Viewing the Occupy Wall St phenomena through this lens....
Beginning from the twentieth century acheivement of the Marxist call for a unity of thinking and acting, Badiou works the rigor of procedures for distinguishing truth in a unity of theory and practice, in a modernity where infinite alterity has been secularised, completely.
Badiou's book Being and Event invites the reader into the mathematically thinkable of the void and the infinite - each thinkable, but also outside of a system of representation. The unthinkable starting point of choice, here, is that 'the one is not' and hence 'nothing is' - unthinkable because as complex as an appearance might be, we require existent, something, in order to count it as a phenomena at all.
Being thus can be thought as what no philosophical system can contain - a pure, non-presentable multiple. 'the figure of pure multiple is not, but it does happen', and it happens right at the void of a situation, where the situation cannot account for itself, when someone throws caution to the wind, jumps the breach, declares unaccountability to be the event worth heeding.
Here we have an event, an event that supplements Being - 'it is nothing and everything' - if one is not, nothing is, and yet the nothing, the void is precisely from where the event starts. Yet this is not a completely iterative circle, and the semantic registers of the word 'event' give hint of directionality, guideposts:
- political register - war and revolution register as events, phenomenon outside the boundaries of expectation or legitimacy of some description;
- theological register - apocalypses and miracles, occasions without precedent or mirror, occasions that are singular, sudden and vast,
- aesthetic register - sublime events not pleasing and beautiful, rather disjunctive, disruptive. Terrifying cataracts, art that births awkward epiphany as opposed to pleasant contemplation,
- biographical register - turning points - those most often reported by people in psychological research as defining moments of development - death, marriage breakdown, births where ritual seeks to reintegrate such disruption into the fabric of culture and community,
- academic register - in linguistics, verbs, adverbs and adjectives create an event in not indicating substance but rather happening, having no boundedness, no unity of referent.
Badiou turns to examples - the French Revolution, unanticipated in developmental logic - 'nothing took place but the place' a chance occurrence unique to situation and irreducible to a harsh winter, mob violence, resentment in outburst, or any other linear singular reason. A void in any given ordering of the situation occurred, haphazard appearance.
The other wonderful example is atonal music - from Haydn to Beethoven classical music exploits tonality, eventually, repetitively so. With the inculcation of Schonberg we see atonality birthed outside the tradition of tonality, indifferent to it and ultimately unaffected by its necessity.
Working the philosophy through set theory of mathematics draws forth the observation of generality and universality - set theory founds mathematics on empty sets, no quality, essence or relation in sight. The very location of the multiple and the infinite, the very meaning of being not-one.
Evil is incurred at the indoctrination of a one, the foreclosure announced in that moment. If we commit ourselves to an event, we commit ourselves as subjects, and are subject to good and evil in this way - as proper subjects, we are subject to truth, and if our commitment is false, fidelity to the event becomes an evil in proportion to the closure. Universality becomes a sham.
While an event forces an account for its beginning, it does not have a generic rigor in the void of it's situation - living in truth, and being subject to truth requires an openness to eventuality, an event is an open process of making multiplicity which never closes to complete immanence (divine memory) or ultimate transcendence (timeless beyond).
Set theory also has a beautiful twist - in removing the representationalist aspect of number, sets serve a project of understanding the world as arising from blank 'thatness', a void of meaning, then grouping together multiplicities based on minimal axiom, then branching incredibly quickly into vast uncountable subsets, deriving the instability through which the next event emerges.
Beautiful.
Ref:
J Simons (Ed). (2010) From Agamben to Žižek. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Wednesday, October 19, 2011
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
Synthetic Communities of Practice
Bare bones outline of a new approach to metatheory.
In the field of dynamic encounter, draw into a synthetic community of practice (Wegner, 1998), a body of voices who resonate with a kind of joint attention to/within the field of dynamic encounter. Examples may include folk who actually met in person, like The Metaphysical Club, people who gathered with a common intent, such as the Tel Quel contributors, or even just voices in a common field, such as (as I'm engaging at the moment) social theory.
Then,
calling on the wisdom of Badiou's event (1999) to draw the boundary edges
identify, for the voices:
- ontological pluralism - epistemological distance, methodological variety, ontological pluralism (Hargens, 2010)
- causal layered analysis - poststructuralist analysis of enactment through lens of litany, systemic perspective, worldview or mythology (Inayatullah, 1998)
- tacit assumptions in concepts, understood through an integral cube model of the unconscious (healthy conscious, dynamic subconscious, unhealthy unconscios, inert unconscious) (Ingersoll and Zeitler, 2010)
draw together the emergent themes, language, points of distinction, new additions to the field offered, by each contributor in the synthetic community;
look for themes emergent, the growth areas they identify in their own writing, for the field in question;
create a cone of possible futures (Voros, 2003) of probable, preferable, plausible possible and potential futures (these need much more explanation, each has a time arc and a set of principles operating)
use this cone to
disrupt linear process (Mansfield, private communication)
and
birth the implausible.
Generative, no? :)
Must add references.
In the field of dynamic encounter, draw into a synthetic community of practice (Wegner, 1998), a body of voices who resonate with a kind of joint attention to/within the field of dynamic encounter. Examples may include folk who actually met in person, like The Metaphysical Club, people who gathered with a common intent, such as the Tel Quel contributors, or even just voices in a common field, such as (as I'm engaging at the moment) social theory.
Then,
calling on the wisdom of Badiou's event (1999) to draw the boundary edges
identify, for the voices:
- ontological pluralism - epistemological distance, methodological variety, ontological pluralism (Hargens, 2010)
- causal layered analysis - poststructuralist analysis of enactment through lens of litany, systemic perspective, worldview or mythology (Inayatullah, 1998)
- tacit assumptions in concepts, understood through an integral cube model of the unconscious (healthy conscious, dynamic subconscious, unhealthy unconscios, inert unconscious) (Ingersoll and Zeitler, 2010)
draw together the emergent themes, language, points of distinction, new additions to the field offered, by each contributor in the synthetic community;
look for themes emergent, the growth areas they identify in their own writing, for the field in question;
create a cone of possible futures (Voros, 2003) of probable, preferable, plausible possible and potential futures (these need much more explanation, each has a time arc and a set of principles operating)
use this cone to
disrupt linear process (Mansfield, private communication)
and
birth the implausible.
Generative, no? :)
Must add references.
Tuesday, October 11, 2011
Language and being
The temporary 'Happy Talk' house, built out of pallets, to welcome expressions of public art at 'Art & About', in Sandringham Gardens, Hyde Park, Sydney.
I'm a part of several online communities. Spanning across my university subjects, and interests including philosophy, spirituality, writing software code, engaging counselling practice and sharing creative writing experience, there are many people I'm graced to meet, online, in a day and a month and a year whom I will never, ever, actually meet in person.
As our online selves are refracted back into embodied life, I've been prompted to reflect a little on how my way of being and speaking have changed, as result of taking part in online community, in online life. The structures of the self, it seems, have never been more flexible, more permeable, than they are in this day and this age - it is almost entirely possible to own a persona that is the complete not-you of you, the antithesis of any identifier which would usually be a place within which your consciousness could be found, nurtured, on any given rainy Saturday afternoon. No longer are the constituencies of my physical being the determinants of my encounter with you - for all you know, reading this right now, I'm a 72 year old Nordish man who has happened into an internet cafe in Singapore by virtue of a missed flight home from Mauritius, looking for a spot of play in a complete figment of his own imagination, an online persona called Trish.
Presuming a little authenticity into the picture, and calling forth a sense that global online community might be a birthplace as worthy as any for that phenomenon we call 'intentional community', I've been reading into the shape of Wegner's Communities of Practice.
There are some useful signifiers that come from a paper on the same, by Fauske and Wade (2003) that delineate ways of being together, online, that are identified as 'generative' - that is, that foster deep and broad conversation, in an online environment.
There are a few different models of action enquiry and action research that are beneficial to encounter, with respect to these topics, as well. But for now, I thought I'd gather together some of the truly wonderful material from the Fauske and Wade paper, that we might engage these thoughts in our own being, in our here amongst, online.
The authors speak about what historically is shaped as gender-characterised discourse, but within their research they found no attribution could be made to male or female participants, rather they acknowledge that computer-mediated community participation and conversation grows when statements are made that are:
Supporting: statements that agree with earlier ones by other folks, and that express appreciation and thanking, acknowledging what others have said;
Perspective Taking: Considering of perspectives offered by other folks, and considering multiple points of view and alternative interpretations offered by others;
Inquiring: asking questions that do not constitute rhetorical devices in arguments.
Self Questioning: Of one's own assumptions, offering alternatives to the group to own point of view, making clear the disclaimers about knowledge or understanding in the field. Openness, hedging and sometimes doubting characterise this perspective.
Challenging: offering counter evidence, occupying a stance of distancing, with clarity as an intent.
Nonsupporting posts would be shaped like this:
Nonsupporting: Mocking, putting others down, isolating group members, aligning other voices against this one.
Posturing: Assuming a pose by lecturing to community members, assuming a type of authority that separates oneself from the others within the group.
Both men and women were reported as attenuating, which is to say that folks would offer suggestions, rather than be directive, and would remain receptive. Personalising responses also functions to enable seeing-in, to the connections and distinctions offered between communications.
Importantly, through engaging such practices, the researchers found that the democratic environment enabled by computer mediated community could be most resourced, where the structure through which the community had been grounded in the beginning, as they came together, could be easily dismantled once there was trust and agreement established amongst the members such that their own journey could be chartered. Roles in the community were radically revised, and subject to agreed revision without disharmony, and with maximal inclusivity of perspective. Interpersonal connectivity, in an environment seemingly hostile to such a phenomenon, was actually fostered.
Heavenly. :)
Ref:
Fauske, J, & Wade, S.E. (2003). Research to Practice Online: Conditions that Foster Democracy, Community, and Critical Thinking In Computer-Mediated Discussions. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 36(2) 137-153.
Wednesday, October 5, 2011
The moment in the rose-garden
At the still point of the turning world. Neither flesh nor fleshless;
Neither from nor towards; at the still point, there the dance is,
But neither arrest or movement. And do not call it fixity,
Where past and future are gathered. Neither movement from nor towards,
Neither ascent nor decline. Except for the point, the still point,
There would be no dance, and there is only the dance.
I can only say, there we have been: but I cannot say where.
And I cannot say, how long, for that is to place it in time.
The inner freedom from the practical desire,
The release from action and suffering, release from
The inner and outer compulsion, yet surrounded
By a grace of sense, a white light still and moving,
Erhebung without motion, concentration
Without elimination, both a new world
And the old made explicit, understood
In the completion of it's partial ecstasy,
The resolution of it's partial horror.
Yet the enchainment of past and future,
Woven into the weakness of the changing body,
Protects mankind from heaven and damnation
Which flesh cannot endure.
Time past and time future
Allow but a little consciousness.
To be conscious is not to be in time
But only in time can the moment in the rose-garden,
The moment in the arbor where the rain beat
The moment in the draughty church at smokefall
Be remembered; involved with past and future.
Only through time is time conquered.
from: Burnt Norton, TS Eliot
Neither from nor towards; at the still point, there the dance is,
But neither arrest or movement. And do not call it fixity,
Where past and future are gathered. Neither movement from nor towards,
Neither ascent nor decline. Except for the point, the still point,
There would be no dance, and there is only the dance.
I can only say, there we have been: but I cannot say where.
And I cannot say, how long, for that is to place it in time.
The inner freedom from the practical desire,
The release from action and suffering, release from
The inner and outer compulsion, yet surrounded
By a grace of sense, a white light still and moving,
Erhebung without motion, concentration
Without elimination, both a new world
And the old made explicit, understood
In the completion of it's partial ecstasy,
The resolution of it's partial horror.
Yet the enchainment of past and future,
Woven into the weakness of the changing body,
Protects mankind from heaven and damnation
Which flesh cannot endure.
Time past and time future
Allow but a little consciousness.
To be conscious is not to be in time
But only in time can the moment in the rose-garden,
The moment in the arbor where the rain beat
The moment in the draughty church at smokefall
Be remembered; involved with past and future.
Only through time is time conquered.
from: Burnt Norton, TS Eliot
A heart practice for grief
This is a practice that can help when you are suffering from deep sorrow and grief, adapted from a practice given to Sogyal Rinpoche by Jamyang Khyentse and recorded in ‘The Tibetan Book of Living & Dying’.
Described as a practice for people who are going through emotional torment or mental anguish and breakdown, the practice can bring both relief and solace.
1. Invocation
Invoke in the sky in front of you the presence of someone, or some enlightened being, whom inspires you the most, and consider that this being is the embodiment of all sages and worthy teachers. Even if you cannot imagine in your mind's eye any one form, try and find a presence, a sense of an infinite power, compassion, and blessing.
2. Calling Out
Open your heart and call to presence a sense of the pain and suffering you have felt. Hold the sense that the teacher or sage can hold all this suffering with you, can measure and tend to the needs expressed in the pain.
3. Filling the Heart with Bliss
Imagine and know now that the teacher you are crying out to responds, with all his or her love, compassion and wisdom. Imagine a light as nectar, streaming from the teacher, filling your heart up, completely, and transforming all your suffering into bliss.
An example of a sage that Sogyal Rinpoche draws upon is Padmasambhava, simply sitting in meditation posture, wrapped in his gown and robes, exuding an enchanting feeling of warm and cozy comfort, and with a loving smile on his face. In this emanation he is called "Great Bliss." His hands lie relaxed in his lap, cradling a cup made from the top of a skull. It is full of the nectar of Great Bliss, swirling and sparkling, the source of all healing. He sits serenely on a lotus blossom, ringed by a shimmering sphere of light.
Think of him as infinitely warm and loving, a sun of bliss, comfort, peace, and healing. Open your heart, let out all your suffering; cry out for help. Imagine now thousands of rays of light streaming out of his body or from his heart: Imagine that the nectar of Great Bliss in the skull cup in his hands overflows with joy and pours down over you in a continuous stream of soothing, golden liquid light. It flows into your heart, filling it and transforming your suffering into bliss.
4. Helping Those Who Have Died
As you do this practice again and again, filling your heart with bliss, it will be the case that your suffering will dissolve in the confident peace of the nature of your mind. You will realize, with joy and delight, that the sages and teachers are not outside of you but always with you, inseparable from the nature of your mind.
Imagine you are sending this blessing, the light of healing compassion, to your loved one/s who has/have died.
It’s a Buddhist teaching, and the Christian symbol of the ultimate split between life and death with Jesus nailed to a wooden cross, that offers to us a sense of wisdom in suffering – suffering nurtures it’s own teaching, on the nature of compassion, for ourselves, for others. Accepting pain, as it is, hands us a priceless gift: the chance of discovering what lies behind sorrow.
"Grief," Rumi wrote, "can be the garden of compassion."
If you keep your heart open, vulnerable, pain can become an ally in the life search for love and wisdom.
Rilke wrote, the protected heart that is "never exposed to loss, innocent and secure, cannot know tenderness; only the won-back heart can ever be satisfied: free, through all it has given up, to rejoice in its mastery."
I've spent a good part of the day today wrapped in grief, with my friend Gilly, a close friend lost her son in a car accident on the weekend.
He was three years old.
May the divine assistance remain always with him.
Even in death; even in death.
Ref:
Sogyal Rinpoche. (2002). The Tibetan Book of Living and Dying. London: Rider
Sunday, September 25, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

