Friday, March 19, 2010

Autonomy by Wislawa Szymborska

In danger the holothurian splits itself in two: it offers one self to be devoured by the world and in it's second self escapes.

In the middle of the holothurian's body a chasm opens and it's edges immediately become alien to each other.

On one edge, death, the other, life.

Here despair, there, hope.

To die as much as necessary, without overstepping the bounds.

To grow again from a salvaged remnant.

Here a heavy heart, there non omnis mortar, three little words only, like three little plumes ascending.

Wislawa Szymborska, 1996 Nobel prize winner for literature.

Psalm 42 of the Ordo Missae

P. Introibo ad altare Dei
S Ad Deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.
P. Judica me, Deus, et discerne causam meam de gente non sancta: ab homine iniquo et doloso erue me.
P. I will go to the altar of God.
S. To God, the joy of my youth.
P. Do me justice, O God, and fight my fight against an unholy people, rescue me from the wicked and deceitful man.
S. Quia tu es, Deus, fortitudo mea: quare me repulisti, et quare tristis incedo, dum affligit me inimicus?S. For Thou, O God, art my strength, why hast Thou forsaken me? And why do I go about in sadness, while the enemy harasses me?
P. Emitte lucem tuam et veritatem tuam: ipsa me deduxerunt et adduxerunt in montem sanctum tuum, et in tabernacula tua.P. Send forth Thy light and thy truth: for they have led me and brought me to thy holy hill and Thy dwelling place.
S. Et introibo ad altare Dei: ad Deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.
P. Confitebor tibi in cithara, Deus, Deus meus quare tristis es anima mea, et quare conturbas me?
S. And I will go to the altar of god, to God, the joy of my youth.
P. I shall yet praise Thee upon the harp, O God, my God. Why art thou sad, my soul, and why art thou downcast?
S. Spera in Deo, quoniam adhuc confitebor illi: salutare vultus mei, et Deus meus.S. Trust in God, for I shall yet praise Him, my Savior, and my God.
P. Gloria Patri, et Filio, et Spiritui Sancto.P. Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Spirit.
S. Sicut erat in principo, et nunc, et semper: et in saecula saeculorum. Amen.S. As it was in the beginning is now, and ever shall be, world without end. Amen.
P. Introibo ad altare Dei.
S. Ad Deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.
P. I will go to the altar of God.
S. To God, the joy of my youth.


I made it to the Feria Sung Mass tonight at Lewisham's Maternal Heart chapel - Latin Mass in Lent is a solemn affair - knocks not bells on entry, dour black candlesticks, the Gloria and Alleluia omitted and all mantillas black, yes, please. Tonight's Mass took me through an understanding of the breathless, naked awaiting, in preparation for the coming of the Light, at Easter, an understanding that must be so resonant with Christianity as it is lived consonant with the seasons in the northern hemisphere. There is the symbolic understanding of the 40 days of asceticism, which of course is applicable to all human experience, no matter the continent upon which we rest. The Gospel readings at this time of year describe Christ's performance of miracle upon miracle upon miracle - part of me wonders in a burning painted this brightly, in the followers portrayed in their multitudes, His tireless, ceaseless push onwards, about the meaning that we ascribe to human life, when we are very close to the end of it. If I parallel these stories of Christ that are re-counted in the Bible to the stories that I hear from elderly folk about the important things they have done in their lives - the echoes remain the same. These stories of miracles, casting out the demons of many or saving a fellow nurse on the army fields from gunshot - these times of immense transformation, these seem to be how humans, as we are, define the ever-alterable courses of our lives.

Psalm 42 sat particularly close to my heart, tonight. It's possible to take a very surface reading of this call and response litany between priest and acolyte - going to the 'joy of my youth' through the altar of God in one way paints a very ageist picture pitting the young against old, fully in harmony with how we Westerners value our human lives (she says ever so cynically).

But there is a deeper, more transformative way to read/listen to Psalm 42 as it is recited here. This Psalm sets the scene for what will happen in the Mass - we are graced with a space where we can acknowledge the ways that we have been separated from the Divine - where it might seem to us that the Divine has indeed been siding with our enemy. We ask that the light be sent to us, and we enter upon a place above, the holy hill, to find again the re-newed zest to continue on our own true paths, the zeal that we most recognise in character as having been so present in our youth.

This Psalm invites me into a space where I am questioning the reasons I am sad, or downcast, it invites me to look into my own heart for separation, for distinctions I am making between myself and 'the Other'. May it never be said that I stood in the way, for one moment of my own, or anyone else's introspection. Herein lies the key to wisdom, or one of the many keys, methinks. :)

Thursday, March 11, 2010

A Long Standing Obsession - Two Ways




I've been studying erotic plasticity of the female sex drive - that is, the way that female behaviour might be more sharply shaped by cultural and social cues than male behaviour actually is. I'm not talking about old fashioned submissive and subordinate housewife roles, moreso a predisposition originally grounded in biology, but extended into our distal selves, a predisposition grounded on the notion that the Other comes first.

Distal self might need defining - 'distal self''  is a term coming from a theory called the construal level theory, that says that at any one time we have at least two models of the self active and available in our psyche - the proximal self, the self that is present right now and experiencing through the senses, and a distal self, which contains the experiences of the self through time - our memories, our future projections, and our emotional and imaginal selves live in the distal self.

The line 'You made me a thief of your heart' echoes over and over in my head as I read this literature. Distal self, here you be shaped.

Obsessed with Sinead because she's fiery and beautiful and feminine. Obsessed with connection to the Other, and beset by a world from which the description emerges that this here equates with co-dependence.

I still, still, don't get it.

Obstinate? Ignorant? Pathological? Must be.
Non-clinging
Non-grasping
Non-attachment
Non-aversion
Non-delusion
Non-separation
Non-dissolution
Non-distinction
Non-perception
Non-conditioned.

Friday, March 5, 2010

The Four Tuning-In Phases

Arriving on my front door step from India this summer was a gorgeous lime green and vivid yellow covered secondhand hardback book, costing a measly $8.50, called 'Meditation Differently' by Herbert Guenther. This edition was published just the year before he passed away, being in 2005. It smells of incense and resin.

My recent lacking-in-confidence trait has been to give a paragraph by paragraph summary of the books that I am reading, barely straying from the revered words of the author lest I make the gist of their work too incomprehensible to read, via the filtering through my own mind, and the typing of my (inevitably distracted) fingers.

Guenther is far too dense and terse in style to make that habit possible with this book, really - phonetic-Tibetan is scattered liberally throughout the text, as are his occasionally obscure parallels to Western philosophy. There are some secret never-been-revealed before (I think) teachings on the psychological meaning of empowerment, the snying-thig, the essence of all essences, the Dzogchen approach to reality and two Mahamudra teachings on the Four Tuning-In Phases. It is the last of these I'm looking at today.

This book gives me material to meditate on, as well as meditations to do. I'm sort of enchanted with it. I'll draw out some of the skeletons of his translations of Mahamudra and Dzogchen texts as he has made available here, and we'll see how I go with incorporating at least some of this depth into the lunchtime mindfulness classes at uni.

There's a typical set up to most of these teachings, where there is a short invocation and a long invocation that includes gnosemes (vowel utterances that perform  a function like symbolically indicating the complementarity of the feminine and masculine aspects of Being). This long invocation usually ends linking into the beginning of the teaching.

An apology is nearly always given for the shortcomings of the teacher, right at the very end. I feel right at home. :)

The translation in particular of the Four Tuning-In Phases that I am working with is originally the work of Padma Dkarpo (1527-92).

The text points to the interconnectedness of all things - the warmth of goal realisation in studying this text, the delight arising from it's challenge, the existent and non-existent entities of one's reality, all of these have dependent origination.

The four unpollutable Tuning-In Phases of psychic awakening are:

1) Single pointedness;

The explosion of time-and-space psychic energy, experienced as a ceaseless opening up. Worldly matters matter less.

2) Dissociation from conceptualisation;

Not anticipating spiritual wakefulness or fearing samsara. Not holding onto, nor forcing change in, anything. One feels like a pauper having discovered precious treasure.

3) Single piquancy;

The deeply felt understanding that  the phenomenal 'that which lights up' and the noumenal 'that which is dynamically open, nothing' are indivisible. Subject-object dichotomies have subsided.

4) No-more-model building.

Whatever lights up and whatever has concretely arisen is already, in totality, present. Anxiety is a non-entity here - your experience, right here, now, is the finished model, the only possibility. One stands free of the notion that something has been imaginatively built by an imaginative builder.

The objects of one's experience in this realm do not come-into-existence - there is a sense of an uninterrupted flow of unity.

Being's dynamics are conceptually undivided, ontically without origination, non-dual and not within the scope of representational thought.


The point is to withdraw outwards/inwards, to a stage where thing and no-thing-ness do not obtain to dualism. The interface between quiescence and agitation comes tumbling down, too, sheer joy arises, and a sense of the primordial 'time before time' comes to permeate experience.

We become aware of our 'ec-static intensity' - the sub-moment-to-moment fluctuation between zero intensity and pristine lucidity, and that's lucidity in terms of 'light'.

I could bathe in this for hours. Oh. I think I have :)

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Shadow fragments

I'm working on a presentation for my Psychoanalysis unit, where we are challenged to choose a term from the field of psychoanalysis, and discuss the term as it is relevant to an experience arising within our own lives.

I'm choosing the Jungian term, 'shadow'. Mention of Jung to any of my psychology tutors  has historically had the effect of eliciting some decidedly less than favourable facial expressions, to be honest. The wizard's wily ways just aren't a digestible form of intellectual de rigueur for our Psychology department teachers. It makes sense, really, with the neuroscience and and cognitive psychology orientation that our university is renowned for - neurotransmitters and between-subjects designs are several times twice removed from mandalas and collective unconscious archetypes.

Anyway, I'm gathering here some of the paragraphs from his different books that I've read (and that I have on my bookshelf) that address the phenomenon of shadow.

Until I had sat here, this morning, and perused my bookshelf, I hadn't really cognised precisely how many of Jung's works I have in my possession.

Shadow?

:)

'The unconscious is commonly regarded as a sort of incapsulated fragment of our most personal and intimate life - something like what the Bible calls 'heart' and considers the source of all evil thoughts. In the chambers of the heart dwell the wicked blood-spirits, swift anger and sensual weakness. This is how the unconscious looks when seen from the conscious side. But consciousness appears to be essentially an affair of the cerebrum, which sees everything separately and in isolation, and therefore sees the unconscious in this way too, regarding it outright as my unconscious. Hence it is generally believed that anyone who descends into the unconscious gets into a suffocating atmosphere of egocentric subjectivity, and in this blind alley is exposed to the attack of all the ferocious beasts which the caverns of the psychic world are supposed to harbour.'

'True, whoever looks into the mirror of the water will see first of all his own face. Whoever goes into himself risks a confrontation with himself. The mirror does not flatter, it faithfully shows whatever looks into it; namely, the face we never show to the world because we cover it with the persona, the mask of the actor. But the mirror lies behind the mask and shows the true face.'

'This confrontation is the first test of courage on the inner way, a test sufficient to frighten off most people, for the meeting with ourselves belongs to the more unpleasant things that can be avoided so long as we can project everything negative into the environment. But if we are able to see our own shadow and can bear knowing about it, then at least a small part of the problem has already been solved; we at least have brought up the personal unconscious. The shadow is a living part of the personality and therefore wants to live with it in some form. It cannot be argued out of existence or rationalised into harmlessness.'

Ref:
Jung, C.G. (1959). The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious. 2nd Ed. London: Routledge.


'The archetypes most clearly characterised from the empirical point of view are those which have the most frequent and disturbing influence of the ego. These are the shadow, the anima and the animus. The most accessible of these, and the easiest to experience, is the shadow, for its nature can in large measure be inferred from the contents of the personal unconscious. '

'The shadow is a moral problem that challenges the whole ego-personality, for no one can become conscious of the shadow without considerable moral effort. To become conscious of it involves recognising the dark aspects of personality as present and real. This act is the essential condition for any kind of self-knowledge, and it therefore, as a rule, meets considerable resistance.'

'Closer examination of the dark characteristics - that is, the inferiorities constituting the shadow- reveals that they have an emotional nature, a kind of autonomy, and accordingly, an obsessive, or, better, a possessive, quality.'

'Although, with insight and good will, the shadow can to some extent be assimilated into the conscious personality, experience shows there are certain features which offer the most stubborn resistance to moral control and prove almost impossible to influence. These resistances are usually bound up with projections, which are not recognised as such, and their recognition is a moral achievement beyond the ordinary... No matter how obvious it may be to the neutral observer that it is a matter of projections, there is little hope that the subject will perceive this himself.'

'Let us suppose that a certain individual shows no inclination whatever to recognise his projections. The projection making factor then has a free hand and can realise it's object - if it has one - or bring about some other situation characteristic of its power. As we know, it is not the conscious subject but the unconscious which does the projecting. Hence one meets with projections, one does not make them. The effect of projection is to isolate the subject from his environment, since instead of a real relation to it there is now only an illusory one. Projections change the world into a replica of one's own unknown face. [italics mine]... The resultant sentiment d'incompletude and the still worsening feeling of sterility are in their turn explained by projection as the malevolence of the environment, and by means of this vicious circle the isolation is intensified.'

This paragraph has completely made me re-think the notion of 'shadow' that I had been holding in my mind:

'One might assume that projections like these, which are so very difficult if not impossible to dissolve, would belong in the realm of the shadow - that is, to the negative side of the personality. This assumption becomes untenable after a certain point, because the symbols that then appear no longer refer refer to the same but to the opposite sex...a contrasexual figure... Though the shadow is a motif as well known to mythology as anima and animus, it represents first and foremost the personal unconscious....when it appears as an archetype, one encounters the same difficulties as with anima and animus. In other words, it is quite within the bounds of possibility for a man to recognise the relative evil of his nature, but it is a rare and shattering experience for him to gaze into the face of absolute evil'.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Limen

Limen is a Latin word, it means ‘a threshold’.

‘Foucault’s objection to the inwardly directed gaze rests on the unstated assumption that self-observation is, by it’s very nature, violent. Because le regard is considered intrinsically malevolent, there is no possibility of a non-objectionable split between an observing and an observed part of the self and a form of benign self-exploration. There is no place in Foucault’s thinking for the distinction between the observing ego, motivated by epistemophilic curiosity – the necessary precondition for a psychoanalytic process – and the continuous scrutiny of a sadistic ego. Despite his rebellion against Sartre, Foucault adhere’s to the master’s ‘paranoid ontology of the gaze’. The loving sparkle in the mother’s – or the lover’s – eye has no place in Foucault’s thinking, only the panoptic gaze of the persecutory father’.

In ‘The Whitebook’ – Gutting, G. (1994).‘The Cambridge Companion to Foucault’. 2nd Ed, London: Cambridge University Press, p 320.


This was an intriguing and disturbing paragraph for me to meet in my readings for ‘Philosophy and Psychoanalysis’, this week.

It’s intriguing to read as I walk into a career in the therapy field, and I read Foucault’s damning, violent rejection of bourgeois normality reified in the name of psychic health in psychiatry. His paragraphs speak mostly to me as a rage of anguish, a rage against a society that in no way provided him, himself, with a place to ‘be’, half-ape, half-angel. He dropped his shoulder and heaved at that culture, hard, he pushed it into a post-modernity that has since walked around on tippy-toes, it seems, flittering on the depth to which pluralistic neo-liberalism should meet with a unifying structuralism, something that nurtures. To read Foucault, I’m not left with an impression of an intellect that lightly engages with everything else to preserve itself for it’s one, specialist field of only interest. Oh no. This man, I think, would have burned holes into the back of my head, into the back of anyone’s head, and it’s not with bitterness, it’s a with a penetrating shove. Answer to this.

I need to think about the way that a dualism, an initial split, can possibly be characterised as something other than violent. Sure, a schism is absolutely the onomatopoeia of itself. It is how it sounds. Absolutely, does the sensitive part of my ear hear a whispered roar of damnation in a call to turn and face, to see the dark edges of the self in the mirror. The mirror can be placed by the therapist or by the own-ego - I'm someone with lifelong blurring of boundary-edges, and the question of who owns what and which parts has never been my question of most concern. The means and the method are not skin-bound, in the way that my mind has expressed itself, repeatedly, through time.

So in the same way, completely, do I know that my own introspection will never ever reveal a complete map of the contours of 'me', those that turn up in this world. Knowledge of the precondition of my socially constructed self seems to have become a birthright, in my less-than-elegant, but still Western and tertiary educated, mind. The groove has been laid in the DNA, maybe, while everyone was out getting high in the 70’s.

Personally, this week, this paragraph is a hard to read, hard-edged, hard to digest. I do not want to walk into the dark edges of myself, even via my revered Foucault, into the nasty sharp judgemental bitch that has her cramped cave-space, within. I do not want to think that the liberation-through-healing that I want to add my own life-weight to, through practicing psychotherapy, only has persecution at it’s heart, as it’s intent. I do not see that the dualism torn with the shoulder that breaks it in the first turn, is ever healed, really again, and that’s a cruelly lived experience, for me, now, today.

I do not get to sit, and let it all just ‘be’, either. There’s a place where the rage gets transmuted, where the whole negative, ugly, twilight chaotic buzz is interred, absorbed, and released. I’m on my way there, slowly, and it horrifies me that I’m taking casualities in retrospect, as I walk.

Not perfect and not beautiful, but not implausible, or uncharacteristic, at that.