whiff a little of the Victorian era).

Discussion time brought out the Oedipus complex of omnipotence into present day examples, where chronic feelings of inadequacy, the narcissism of wealth and the inability of the younger generation to respond to authority figures were all broadlined as possible Oedipal manifestations.

I haven't even half covered the depth of the talk , but Dr. Brooke has left me with a deepened sense of how Oedipus appears in my own life, and has prompted an exploration of my own reaction formations and subceptions, a new depth in my old 'shadow'.

Jung and Phenomenology by Dr. Roger Brooke indeed seems worth a read.

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Montsegur Day

On the 16th March 1244, approximately 220 Cathars and their defenders were marched out of their stronghold, Montsegur Castle, were gathered into a nearby field, and were burned by the Catholic Crusaders.

The act, akin perhaps to an idea of 13th century terrorism, puts some context around the words of the Collect for today, from the Ecclesia Gnostica Lectionary:

Remember them, O Lord in Thy kingdom. The faithful who did not adore the Beast and whom the Beast has slain. The faithful who served Thee because they could do no other, who lived in an age when the right to seek Thee was bought with their lives. Remember those who gave more than they could, more indeed than they possessed; more then they ever should have given. They could do no other. Mercy, Lord on all the burned ones of this world. Mercy on all who loved beyond this world. On all who have loved. On all who have had some true thing to love.
Amen.

http://www.gnosis.org/ecclesia/lect124.htm


The Cathars were dualists, and for as much as we can make sense of the scant historical record of their existence, we understand that they saw the world, that arises, exists and passes away as the realm of the Satan, distinct from the realm of spirit, as immutable, unchangeable, that to which we long towards, that to which we will return, the indivisible Godhead.

While there is mitigated and absolute Catharism, the implied dichotomy of darkened world versus the realm of light puts me in mind of John's Gospel and Nicodemus visiting Jesus in the night and learning:

(John 3:6) That which is born of the flesh is flesh: and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit.

http://www.latinvulgate.com/verse.aspx?t=1&b=4&c=3

The principle that Jesus quotes to Nicodemus promises that a renewal of life in adulthood is possible, and in Christianity this is the process of adult Baptism. In Jungian psychotherapy, this is achieved through the process of individuation, by finding the gold that is life purpose and orienting all life energy, all Flow, in harmony with it's course.

As an aside, one other principle that the Cathars held that I've recently read of is that Mary gave birth to Jesus 'adombrad' - neither adding, nor subtracting to his Being, rather providing a pure container, a vessel, a clear environment, in which the Christ could seek nurturance into life.

Allowing the purity of the Light to shine forth,
neither seeking to impose, or influence,
rather,
heeding the Call,
as presented.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Hamartia and Mary Magdalene

This afternoon I was blessed with half an hour with which I was able to scoot on into Gleebooks and sneak some time with 'The Existential Jesus' by John Carroll. The Existential Jesus explores Jesus' life through the Gospel of Mark, based on reading groups that the secular author had run over ten years at the University.

Hamartia means 'missing the mark' - 'a loss of direction'- John Carroll, a sociology professor at La Trobe University, who's virtues I have espoused previously in my entry on 'Ego & Soul' - takes this Greek word for sin and measures it against different characters of the Bible as they turn up in Mark. Perhaps most importantly, he characterises Mark's Jesus as representing the 'I am' - the confluence of different traits in the simplicity of being, that is completely free of ethics and morals (and teachings on ethics and morals, a position which would no doubt rankle with orthodoxy).

In regards to the Magdalene, Carroll portrays the woman with the alabaster jar who anoints Jesus as Mary Magdalene - a scene that is replayed across the four synoptic Gospels.
If I presume for a minute that Mary does occupy this role (the identity of the woman is left uncertain in Mark) the idea that the giving nature of Mary's love, now, in the present, makes reparation for the 'loss of direction' that was evident in her life before, has a lot of appeal as far as I'm concerned.

It points not only to the blessing that can be found in forgiveness, for whatever context that may apply to, it points further, to an inward direction found via the focus of intent that comes with being completely, overwhelmingly besotted in a particular directional gaze. For Mary, that focus was on her Saviour, the Christ. She's one of two people who recognise the transformed Christ at resurrection - regardless of whether she was or wasn't 'The First Disciple', she reads as a character of insight, and depth.

The transcript of Carroll's interview with the ABC (sans any Magdalene content) is here:
http://www.abc.net.au/rn/religionreport/stories/2007/1864844.htm

Sunday, March 8, 2009

A Wake Up Call

For me, the question of how to weigh up the value of one-already-human life against a yet-to-be human life is not an un-knotty problem.

What strikes me here in the article attached to the link below is the hard line drawn against a victim of on-going abuse. And the ex-communication of the girl victim and the doctors, but not the perpetrator.

God, does indeed, from all appearances here, forgive all.

'Vatican defends excommunication for raped nine-year old girl's abortion'


There are strong personal reasons as to why this article grieves me, but if I try to stretch myself beyond this limitation, I still can't see how the Vatican stance portrayed here is even close to OK.

One human life.